All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 2: The Green Revolution and GM crops
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
4.4.3 asks how effective strategies to increase food supply are. The first strategies are technological: the Green Revolution and genetically modified (GM) crops, the so-called Gene Revolution.
The Green Revolution
From the 1960s, high-yielding varieties (HYVs) of wheat and rice, with irrigation, fertilisers and pesticides, spread widely in less-industrialised countries, supported by international aid agencies. New wheat varieties were adopted in India and Pakistan and new rice varieties in the Philippines and Indonesia; almost all wheat and rice grown today originated in the Green Revolution (Encyclopedia.com, Green Revolution).
Advantages (economic, social): higher yields; India produced more wheat and rice, helping to avert famines and save foreign exchange.
Disadvantages: wealthier farmers who could afford seeds, fertiliser and irrigation gained most, widening inequality; heavy use of fertilisers, pesticides and irrigation worsened environmental problems (water depletion, salinisation, pollution, loss of crop diversity) (4.4.3).
Limited impact in Africa: HYVs focused on wheat and rice, while African farmers grow more varied crops (maize, sorghum, millet, cassava) on rain-fed land with little irrigation and poor infrastructure. There are also doubts about whether yields can keep rising.
| Aspect | Benefit | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Higher yields, foreign exchange saved | Input costs, debt |
| Social | Famines averted | Inequality between farmers |
| Environmental | Less new land needed | Water use, chemicals, salinisation |
GM crops
Genetically modified crops have genes added to give traits such as pest resistance (Bt cotton, Bt maize) or herbicide tolerance. ISAAA reported 190.4 million hectares in 2019 in 29 countries, about 112 times the 1.7 million hectares of 1996. Soybeans (91.9 million ha) were the largest crop; 79% of the world's cotton area and 74% of soybean area were GM. The USA, Brazil, Argentina, Canada and India grew 91% of the total (ISAAA Brief 55).
Are they helping food security? The specification says they are widely adopted but their benefit to food security is unclear: much GM area is soy and maize for animal feed and biofuel, and cotton is not food; concerns include corporate control of seed, cost, and possible environmental effects. Supporters point to higher yields, lower insecticide use and traits such as drought tolerance and vitamin enrichment. Note that ISAAA is an organisation that promotes biotech crops, so its interpretation should be weighed against other sources.
Worked example
Explain why the Green Revolution had less impact in Sub-Saharan Africa than in South Asia.
- HYVs were bred mainly for wheat and rice, which are less important in many African farming systems based on maize, sorghum, millet and cassava.
- HYVs needed irrigation, but most African farming is rain-fed.
- Poor roads, weak markets and lack of credit made fertiliser and seed expensive or unavailable.
Answer: Wrong crops, little irrigation and weak infrastructure and credit.
Check yourself
- GM crops covered 1.7 million hectares in 1996 and 190.4 million hectares in 2019. How many times larger was the 2019 area? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Show answer
112 times. 190.4 / 1.7 = 112.
- Soybeans covered 91.9 million of the 190.4 million hectares of GM crops in 2019. What percentage is that? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Show answer
48 %. 91.9 / 190.4 x 100 = 48%.
- Which inputs did Green Revolution high-yielding varieties usually depend on?
- Shifting cultivation
- Organic manure only
- Irrigation, fertilisers and pesticides
- No inputs at all
Show answer
Irrigation, fertilisers and pesticides. HYVs respond to water and fertiliser.
- Why did the Green Revolution increase inequality in some rural areas?
- Poorer farmers received free land
- Wealthier farmers could afford the seeds, fertiliser and irrigation and gained most
- It only benefited city dwellers
- Yields fell for everyone
Show answer
Wealthier farmers could afford the seeds, fertiliser and irrigation and gained most. Access to inputs depended on wealth.
- Why is the benefit of GM crops to food security described as unclear?
- GM crops cannot grow
- They are banned everywhere
- They are grown mainly by subsistence farmers in Africa
- Much GM area is soy and maize for animal feed and biofuels, and cotton, rather than food for the hungry
Show answer
Much GM area is soy and maize for animal feed and biofuels, and cotton, rather than food for the hungry. Specification 4.4.3 and ISAAA crop data.
- Explain why a student should be cautious about using ISAAA figures to argue that GM crops improve food security.
Show answer
ISAAA promotes biotech crops, so it may present GM in a favourable way; area planted shows adoption, not whether hungry people get more food, so the evidence should be checked against independent sources.. Possible bias and what the data actually show.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Encyclopedia.com (Gale, Plant Sciences): Green Revolution
- ISAAA Brief 55 (2019): Executive summary, global status of biotech/GM crops
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.