All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

George Herbert: Redemption, The Collar, The Pulley and Love (III)

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Herbert's poems from The Temple (1633) dramatise a soul's relationship with God in plain language and ingenious forms. The January 2024 question asked about The Pulley; Herbert pairs well with Donne's religious poems and Vaughan.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Redemption and The Collar

Redemption

The Collar

The Pulley

Love (III)

Worked example

Compare how Herbert resolves rebellion or unworthiness in The Collar and Love (III).

  1. The Collar: an outburst of anger and freedom, chaotic form; resolved instantly by God's call 'Child!' and the reply 'My Lord'.
  2. Love (III): the soul's shame ('Guilty of dust and sin') is answered patiently through dialogue until he sits and eats.
  3. Method: both end with short, simple lines that show surrender.
  4. Difference: the Collar's resolution is sudden; Love (III) is gradual and courteous.
  5. Context: Herbert's priesthood at Bemerton (Poetry Foundation); grace as God's free gift in Protestant theology.

Answer: Herbert resolves both crises through God's voice, but The Collar's rebellion is silenced in a single word, while Love (III) wins over the hesitant soul through a patient conversation that ends in a shared meal.

Key idea: Redemption: parable sonnet, Christ found among thieves, 'Your suit is granted, said, and died'. The Collar: rebellion in disordered form, 'Child!' 'My Lord'. The Pulley: God withholds rest so weariness draws man to him. Love (III): dialogue of welcome, grace as a feast.

Check yourself

  1. Where does the speaker of Redemption finally find the lord?
    • In a great palace
    • In a church
    • In heaven
    • Among thieves and murderers
    Show answer

    Among thieves and murderers. Christ at the Crucifixion.

  2. How does Herbert use form in The Collar?
    • Strict sonnet form throughout
    • Irregular lines and rhymes enact rebellion until order returns at the end
    • Prose
    • Rhyming couplets only
    Show answer

    Irregular lines and rhymes enact rebellion until order returns at the end. Form mirrors the rebellion.

  3. In The Pulley, which blessing does God keep back?
    • Beauty
    • Wisdom
    • Pleasure
    • Rest
    Show answer

    Rest. Restlessness pulls man back to God.

  4. How does Love (III) end?
    • 'So I did sit and eat'
    • 'I will abroad!'
    • 'My Lord'
    • 'and died'
    Show answer

    'So I did sit and eat'. Acceptance of grace.

  5. Which meanings may the title 'The Collar' carry?
    • A dog's collar only
    • A shirt collar and a necklace
    • A clerical collar, choler (anger) and the caller
    • A collarbone
    Show answer

    A clerical collar, choler (anger) and the caller. Puns on service, anger and the call.

  6. Which second poem did the January 2024 mark scheme suggest for The Pulley?
    • Vaughan's The World
    • Donne's The Flea
    • Marvell's To His Coy Mistress
    • Carew's A Song
    Show answer

    Vaughan's The World. Both religious.

  7. Explain the paradox at the heart of The Pulley.
    Show answer

    God gives man every blessing except rest, so that restlessness and weariness will pull him back to God, meaning a lack becomes the greatest gift.. Withheld rest draws man to God.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.