All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet

Desalination, conservation, intermediate technology and sharing agreements

Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet

Spec 3.6.3 key ideas 2 and 3: desalination and water conservation, low-cost intermediate technology, and international agreements for sharing water.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Key idea 2: desalination and conservation

Desalination removes salt from sea water or brackish groundwater, by reverse osmosis (forcing water through membranes) or thermal distillation. It suits physically water-scarce, wealthy coastal places (Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Israel; Australian cities built plants during the Millennium Drought). Issues: high energy use and cost (often fossil fuelled, adding emissions), toxic brine discharged into the sea, harm to marine life at intakes, and little use to poor inland regions. The June 2025 mark scheme expected desalination in the Middle East and North Africa to be weighed against cost, environmental impact, alternatives and scale limits in places such as India and Pakistan.

Water conservation may be more sustainable because supplies are finite:

Key idea 3: intermediate technology and water sharing

Intermediate technology is low-cost, small-scale technology that local people can build, use and repair themselves:

They improve supply and wellbeing quickly and cheaply, but serve small numbers and depend on maintenance and spare parts.

International agreements: the Helsinki Rules (1966) and the Berlin Rules (2004), drawn up by the International Law Association, set out principles for equitable and reasonable use of shared rivers and aquifers, the duty not to cause significant harm to other states, and the duty to cooperate and share information. They can promote fair sharing, but they are not binding, are hard to enforce, and older agreements (such as the 1920s and 1950s agreements on the Nile) often exclude upstream states. The January 2024 mark scheme credited the Danube as a cooperative success, and China's Mekong dams and Ethiopia's Blue Nile dam as examples of unilateral action.

Worked example

A government is choosing between a desalination plant and a national leak-reduction and metering programme for a dry coastal city. Use a brief cost-benefit approach to recommend one.

  1. Desalination: benefit, a new reliable supply independent of rainfall; costs, high capital and energy cost, brine pollution, carbon emissions.
  2. Leak reduction and metering: benefit, cheaper, saves existing water, cuts demand, no brine; costs, slower, needs public support, cannot add new water if demand keeps rising.
  3. Recommendation: start with conservation because it is cheaper and more sustainable, and add desalination only if demand still exceeds supply in droughts.

Answer: Conservation first, desalination as back-up: the cheaper, lower-impact option is more sustainable, but a drought-proof source may still be needed.

Key idea: Desalination suits rich, physically water-scarce coasts but uses much energy and produces brine. Conservation (metering, efficient appliances, drip irrigation, grey water) may be more sustainable. Intermediate technology (hand pumps, sand dams, rainwater tanks) helps poor communities cheaply. The Helsinki (1966) and Berlin (2004) Rules promote equitable sharing but are not binding.

Check yourself

  1. Reverse osmosis desalination works by
    • forcing salt water through membranes that hold back the salt
    • boiling water using geothermal steam only
    • adding chemicals to make salt sink
    • freezing the sea
    Show answer

    forcing salt water through membranes that hold back the salt. Membrane technology, energy intensive.

  2. Drip irrigation conserves water because it
    • floods whole fields
    • uses only desalinated water
    • delivers small amounts directly to plant roots, reducing evaporation and runoff
    • increases evaporation
    Show answer

    delivers small amounts directly to plant roots, reducing evaporation and runoff. Precision delivery cuts losses.

  3. A weakness of the Helsinki and Berlin Rules is that they
    • are not legally binding and are hard to enforce
    • ban all dams
    • only apply to oceans
    • require desalination
    Show answer

    are not legally binding and are hard to enforce. Principles depend on states choosing to follow them.

  4. Which is the best example of intermediate technology for water supply?
    • A large state-run desalination plant
    • A 5,000 MW hydroelectric dam
    • An inter-basin transfer tunnel
    • A community-built sand dam on a seasonal river
    Show answer

    A community-built sand dam on a seasonal river. Small scale, low cost, locally maintained.

  5. Global water-use efficiency rose 19.3% between 2015 and 2021 (UN-Water, citing FAO). If a country's efficiency was 20 US$ of output per cubic metre of water in 2015 and it matched the global rise, what would it be in 2021? Give your answer to 2 decimal places.
    Show answer

    23.86 US$ per m3. 20 x 1.193 = 23.86 US$ per cubic metre.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.