All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography

Option 3: Valuing and protecting cultures

Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography

The last part of 4.5.1 asks why some cultures and landscapes are valued and protected more than others, and how indigenous groups, NGOs, communities and governments try to protect land rights and ways of life.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Who decides what is protected?

Governments and UNESCO make protection decisions based on attitudes and values (4.5.1). UNESCO's World Heritage List protects sites of 'outstanding universal value'; national governments designate national parks, listed buildings and conservation areas.

Critics argue that selection reflects whose values count: monumental, built heritage in richer countries has historically been listed more often than living, intangible or indigenous heritage. Protection can also freeze a landscape for tourists rather than for the people whose culture it is.

The January 2024 research focus asked why different groups value cultural landscapes in different ways and how various locations protect them.

Indigenous rights and wilderness

Indigenous groups face difficulties protecting land rights, wilderness and ways of life against economic exploitation such as mining, logging, oil and gas, dams, agribusiness and tourism (4.5.1). They are often politically weak, lack formal land titles, and may be in remote areas where laws are poorly enforced.

The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted by the General Assembly on 13 September 2007; 4 states voted against and 11 abstained. The four that voted against, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, have since reversed their positions and support it (UN DESA). It sets minimum standards for the survival, dignity and well-being of indigenous peoples, including self-determination and control over resources on traditional lands.

PlayerTypical action
UNESCOWorld Heritage listing, conservation funding
National governmentsLand rights laws, protected areas, co-management
NGOsCampaigns, legal support, mapping territories
Community groupsSelf-management, cultural revival, tourism on own terms

Case study: the Uluru climb closure

Uluru-Kata Tjuta National Park was handed back to Anangu in 1985 ('Handback') and is jointly managed. Signs from the 1990s asked visitors, on behalf of Anangu, to 'Please don't climb'. The 2010 management plan signalled the intention to work towards closing the climb. In November 2017 the Board of Management agreed closure criteria, which included the proportion of visitors climbing falling below 20%, and voted unanimously to close the climb; it closed permanently on 26 October 2019, the 34th anniversary of Handback. Climbing is now an offence under national environmental law (Parks Australia).

This shows co-management and indigenous values shaping protection, but it took 34 years from Handback and relied on falling demand, showing how economic interests delay change.

Worked example

Evaluate the Uluru climb closure as an example of protecting indigenous culture.

  1. Success: Anangu law (Tjukurpa) is now respected; joint management gave Traditional Owners real decision-making power; closure is legally enforced.
  2. Limits: it took 34 years after Handback; closure waited until fewer than 20% of visitors climbed, so economic concerns came first.
  3. Wider point: the park still depends on tourism, so protection is a negotiated balance between cultural and economic values.

Answer: A real but slow success, made possible by co-management and changing visitor attitudes.

Key idea: Protection reflects values: UNESCO and governments choose what to protect, often favouring built heritage. Indigenous groups struggle against economic exploitation; UNDRIP (2007) sets minimum standards. NGOs, communities and some governments protect or restore rights, as in the co-managed Uluru climb closure (2019).

Check yourself

  1. Uluru-Kata Tjuta was handed back to Anangu in 1985 and the climb closed in 2019. How many years later was the closure?
    Show answer

    34 years. 2019 - 1985 = 34 years.

  2. UNDRIP was opposed by 4 states with 11 abstentions. If 144 states voted in favour, what percentage of states casting a vote or abstaining supported it? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
    Show answer

    90.6 %. 144 / 159 x 100 = 90.6%.

  3. Which four countries voted against UNDRIP in 2007 but have since reversed their position?
    • Brazil, India, China and Russia
    • Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States
    • France, Germany, Italy and Spain
    • Japan, Korea, Iceland and Norway
    Show answer

    Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States. All four have large indigenous populations and later endorsed it.

  4. Why is World Heritage listing sometimes criticised?
    • It always bans tourism
    • It removes all funding
    • Selection can reflect the values of powerful groups, favouring monumental built heritage
    • It applies only to natural sites
    Show answer

    Selection can reflect the values of powerful groups, favouring monumental built heritage. Attitudes and values shape selection.

  5. Which is a common economic threat to indigenous land rights?
    • Mining and logging concessions granted without consent
    • A UNESCO listing
    • A community language school
    • Co-management of a national park
    Show answer

    Mining and logging concessions granted without consent. Economic exploitation of land and resources.

  6. Explain why indigenous groups often find it difficult to protect their land rights.
    Show answer

    They often lack formal legal titles to land, have little political power compared with governments and companies, and live in remote areas where laws are poorly enforced, so mining, logging or farming interests can override them.. Weak legal position and weak power relative to economic interests.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.