All subjects · English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose

Poem 17: From the Journal of a Disappointed Man (Andrew Motion)

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose

From the Journal of a Disappointed Man watches a team of workmen fail at a job, and leaves both them and the speaker suspended. Have your clean copy of the anthology open: this lesson describes the poem but does not reproduce it.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Situation and voice

The speaker, writing as if in a journal, watches a crew of strong, silent workmen trying to drive a wooden pile into a pier (LitCharts). The pile hangs over the water from a cable. Something goes wrong; they work at it for over an hour, then give up and leave, with the pile still hanging. The speaker appears to be a writer or thinker who sees himself as separate from the workers; why he is disappointed is never stated.

Form and structure

Language, imagery and themes

Connections and exam use

Worked example

Plan one paragraph comparing frustration in Please Hold and From the Journal of a Disappointed Man.

  1. O'Driscoll: frustration rises to swearing; the speaker cannot get through to a person.
  2. Motion: frustration is silent; the workmen abandon the job and the speaker is left hanging.
  3. Form: O'Driscoll's long first stanza mirrors the endless call; Motion's enjambment and unresolved ending leave things suspended.

Answer: Loud versus silent frustration, both ending without resolution.

Key idea: Journal of a Disappointed Man: workmen fail to drive a pile into a pier and leave; eleven free-verse quatrains, prose-like rhythm, enjambment, no resolution; work, class and masculinity.

Check yourself

  1. What are the workmen trying to do?
    • Cut down pampas grass
    • Drive a wooden pile into a pier
    • Repair a telephone line
    • Build a lifeboat
    Show answer

    Drive a wooden pile into a pier. LitCharts: they try to drive a pile into a pier.

  2. What happens in the end?
    • They finish the job and celebrate
    • The pier collapses
    • The speaker joins in and succeeds
    • They give up and leave, with the pile still hanging
    Show answer

    They give up and leave, with the pile still hanging. The job is left unfinished.

  3. The poem is written in
    • one unbroken stanza
    • eleven four-line stanzas of free verse
    • a villanelle
    • rhyming couplets
    Show answer

    eleven four-line stanzas of free verse. LitCharts: eleven quatrains, free verse.

  4. How does the enjambment connect to the poem's subject?
    • It speeds the poem up like a chase
    • It creates rhyme
    • It leaves words hanging, like the suspended pile
    • It has no connection
    Show answer

    It leaves words hanging, like the suspended pile. Suspended syntax for a suspended pile.

  5. Which second poem made a strong pairing on work in June 2023?
    • Please Hold
    • Genetics
    • Material
    • The Map Woman
    Show answer

    Please Hold. The report praised pairings with Please Hold on the changing nature of work.

  6. Andrew Motion was UK Poet Laureate for
    • one year
    • fifty years
    • ten years
    • never
    Show answer

    ten years. LitCharts: Poet Laureate for a decade.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.