All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 3: How and why cultural diversity varies
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
The second part of Option 3 (4.5.2) asks 'How and why does cultural diversity vary spatially?' Its key idea is that cultural diversity varies spatially at all scales, and the specification asks you to compare countries using census data on ethnicity and religion. The June 2019 research focus asked why cultural diversity varies and how connectedness affects it.
Measuring cultural diversity
The specification points to census data on ethnicity and religion to compare diversity between countries. Useful measures:
- the share born overseas or of foreign nationality;
- the share of the largest group (high share = low diversity);
- a diversity index such as Simpson's: D = 1 - sum of p squared, where p is each group's proportion. D is 0 if everyone is in one group and approaches 1 with many equal groups.
Example, Singapore Census 2020 (resident ethnic groups): Chinese 74.3%, Malay 13.5%, Indian 9.0%, Others 3.2% (Singapore Department of Statistics). Religion (residents aged 15 and over) is far more mixed: Buddhism 31.1%, no religion 20.0%, Christianity 18.9%, Islam 15.6%, Taoism 8.8%, Hinduism 5.0%.
Limitations: categories differ between countries and censuses (some ask about ancestry, some about nationality), self-identification changes, and diversity within a category (for example many Chinese dialect groups) is hidden.
| Singapore 2020 | Ethnic groups | Religion |
|---|---|---|
| Largest group | Chinese 74.3% | Buddhism 31.1% |
| Simpson's D | 0.42 | 0.79 |
Simpson's index calculated from the Census of Population 2020 percentages
Contrasting countries
- Australia (2021 Census): 27.6% of people born overseas and 48.2% with at least one parent born overseas; India became the third largest country of birth; Mandarin (685,274 speakers) and Arabic (367,159) were the most common languages after English at home (ABS, 2022).
- Japan: a record 3,768,977 foreign residents at the end of 2024, up 357,985 (10.5%) in a year, largest groups Chinese, Vietnamese and South Korean (Immigration Services Agency, via Nippon.com). Still a small share of Japan's total population, so Japan remains relatively homogeneous.
- Iceland: immigrants were 19.6% of the population on 1 January 2026 (77,226), and with the second generation 21.7%, the highest recorded; Poles are the largest group (29.9% of immigrants) (Statistics Iceland). Once isolated and very homogeneous, Iceland has diversified quickly.
Globally, international migrants numbered 304 million in 2024, 3.7% of world population, up from about 154 million (2.9%) in 1990 (UN DESA via Destatis).
Why diversity varies
Explanations credited in the June 2025 and January 2025 mark schemes:
- Migration: scale and type (labour, refugees, family, colonial ties). Large global cities (London, Toronto, Sydney, Singapore) are the most diverse.
- Government policy: open, points-based or multicultural policies (Canada, Australia) increase diversity; restrictive policies limit it; forced assimilation reduces it.
- Connectedness: links by trade, transport, media and the internet; but high connectedness does not always mean high diversity (Japan).
- Isolation: physical or political isolation keeps populations uniform (historically Iceland; North Korea).
- History: colonisation, empire and past migrations.
- Scale and urban-rural contrasts: cities are more diverse than rural areas within the same country; remote rural communities are not necessarily homogeneous.
Worked example
Calculate Simpson's diversity index for Singapore's ethnic groups in 2020 and compare it with 2010 (Chinese 74.1, Malay 13.4, Indian 9.2, Others 3.3).
- 2020: sum of p squared = 0.7432 + 0.1352 + 0.0902 + 0.0322 = 0.5794
- D(2020) = 1 - 0.5794 = 0.421
- D(2010) = 1 - 0.5766 = 0.423
Answer: D is about 0.42 in both years (0.423 in 2010, 0.421 in 2020): ethnic diversity among residents barely changed, even though religious diversity is much higher (D = 0.79).
Check yourself
- Calculate Simpson's diversity index D = 1 - sum of p squared for Singapore's ethnic groups in 2020 (Chinese 74.3%, Malay 13.5%, Indian 9.0%, Others 3.2%). Give your answer to 2 decimal places.
Show answer
0.42. Sum of p squared = 0.5794; D = 0.421.
- Japan had 3,768,977 foreign residents at the end of 2024, up 357,985 in a year. How many foreign residents were there at the end of 2023?
Show answer
3410992 people. 3,768,977 - 357,985 = 3,410,992.
- International migrants numbered about 154 million in 1990 and 304 million in 2024. What was the percentage increase? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Show answer
97 %. (304 - 154) / 154 x 100 = 97%.
- Which is a limitation of comparing cultural diversity between countries using census data?
- Censuses never ask about religion
- Countries use different categories, such as nationality, ethnicity or ancestry
- Census data are always out of date by 50 years
- Censuses count only tourists
Show answer
Countries use different categories, such as nationality, ethnicity or ancestry. Categories are not standardised.
- Japan is used in mark schemes as an example of
- a country with no foreign residents
- a country with open migration since 1900
- a remote isolated island
- high connectedness that has not produced high cultural diversity
Show answer
high connectedness that has not produced high cultural diversity. January 2025 mark scheme: high connectedness does not always mean high diversity.
- Immigrants were 19.6% of Iceland's population on 1 January 2026. Which group was largest?
- People from Japan
- People from Poland
- People from Brazil
- People from Australia
Show answer
People from Poland. Poles were 29.9% of immigrants (Statistics Iceland).
- Explain how government policy can influence the cultural diversity of a country.
Show answer
Open immigration and multicultural policies attract migrants and support minority cultures, increasing diversity, while restrictive immigration or forced assimilation policies limit migration and pressure minorities to conform, reducing diversity.. Open policies raise diversity; restrictive or assimilation policies lower it.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Singapore Department of Statistics: Census of Population 2020, Statistical Release 1, key findings
- Australian Bureau of Statistics media release (28 June 2022): 2021 Census, nearly half of Australians have a parent born overseas
- Nippon.com Japan Data: Foreign residents in Japan at the end of 2024 (Immigration Services Agency figures)
- Statistics Iceland news release (10 June 2026): Population by origin, 1 January 2026
- Destatis (updated 7 May 2025): 304 million migrants worldwide (UN DESA International Migrant Stock 2024)
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WGE04/01 research focus (pre-release), June 2019
- Pearson WGE04/01 research focus (pre-release), January 2019
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.