All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
George Herbert: Redemption, The Collar, The Pulley and Love (III)
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Herbert's poems from The Temple (1633) dramatise a soul's relationship with God in plain language and ingenious forms. The January 2024 question asked about The Pulley; Herbert pairs well with Donne's religious poems and Vaughan.
Redemption and The Collar
Redemption
- A parable sonnet: 'Having been tenant long to a rich lord', the speaker seeks the lord to ask for a new, cheaper lease. He searches 'great resorts' and finds him at last among 'thieves and murderers'.
- The twist: 'Who straight, Your suit is granted, said, and died.' The lord is Christ; the new lease is the New Covenant, granted through the Crucifixion.
- Methods: allegory, legal and property language, a narrative sonnet whose final line delivers the turn.
The Collar
- Rebellion: 'I struck the board, and cried, No more; / I will abroad!' The speaker complains that his service brings only thorns and lost harvests.
- Form mirrors content: irregular line lengths and scattered rhymes enact disorder.
- Resolution: as he raves, he hears 'one calling, Child! / And I replied, My Lord.' Order and rhyme return.
- Title puns: the clerical collar, choler (anger), the caller.
The Pulley
- Myth of creation: 'When God at first made man, / Having a glass of blessings standing by', he pours out strength, beauty, wisdom, honour, pleasure, but keeps back one: rest.
- Reasoning: if man had rest he would 'rest in Nature, not the God of Nature'.
- Paradox and pun: 'Let him be rich and weary', so that if goodness does not lead him, 'weariness / May toss him to my breast'. Rest/restlessness, pulley as a device that raises by pulling down.
- Mark scheme points (January 2024): God as an experimenter in a personal relationship with humanity; biblical reference; diction of treasure and gifts; contrast around 'rest'; Watson on Herbert as a mystic; suggested pairing with Vaughan's The World.
Love (III)
- Allegory of welcome: 'Love bade me welcome: yet my soul drew back, / Guilty of dust and sin.'
- Dialogue: 'quick-eyed Love' answers each objection gently: the guest feels unworthy; Love points out who made his eyes; he asks to serve; Love insists: 'You must sit down, says Love, and taste my meat: / So I did sit and eat.'
- Images: hospitality, a feast (Holy Communion; the heavenly banquet).
- Tone: tender, courteous, grace freely given; the final monosyllables show complete acceptance.
- Readers often take it as the end point of the soul's journey in The Temple: struggle resolved into acceptance.
Worked example
Compare how Herbert resolves rebellion or unworthiness in The Collar and Love (III).
- The Collar: an outburst of anger and freedom, chaotic form; resolved instantly by God's call 'Child!' and the reply 'My Lord'.
- Love (III): the soul's shame ('Guilty of dust and sin') is answered patiently through dialogue until he sits and eats.
- Method: both end with short, simple lines that show surrender.
- Difference: the Collar's resolution is sudden; Love (III) is gradual and courteous.
- Context: Herbert's priesthood at Bemerton (Poetry Foundation); grace as God's free gift in Protestant theology.
Answer: Herbert resolves both crises through God's voice, but The Collar's rebellion is silenced in a single word, while Love (III) wins over the hesitant soul through a patient conversation that ends in a shared meal.
Check yourself
- Where does the speaker of Redemption finally find the lord?
- In a great palace
- In a church
- In heaven
- Among thieves and murderers
Show answer
Among thieves and murderers. Christ at the Crucifixion.
- How does Herbert use form in The Collar?
- Strict sonnet form throughout
- Irregular lines and rhymes enact rebellion until order returns at the end
- Prose
- Rhyming couplets only
Show answer
Irregular lines and rhymes enact rebellion until order returns at the end. Form mirrors the rebellion.
- In The Pulley, which blessing does God keep back?
- Beauty
- Wisdom
- Pleasure
- Rest
Show answer
Rest. Restlessness pulls man back to God.
- How does Love (III) end?
- 'So I did sit and eat'
- 'I will abroad!'
- 'My Lord'
- 'and died'
Show answer
'So I did sit and eat'. Acceptance of grace.
- Which meanings may the title 'The Collar' carry?
- A dog's collar only
- A shirt collar and a necklace
- A clerical collar, choler (anger) and the caller
- A collarbone
Show answer
A clerical collar, choler (anger) and the caller. Puns on service, anger and the call.
- Which second poem did the January 2024 mark scheme suggest for The Pulley?
- Vaughan's The World
- Donne's The Flea
- Marvell's To His Coy Mistress
- Carew's A Song
Show answer
Vaughan's The World. Both religious.
- Explain the paradox at the heart of The Pulley.
Show answer
God gives man every blessing except rest, so that restlessness and weariness will pull him back to God, meaning a lack becomes the greatest gift.. Withheld rest draws man to God.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Pearson IAL English Literature Appendix 5: prescribed texts, version 1.4 (May 2021): Unit 4 anthologies and prescribed poems
- Poetry Foundation: George Herbert
- Poetry Foundation: Henry Vaughan
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pressbooks, Early British Literature: George Herbert, The Temple (Redemption text)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.