All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Thomas Carew: An Eddy, To a Lady that Desired I Would Love Her, and A Song
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Carew was the leading poet of Charles I's court, a Cavalier who learned from both Jonson and Donne. The June 2022 question focused on imagery and symbolism in To My Mistress Sitting by a River's Side; the January 2025 question asked about beauty in A Song ('Ask me no more').
Carew in context
From the Poetry Foundation:
- Courtier of Charles I, sworn gentleman of the privy chamber in 1630; the court's 'poetic arbiter elegantiae'.
- Worked in the Petrarchan tradition but polished its conceits with wit and elegance; this became known as Cavalier verse. The Poetry Foundation names Suckling, Lovelace, Waller and Marvell among the younger poets who dominated the mid-century scene.
- Jonson was his formative influence; Donne shaped his early lyrics; his elegy on Donne calls him 'a King, that rul'd as hee thought fit' over wit.
- Libertine reputation ('A Rapture' was denounced in Parliament); Pope dismissed him as 'a bad Waller'; later critics called him 'a deft and sophisticated master of the lyric'.
A Song ('Ask me no more') and To a Lady
A Song
- Anaphora: each stanza begins 'Ask me no more', listing where beauties of nature go: 'where Jove bestows, / When June is past, the fading rose'; the 'golden atoms of the day'; the nightingale; falling stars; the phoenix.
- The answer each time: they go to the mistress, who contains all beauty; the phoenix 'in your fragrant bosom dies'.
- Hyperbole and compliment in polished Cavalier style; the January 2025 mark scheme lists diction such as 'golden atoms', the nightingale symbol, anaphora and personal address, metrical cadence, Petrarchan influence and an eco-critical reading of England's seasons.
To a Lady that Desired I Would Love Her
- Opening: 'Now you have freely given me leave to love, / What will you do?' The lady has allowed him to love her; the speaker asks how she will respond.
- Argument: she might mock, pity, torment or love him, but ''Tis easy to destroy, you may create'; he refuses to be one of the whining poets who seek fame from their tears, because grief is 'a puddle' that reflects her beauty badly, while joy produces clear, bright praise.
- Tone: witty, frank, negotiating: love as an exchange in which her kindness buys his best verse. The June 2025 mark scheme suggested it as a second poem for a question on longing in Philips's 'Orinda to Lucasia'.
To My Mistress Sitting by a River's Side: An Eddy
- Conceit: the speaker asks his mistress to 'Mark, how yond eddy steals away' from the main stream to play with the banks and then returns; the eddy becomes a figure for her, and he ends 'Be thou this eddy', offering his breast as her shore, in the manner of a Cavalier compliment.
- Water motif (June 2022 mark scheme): simile, metaphor and conceit built around the river's movement; the eddy's return as desire's return.
- Context in the mark scheme: Carew's debt to Jonson, Donne and Marino; Cavalier verse; his libertine life; historicist readings of the coming Civil War; psychoanalytic and gender readings.
- Useful for questions on imagery, nature, desire or the gaze.
Worked example
Compare how beauty is presented in Carew's A Song and Marvell's To His Coy Mistress (the January 2025 pairing).
- Carew: all nature's beauties (the rose, the 'golden atoms', the nightingale, the phoenix) find their home in the mistress; beauty is eternal and gathered into her.
- Marvell: beauty is threatened by time: 'Thy beauty shall no more be found'; it must be enjoyed now.
- Method: Carew's anaphora creates a calm, ceremonial compliment; Marvell's three-part argument builds urgency.
- Context: both are Cavalier-era compliments to a mistress, but Marvell's carpe diem bends the tradition towards mortality.
- AO5: a gender reading sees both women as objects of male praise or persuasion.
Answer: Carew makes his mistress the eternal resting place of every beauty, while Marvell insists beauty is perishable, so one poem celebrates and the other pressures.
Check yourself
- How does the Poetry Foundation describe Carew's role at Charles I's court?
- As its chief preacher
- As its 'poetic arbiter elegantiae'
- As Poet Laureate
- As Latin secretary
Show answer
As its 'poetic arbiter elegantiae'. The arbiter of elegance.
- What device structures A Song ('Ask me no more')?
- Enjambment across all stanzas
- Free verse
- A refrain at the end of each line
- Anaphora: each stanza begins with the same words
Show answer
Anaphora: each stanza begins with the same words. Repetition of the opening phrase.
- Where does the phoenix die in A Song?
- In the sea
- In the mistress's fragrant bosom
- In a church
- In the sun
Show answer
In the mistress's fragrant bosom. Hyperbolic compliment.
- How did Alexander Pope dismiss Carew, according to the Poetry Foundation?
- As 'the first poet in the world'
- As 'the Matchless Orinda'
- As 'a bad Waller'
- As 'the Silurist'
Show answer
As 'a bad Waller'. A comparison with Edmund Waller.
- What motif did the June 2022 mark scheme pick out in To My Mistress Sitting by a River's Side: An Eddy?
- The water motif, developed through simile, metaphor and conceit
- A burning candle
- A ship at sea
- A garden in winter
Show answer
The water motif, developed through simile, metaphor and conceit. Water motif.
- What question does the speaker ask in To a Lady that Desired I Would Love Her?
- Whether she will marry him tomorrow
- Where the rose goes in winter
- What she will do now that she has given him leave to love
- Why the sun rises
Show answer
What she will do now that she has given him leave to love. 'What will you do?'
- What makes Carew a Cavalier poet rather than simply a metaphysical one?
Show answer
He wrote polished, elegant lyrics for Charles I's court, refining Petrarchan compliment with Jonson's clarity and smooth form, using wit more for grace and flattery than for Donne's difficult conceits.. Court, polish, compliment.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Pearson IAL English Literature Appendix 5: prescribed texts, version 1.4 (May 2021): Unit 4 anthologies and prescribed poems
- Poetry Foundation: Thomas Carew
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2022 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 examiner report, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.