All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Water futures: mega-dams and water transfers
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
What are the most sustainable ways to meet present and future water demand? (spec 3.6.3) This lesson covers key idea 1: the costs and benefits of large dams, multi-purpose schemes and water transfers, using cost-benefit analysis (skill 12).
Large dams and multi-purpose schemes
Large dams and reservoirs, especially multi-purpose schemes, store water for irrigation and cities, generate hydroelectricity, control floods and improve navigation.
- Economic benefits: reliable water and power, irrigation, jobs. Costs: very high construction cost and debt, sedimentation reduces capacity over time.
- Social: displacement of people from the flooded area, loss of farmland and cultural sites; but flood protection and electricity for millions.
- Environmental: trapped sediment starves downstream deltas and farmland of silt, barriers to fish migration, evaporation losses from reservoirs, methane from rotting vegetation.
- Examples by development level: Hoover Dam on the Colorado (developed), Three Gorges on the Yangtze (emerging), GERD on the Blue Nile (developing: 5,150 MW and a 74 billion cubic metre reservoir).
Water transfers and cost-benefit analysis
Water transfers move water from surplus to deficit regions by canals, tunnels and pipelines (such as China's South-North Water Transfer Project). Benefits: water for cities, industry and irrigation in dry areas. Costs: enormous expense and energy use, impacts on the donor river and its ecosystems, displacement, and conflict between donor and receiving regions. Skill (12): a cost-benefit analysis lists and weighs economic, social and environmental costs and benefits, often giving each a score or monetary value, and asks who gains and who loses.
Worked example
Use a cost-benefit approach to assess a large multi-purpose dam in a developing country.
- Benefits: reliable water for irrigation and cities, hydroelectricity, flood control and navigation; jobs during construction.
- Costs: very high cost and debt; displacement of people; sediment trapped so downstream farmland and deltas lose silt; evaporation losses; possible conflict with downstream states.
- Who gains and who loses: cities and industry gain power and water; displaced rural communities and downstream users may lose.
- Judgement: worthwhile only if displaced people are compensated, downstream flows are agreed and the debt is affordable.
Answer: A cost-benefit analysis weighs economic, social and environmental effects and asks who gains and who loses.
Check yourself
- A multi-purpose dam scheme is designed to provide
- water storage, hydroelectricity, flood control and navigation
- only drinking water
- only irrigation
- desalinated water
Show answer
water storage, hydroelectricity, flood control and navigation. Several functions from one project.
- Why can a large dam damage farmland on a delta far downstream?
- The dam increases salt in the reservoir
- Dams cause tropical cyclones
- The reservoir traps sediment that would otherwise renew the delta's soils
- Dams increase river sediment loads downstream
Show answer
The reservoir traps sediment that would otherwise renew the delta's soils. Sediment starvation affects deltas and fisheries.
- Explain why water transfer schemes can cause conflict.
Show answer
Taking water from a donor river reduces flows for farmers, communities and ecosystems in the source region, who may lose out while the receiving region benefits, so the two regions compete for the water.. Reduced flow in the donor area, affected users, competition.
- A cost-benefit analysis of a water scheme should
- list only the money the scheme will earn
- consider only the environmental impacts
- be carried out only after the scheme is built
- weigh economic, social and environmental costs and benefits and identify who gains and who loses
Show answer
weigh economic, social and environmental costs and benefits and identify who gains and who loses. Skill (12): a full, balanced assessment before deciding.
- In a water transfer scheme, the donor region is
- the region that receives extra water
- the region with surplus water that gives some up
- the government that pays for the scheme
- the sea into which the river flows
Show answer
the region with surplus water that gives some up. Water moves from the donor (surplus) to the receiving (deficit) region.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- Dawn, via AFP (10 September 2025): Ethiopia inaugurates Africa's biggest dam
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.