All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Managing biodiversity: sustainable yield, players and conservation strategies
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Who decides how ecosystems are used, and which conservation approaches work? (spec 3.4.3, enquiry question: how can ecosystems and biodiversity be managed successfully?) This lesson covers key ideas 1 and 2: sustainable yield, the players and their conflicting views, and local and global conservation strategies.
Key idea 1: sustainable yield and the players
Sustainable yield is the amount of a resource (timber, fish, bushmeat, grazing) that can be taken each year without reducing the stock's ability to replace itself. Harvesting above it depletes the resource; harvesting at or below it can continue indefinitely. It informs logging quotas, fishing limits and hunting permits, but it is hard to calculate accurately, ecosystems vary from year to year, and enforcement is difficult.
Players and their often conflicting views:
- Individuals: farmers, loggers, hunters, tourists and consumers make everyday choices.
- Interest groups: TNCs and agribusiness (land for production), indigenous groups (land rights, traditional use), conservation NGOs such as WWF (protection, campaigns, funding), local communities.
- Governments: create laws and protected areas, but also promote development (roads, dams, farming).
- International organisations: the UN (UNEP, UNESCO), IUCN (Red List), the World Bank (funding), conventions such as CITES and the Convention on Biological Diversity.
The June 2025 mark scheme expected answers to compare players at local and global scales and noted that answers covering only one scale are self-penalising.
Key idea 2: local and global conservation approaches
Local strategies, each with trade-offs:
- Total protection (strict reserves): best for biodiversity, but excludes local people, can create conflict and 'fortress conservation', and needs policing.
- National parks: protection combined with tourism and research; tourism earns money but can disturb wildlife.
- Sustainable reserves (extractive reserves, community forests): local people harvest rubber, nuts or fish sustainably; this wins support and protects livelihoods, but over-use is a risk.
Global frameworks:
- UNESCO Biosphere Reserves: zoned areas with a strictly protected core, a buffer zone for research and low-impact use, and a transition zone where people live and work sustainably. The network has 797 reserves in 145 countries (UNESCO, June 2026).
- CITES (the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species) controls trade through permits; about 40,900 species are protected (about 6,610 animals and 34,310 plants; US Fish and Wildlife Service). Appendix I species (threatened with extinction) face the strictest controls, Appendix II species need trade permits.
- Biodiversity Action Plans: national plans (under the Convention on Biological Diversity) that set targets for species and habitats.
All global frameworks need funding, monitoring and policing; without enforcement, illegal logging and wildlife trade continue.
Worked example
A government plans to turn part of a tropical forest into a sustainable extractive reserve where local people may collect nuts and rubber. Assess one advantage and one disadvantage.
- Advantage: local people gain income from the standing forest, so they support protection and help guard against illegal loggers.
- Disadvantage: if harvesting exceeds the sustainable yield, or hunting continues, species decline; monitoring is needed.
- Judgement: it is likely to succeed only if harvest limits are set from sustainable yield and enforced, and land rights are secure.
Answer: Community support is the main strength; over-use without monitoring is the main risk.
Check yourself
- CITES protects about 40,900 species, of which about 6,610 are animals. What percentage are animals? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
16.2 %. 6,610 / 40,900 x 100 = 16.2%.
- There are 797 biosphere reserves in 145 countries. What is the mean number per country? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
5.5. 797 / 145 = 5.5.
- In a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, where do people live and work in sustainable ways?
- The core
- The buffer zone only for scientists
- The transition zone
- Outside the reserve only
Show answer
The transition zone. Core = strict protection; buffer = research and low impact; transition = settlements and sustainable use.
- Harvesting a fish stock above its sustainable yield will
- increase the stock
- reduce the stock over time
- have no effect
- turn it into an endemic species
Show answer
reduce the stock over time. Removal exceeds replacement.
- A disadvantage of total protection reserves is that they can
- allow unlimited logging
- remove the need for funding
- increase poaching by design
- exclude local people and create conflict
Show answer
exclude local people and create conflict. 'Fortress conservation' can alienate communities.
- CITES protects species mainly by
- buying land for national parks
- controlling international trade through permits
- breeding animals in zoos
- setting fishing quotas within countries
Show answer
controlling international trade through permits. CITES regulates international trade.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- UNESCO (5 June 2026): UNESCO designates 14 new biosphere reserves on World Environment Day
- US Fish and Wildlife Service: How CITES works
- Pearson WGE03/01 mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.