All subjects · English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose
Poem 17: From the Journal of a Disappointed Man (Andrew Motion)
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose
From the Journal of a Disappointed Man watches a team of workmen fail at a job, and leaves both them and the speaker suspended. Have your clean copy of the anthology open: this lesson describes the poem but does not reproduce it.
Situation and voice
The speaker, writing as if in a journal, watches a crew of strong, silent workmen trying to drive a wooden pile into a pier (LitCharts). The pile hangs over the water from a cable. Something goes wrong; they work at it for over an hour, then give up and leave, with the pile still hanging. The speaker appears to be a writer or thinker who sees himself as separate from the workers; why he is disappointed is never stated.
Form and structure
- Eleven four-line stanzas of free verse with no fixed rhyme; lines of roughly nine to thirteen syllables give a prose-like rhythm that suits a journal (LitCharts).
- Enjambment leaves words and images hanging across line breaks, mirroring the suspended pile (LitCharts).
- The poem refuses a satisfying resolution (LitCharts): it stops, unfinished, like the job.
Language, imagery and themes
- The pile swinging over the water: wasted strength and failed support (LitCharts).
- Silence and precise visual detail; hard alliterative sounds suggest the noise of the site (LitCharts).
- Themes: disappointment and failure; labour and class (the speaker first sees the men as brutish, then comes to respect their thought and dignity); masculinity and stoicism (LitCharts).
- Poet: Andrew Motion (born 1952), UK Poet Laureate for ten years, knighted in 2009 (LitCharts).
Connections and exam use
- June 2023: named poem, on work (less popular). Common second poems: Chainsaw Versus the Pampas Grass, Please Hold. Pairing with Please Hold, on the changing nature of work and the frustration it brings, was strong; Out of the Bag gave effective contrasts. Weak answers wrote about masculinity in Chainsaw, or read The Gun as a hunter's work.
- Better second poem for Please Hold (frustration, June 2024).
Worked example
Plan one paragraph comparing frustration in Please Hold and From the Journal of a Disappointed Man.
- O'Driscoll: frustration rises to swearing; the speaker cannot get through to a person.
- Motion: frustration is silent; the workmen abandon the job and the speaker is left hanging.
- Form: O'Driscoll's long first stanza mirrors the endless call; Motion's enjambment and unresolved ending leave things suspended.
Answer: Loud versus silent frustration, both ending without resolution.
Check yourself
- What are the workmen trying to do?
- Cut down pampas grass
- Drive a wooden pile into a pier
- Repair a telephone line
- Build a lifeboat
Show answer
Drive a wooden pile into a pier. LitCharts: they try to drive a pile into a pier.
- What happens in the end?
- They finish the job and celebrate
- The pier collapses
- The speaker joins in and succeeds
- They give up and leave, with the pile still hanging
Show answer
They give up and leave, with the pile still hanging. The job is left unfinished.
- The poem is written in
- one unbroken stanza
- eleven four-line stanzas of free verse
- a villanelle
- rhyming couplets
Show answer
eleven four-line stanzas of free verse. LitCharts: eleven quatrains, free verse.
- How does the enjambment connect to the poem's subject?
- It speeds the poem up like a chase
- It creates rhyme
- It leaves words hanging, like the suspended pile
- It has no connection
Show answer
It leaves words hanging, like the suspended pile. Suspended syntax for a suspended pile.
- Which second poem made a strong pairing on work in June 2023?
- Please Hold
- Genetics
- Material
- The Map Woman
Show answer
Please Hold. The report praised pairings with Please Hold on the changing nature of work.
- Andrew Motion was UK Poet Laureate for
- one year
- fifty years
- ten years
- never
Show answer
ten years. LitCharts: Poet Laureate for a decade.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Literature specification, issue 6, May 2021 (copy hosted by INS World, Singapore; Pearson's own copy is linked from the qualification page)
- Pearson: IAL English Literature Appendix 5, Prescribed Texts, version 1.4 (May 2021)
- LitCharts: From the Journal of a Disappointed Man by Andrew Motion, summary and analysis
- Pearson WET01 examiner report, June 2023
- Pearson WET01 examiner report, June 2024
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.