All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 3: Threats to cultures and cultural landscapes
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
4.5.1 also covers deliberate threats to culture: the historical marginalisation of indigenous peoples, political suppression and genocide, and the deliberate destruction of cultural landscapes.
Marginalisation of indigenous cultures
Indigenous peoples are the descendants of the original inhabitants of a territory who keep distinct cultures. Historically, especially in the colonial era, many were marginalised and their lands exploited (4.5.1):
- land taken for settlers, plantations, mining and ranching;
- forced removal and resettlement;
- loss of language through schooling in the colonisers' language;
- missionary and state campaigns to replace beliefs.
The result is loss of land, livelihoods, languages and knowledge. UNESCO notes more than 6,700 languages are spoken worldwide and at least 40% are threatened with extinction in the long term, mainly because they lack speakers (Austrian Commission for UNESCO, 2022); many are indigenous languages, which is why 2022 to 2032 is the International Decade of Indigenous Languages.
Political threats and deliberate destruction
(4.5.1)
- Suppression: banning languages, religions, dress or customs; forced assimilation policies. The June 2025 mark scheme lists forced assimilation, 'Sovietisation' and colonisation as historical state policies that suppressed diversity.
- Genocide: the deliberate destruction of a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, the most extreme threat.
- Destruction of cultural landscapes in conflict or by political policy: the giant Buddhas of Bamiyan in Afghanistan were destroyed in March 2001; in 2003 the Cultural Landscape and Archaeological Remains of the Bamiyan Valley was inscribed on the World Heritage List and the List of World Heritage in Danger at the same time. UNESCO members then adopted a Declaration on the Intentional Destruction of Cultural Heritage (17 October 2003) and over US$27 million has been invested in conservation and community projects there (UNESCO, 2021).
| Threat | How it harms culture | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Colonial land seizure | Loss of land and livelihood | Indigenous lands taken for settlement |
| Forced assimilation | Loss of language and identity | Bans on languages in schools |
| Deliberate destruction | Loss of heritage and symbols | Bamiyan Buddhas, 2001 |
Why the threats matter
Culture is tied to land: for many indigenous groups, losing land means losing food sources, sacred sites and the knowledge passed down with them. Threats also reduce cultural diversity overall, which UNESCO treats as part of humanity's common heritage. When answering, distinguish deliberate threats (policy, conflict) from the indirect pressures of globalisation and economic development, which are covered later in this option.
Worked example
Classify these as deliberate or indirect threats to culture: (a) a state bans a minority language in schools; (b) young people move to cities and stop speaking their grandparents' language; (c) a militia blows up a historic shrine.
- (a) Deliberate: a political policy of suppression.
- (b) Indirect: urbanisation and globalisation lead to language shift without anyone intending it.
- (c) Deliberate: destruction of a cultural landscape in conflict.
Answer: (a) deliberate, (b) indirect, (c) deliberate.
Check yourself
- UNESCO says more than 6,700 languages are spoken and at least 40% are threatened. At least how many languages is that?
Show answer
2680 languages. 6,700 x 0.40 = 2,680.
- The Bamiyan Buddhas were destroyed in 2001 and the valley was inscribed on the World Heritage List in 2003. How many years after the destruction was this?
Show answer
2 years. 2003 - 2001 = 2 years.
- Forced assimilation means
- pressuring a minority to abandon its culture and adopt the dominant one
- voluntary learning of a second language
- tourists visiting a festival
- protecting a sacred site
Show answer
pressuring a minority to abandon its culture and adopt the dominant one. A political threat to culture.
- In the colonial era, a common way indigenous cultures were marginalised was
- creation of World Heritage Sites
- the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
- free university education in their own languages
- seizure of their land for settlers, plantations and mines
Show answer
seizure of their land for settlers, plantations and mines. Land loss was central.
- Which is a deliberate threat to a cultural landscape?
- Young people migrating to cities
- Destroying monuments during a conflict
- Global spread of fast-food chains
- Rising tourism numbers
Show answer
Destroying monuments during a conflict. Deliberate = intended destruction.
- Explain why loss of land is especially damaging to indigenous cultures.
Show answer
Indigenous cultures are closely tied to their land, which provides food and livelihoods, contains sacred sites and is where traditional knowledge and practices are passed on, so losing it breaks the link to identity.. Land supports both livelihood and identity.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Austrian Commission for UNESCO (2022): UNESCO celebrates the International Decade of Indigenous Languages
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre (11 March 2021): Commemorating 20 years since the destruction of the Buddhas of Bamiyan
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.