All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Katherine Philips: three poems of friendship
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Katherine Philips, 'the Matchless Orinda', wrote some of the period's most admired poems of friendship between women. Her poems were the named poems in January 2023 (A Dialogue of Friendship Multiplied), June 2024 (To My Excellent Lucasia, on Our Friendship) and June 2025 (Orinda to Lucasia), so this option's examiners clearly value her.
Philips in context
From the Poetry Foundation:
- Born in London in 1632; married James Philips, a Parliamentarian MP, in 1648; died of smallpox in 1664.
- Called 'the Incomparable' and 'the Matchless Orinda' (her pen name). Her poems show Royalist sympathies.
- Her friendship poems use coterie names: Anne Owen as Lucasia, Mary Aubrey as Rosania; scholars debate the nature of her 'Society of Friendship'.
- Her translation of Corneille's *Pompey* (Dublin, 1663) made her the first woman to have a drama produced in a British public theatre.
- An unauthorised 1664 edition distressed her; the 1667 *Poems* followed.
- Recent scholarship focuses on how she won acclaim as a woman writer in a period that urged women to silence and obedience.
To My Excellent Lucasia, on Our Friendship
- Argument: before this friendship she was not truly alive: 'I did not live until this time / Crowned my felicity, / When I could say without a crime, / I am not thine, but thee.'
- Metaphysical borrowing: the language of Donne's love poetry (souls united, the world contained in the beloved) is applied to female friendship; the June 2024 mark scheme picks out 'I've all the world in thee' and the flame image ('Then let our flames still light and shine').
- Form: steady ABAB quatrains (mark scheme), calm and controlled.
- Readings: spiritual friendship in the Neoplatonic tradition; a homoerotic reading; a political reading of loyalty (the mark scheme lists political versus love readings and the 'flourishing of women poets').
- The June 2024 mark scheme suggested Donne's 'Woman's Constancy' as a contrasting second poem on faithfulness.
A Dialogue of Friendship Multiplied and Orinda to Lucasia
A Dialogue of Friendship Multiplied
- As the title suggests, a poem in dialogue form that explores friendship extended beyond a pair; the January 2023 mark scheme points to its questions and second-person address, emotive diction and conceits, Philips's friendship with Anne Owen and use of assumed names, religious and poetic dialogue traditions, and suggests Carew's 'To a Lady that Desired I Would Love Her' as a second poem.
Orinda to Lucasia
- A pastoral poem of longing: nature waits for the sun as Orinda waits for Lucasia; the June 2025 mark scheme lists images such as 'the weary birds' and 'The drooping flowers', the pastoral tradition and the shift from rural setting to personal appeal, varied iambic metre and sibilance, Philips's friendship with Anne Owen and classical male friendship, and Scodel on Philips rejecting Cavalier values.
- The June 2025 report said this question had very few answers, but praised one that handled longing in Philips and Bradstreet with good contextual and critical reference.
Worked example
Compare how Philips and Donne present faithfulness (the June 2024 suggested pairing of To My Excellent Lucasia and Woman's Constancy).
- Philips: friendship is total and constant: 'I am not thine, but thee'; identity merges; steady quatrains mirror stability.
- Donne: love lasts 'one whole day'; the speaker imagines her excuses and admits 'by tomorrow, I may think so too'.
- Method: both use metaphysical ideas of souls and worlds, but Philips sincerely, Donne ironically.
- Context: Philips's coterie of friendship and Royalist loyalty; Donne's witty manuscript love poems for male readers.
- AO5: a gender reading sees Philips reclaiming metaphysical language for women's friendship.
Answer: Philips borrows the metaphysical language of union to celebrate a faithful friendship between women, while Donne uses the same wit to mock the very idea of constancy.
Check yourself
- What was Katherine Philips's pen name?
- Orinda
- Lucasia
- Rosania
- Lucasta
Show answer
Orinda. 'The Matchless Orinda'.
- Who was 'Lucasia' in Philips's poems, according to the Poetry Foundation?
- Mary Aubrey
- Philips's daughter
- Anne Owen
- Queen Henrietta Maria
Show answer
Anne Owen. Mary Aubrey was Rosania.
- Which line ends the first stanza of To My Excellent Lucasia?
- 'I am not thine, but thee'
- 'I fear no more'
- 'So I did sit and eat'
- 'Lov'd I not Honour more'
Show answer
'I am not thine, but thee'. Identity merged.
- What was Philips's 'first' in the theatre?
- The first woman to act on stage
- The first female theatre manager
- The first woman to write a masque for Charles I
- The first woman to have a drama produced in a British public theatre
Show answer
The first woman to have a drama produced in a British public theatre. Her translation of Corneille's Pompey, Dublin, 1663.
- Which tradition does Orinda to Lucasia draw on, according to the June 2025 mark scheme?
- The carpe diem tradition
- The pastoral tradition
- The revenge tragedy
- The dramatic monologue
Show answer
The pastoral tradition. Weary birds and drooping flowers.
- What political tension does the Poetry Foundation note in Philips's life?
- She was exiled to France
- She was imprisoned by Cromwell
- She was a Puritan preacher
- Her poems show Royalist sympathies while her husband was a Parliamentarian MP
Show answer
Her poems show Royalist sympathies while her husband was a Parliamentarian MP. Antenor and Orinda.
- How does Philips use metaphysical ideas in To My Excellent Lucasia?
Show answer
She borrows the metaphysical language of lovers' souls uniting and the beloved containing a whole world, and applies it to friendship between women, as in 'I am not thine, but thee'.. Union of souls and worlds, applied to female friendship.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Pearson IAL English Literature Appendix 5: prescribed texts, version 1.4 (May 2021): Unit 4 anthologies and prescribed poems
- Poetry Foundation: Katherine Philips
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2023
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 examiner report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.