All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Metaphysical Poetry: exam questions and essay planning

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

The Metaphysical questions always name one prescribed poem and a focus. Since 2022 the named poems have included Donne, Herbert, Carew, Bradstreet, Lovelace, Marvell, Vaughan and Philips, so you cannot afford to skip any poet.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Past questions

SeriesQuestion 9Question 10
June 2022sin: A Hymn to God the Fatherimagery and symbolism: To My Mistress Sitting by a River's Side: An Eddy
January 2023relationships: Song: To Lucasta, Going to the Warsvoice: A Dialogue of Friendship Multiplied
June 2023female characteristics: To His Coy Mistressfaith: The World
January 2024A Valediction of WeepingThe Pulley
June 2024faithfulness: To My Excellent Lucasia, on Our Friendshipmood and tone: Song ('Go and catch a falling star')
January 2025beauty: A Song ('Ask me no more')imagery and symbolism: A Letter to her Husband
June 2025relationships: Woman's Constancylonging: Orinda to Lucasia

From the Pearson WET04 mark schemes and examiner reports; the January 2024 focuses are not stated in the sources used

Second-poem grid

FocusStrong pairings
Love and seductionThe Flea, To His Coy Mistress, Elegy 19, To a Lady that Desired I Would Love Her
Faithfulness and inconstancyWoman's Constancy, Song, To My Excellent Lucasia, To Lucasta
Absence and partingA Valediction of Weeping, A Letter to her Husband, To Lucasta, Orinda to Lucasia
Faith, sin and graceHoly Sonnets, Hymn to God the Father, Herbert's four poems, Vaughan's two
Death and griefDeath be not Proud, A Nocturnal, The Apparition, The Nymph Complaining
TimeTo His Coy Mistress, The Sun Rising, The Good Morrow, The World
Women and female voicesBradstreet, Philips, The Nymph Complaining, Song, To His Coy Mistress
Beauty and complimentA Song ('Ask me no more'), The Sun Rising, An Eddy

What the reports say

Worked example

Plan an answer: 'Explore the presentation of sin in A Hymn to God the Father and one other poem' (June 2022).

  1. Second poem: the mark scheme suggested 'To His Coy Mistress'; a stronger thematic choice might be 'Batter My Heart' or Herbert's 'Love (III)'. Choose 'Love (III)' to extend the argument: sin answered by grace.
  2. Thesis: Donne's speaker cannot stop confessing because he fears his sin outlasts forgiveness; Herbert's speaker is 'Guilty of dust and sin' but is welcomed anyway.
  3. Paragraph 1: the refrain 'When thou hast done, thou hast not done' and the done/Donne pun.
  4. Paragraph 2: Herbert's dialogue form, where Love answers every objection.
  5. Paragraph 3: the 'sin of fear' and Christ's shining; 'So I did sit and eat'.
  6. Context and AO5: Original Sin and Calvinist anxiety; Donne's ordination; Eliot on fused thought and feeling; a historicist reading.

Answer: Choose a second poem that turns the question: Donne's anxious confession against Herbert's grace makes sin the start of an argument about forgiveness.

Key idea: Named poems since 2022 include all eight poets. Build a focus grid, choose a second poem that extends the argument, name it early, avoid purposeless comments on rhyme, use criticism from the start, hedge broad claims.

Check yourself

  1. What weakness did the January 2023 report find quite often in Section B answers?
    • Too much context
    • Too much criticism
    • Rhyme and versification described 'without any real purpose'
    • No quotation from Lovelace
    Show answer

    Rhyme and versification described 'without any real purpose'. Technical discussion should be 'going somewhere'.

  2. What did the June 2023 report praise in the answer on faith in The World?
    • A clear argument and an informed choice of second poem
    • Its length
    • Its avoidance of quotation
    • Its focus on Marvell
    Show answer

    A clear argument and an informed choice of second poem. Introduction praised.

  3. Which poem was named in the June 2025 question on longing?
    • The Collar
    • The Flea
    • Orinda to Lucasia
    • To His Coy Mistress
    Show answer

    Orinda to Lucasia. Philips.

  4. For a question on absence and parting, which second poem would best pair with A Valediction of Weeping?
    • The Pulley (Herbert)
    • A Letter to her Husband (Bradstreet)
    • Death be not Proud (Donne)
    • The World (Vaughan)
    Show answer

    A Letter to her Husband (Bradstreet). Both lament a husband's or lover's absence.

  5. What did the June 2024 report advise for an enthusiastic answer on mood and tone in Song?
    • Write less
    • Avoid personal response
    • Ignore the second poem
    • Use an appropriate critical idiom
    Show answer

    Use an appropriate critical idiom. Enthusiasm needs the right register.

  6. Outline two lines of argument for: 'Explore the presentation of relationships between men and women in Woman's Constancy and one other poem.'
    Show answer

    In Woman's Constancy the relationship is a witty battle of excuses in which both partners are fickle, whereas a second poem such as A Letter to her Husband shows a faithful marriage where absence brings longing rather than betrayal.. Fickle wit against a contrasting relationship.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.