All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Why conservation is not universal: Kuznets, keystone and iconic species
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Spec 3.4.2 key idea 3: why some countries and people protect biodiversity more than others, using the environmental Kuznets curve and the way people value keystone species, iconic species and the money a standing forest can earn.
The environmental Kuznets curve
The environmental Kuznets curve suggests that as a country develops, environmental degradation first rises (industrialisation, land clearance, resource exploitation) then falls once incomes are high enough for people to demand, and governments to afford, protection. The relationship is complex: rich countries may simply import resources and 'export' degradation to poorer ones; some poorer countries conserve successfully and some richer ones do not; and the curve may not apply to global problems such as carbon emissions.
Keystone species, iconic species and financial value
Attitudes depend on perceived value:
- Keystone species have a disproportionate effect on their ecosystem (fig trees that fruit all year and feed many animals; large predators such as the jaguar that control herbivore numbers). Losing them can collapse the ecosystem, but they may not be well known.
- Iconic species (tigers, orangutans, gorillas, pandas) attract public sympathy and funding, so conservation money can be skewed towards them, though protecting their habitat protects many other species too.
- Financial gains: ecotourism, carbon-credit payments (such as REDD+ schemes) and sustainable harvesting can make a forest worth more standing than cleared, which changes local and national attitudes.
Worked example
Explain why an iconic species such as the orangutan may receive more conservation funding than a keystone species such as a fig tree.
- Iconic species are large, charismatic animals that attract public sympathy, media attention and donations, so NGOs feature them in campaigns.
- Keystone species may be unfamiliar to the public even though losing them could collapse the ecosystem (fig trees fruit all year and feed many animals).
- However, protecting an iconic species' habitat also protects many keystone and lesser-known species, so the money still helps the wider ecosystem.
Answer: Funding follows public perception rather than ecological importance, although protecting an iconic species' habitat can benefit keystone species too.
Check yourself
- The environmental Kuznets curve suggests that environmental degradation
- falls steadily as soon as development begins
- rises without limit as income grows
- rises in early development and falls once incomes are high
- is unrelated to income
Show answer
rises in early development and falls once incomes are high. An inverted U shape, though evidence is mixed.
- Which is the best description of a keystone species?
- A species whose loss would have a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem
- Any species that attracts tourists
- A species found only in zoos
- The largest species in a biome
Show answer
A species whose loss would have a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem. Keystone species hold the structure of an ecosystem together.
- Why might conservation funding be skewed towards iconic species?
- They are always keystone species
- They are found in every biome
- They attract public sympathy, media attention and donations
- They have no habitat needs
Show answer
They attract public sympathy, media attention and donations. Charismatic animals raise money; ecological importance is a separate question.
- Carbon-credit schemes such as REDD+ aim to slow deforestation by
- banning all trade in timber worldwide
- paying for forests to be kept standing because of the carbon they store
- breeding endangered animals in zoos
- replacing forest with plantations
Show answer
paying for forests to be kept standing because of the carbon they store. A standing forest earns money, which changes attitudes to clearance.
- Explain one limitation of the environmental Kuznets curve.
Show answer
Rich countries may appear cleaner only because they import resources and goods from poorer countries, so the degradation is exported rather than reduced, and the curve does not fit global problems such as carbon emissions.. A specific weakness, linked to environmental damage.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- Pearson WGE03/01 mark scheme, January 2024
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.