All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 2: Trade, cash crops and Fair Trade
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
The last part of 4.4.2 is about trade: the costs and benefits of cash crops compared with subsistence farming, Fair Trade, and the forces that move world food prices.
Cash crops versus subsistence farming
Subsistence farming grows food for the farmer's family; cash crops (coffee, cocoa, tea, cotton, cut flowers, export vegetables) are grown for sale, often for export (4.4.2).
Benefits of cash crops: income for farmers and foreign exchange for governments; agriculture can be over one-third of export earnings in some poorer countries (January 2025 mark scheme); money can buy food, schooling and health care.
Costs: land, water and labour are diverted from food crops; farmers depend on volatile world prices; monoculture can degrade soils; profits often go to traders and transnational corporations (TNCs) rather than growers; and subsidies and tariffs in developed countries limit competitiveness.
| Cash crops | Subsistence | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Money, foreign exchange | Little or none |
| Food security | Depends on prices and income | Direct, but vulnerable to harvest failure |
| Risk | Price volatility | Drought, pests |
| Environment | Monoculture, chemicals | Often more diverse |
Fair Trade
Fair Trade schemes guarantee small producers a minimum price and pay a premium for community projects, in return for meeting labour and environmental standards. Fairtrade International reports about 2 million farmers and workers in about 1,900 producer organisations in 70 countries; producers earned more than EUR 211 million in Fairtrade Premium in 2023, and more than EUR 1.5 billion over ten years (Fairtrade International).
Advantages: more stable income, investment in schools, clinics and better farming. Disadvantages: certification costs, only a small share of world trade, much of the retail price still goes to retailers, and benefits may go to better-organised farmers rather than the poorest labourers.
What moves food prices
World food prices depend on (4.4.2):
- Supply: harvests, droughts and floods, pests, conflict (war zones such as Ukraine and Syria disrupt production and exports).
- Demand: population growth, rising incomes and changing diets in emerging countries, and biofuels competing for crops.
- Oil prices: fuel for machinery and transport, and fertiliser production.
- Trade policy: export bans and tariffs; speculation in commodity markets.
The January 2025 question asked students to evaluate the view that increasing both trade and commercial farming is the most important way to improve food security in countries, weighing gains against marginalised smallholders and land grabs.
Worked example
Explain why a coffee-growing smallholder might become food insecure even though she earns cash income.
- Her land and labour go into coffee rather than food crops, so she must buy food.
- If world coffee prices fall, her income drops while food prices may stay the same or rise.
- So her access to food depends on two volatile prices she cannot control.
Answer: Dependence on cash income exposes her to falling crop prices and rising food prices, reducing access to food.
Check yourself
- Producers earned more than EUR 211 million in Fairtrade Premium in 2023 and Fairtrade has about 2 million farmers and workers. What is the mean premium per farmer or worker in euros? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
EUR 105.5. 211,000,000 / 2,000,000 = 105.5.
- Which is a disadvantage of a country relying on cash crop exports?
- Income depends on volatile world prices
- It earns foreign exchange
- It provides employment
- It can fund imports of food
Show answer
Income depends on volatile world prices. Price falls can cut national and household income sharply.
- What does Fair Trade guarantee to producers?
- Ownership of the supermarkets
- Free fertiliser
- A minimum price and a premium for community projects
- Exemption from all standards
Show answer
A minimum price and a premium for community projects. In return for standards.
- Why do higher oil prices tend to raise food prices?
- People eat less
- Fuel and fertiliser costs rise for farming and transport
- Crops grow faster
- Oil is used as a food ingredient
Show answer
Fuel and fertiliser costs rise for farming and transport. Energy is a major input to modern farming.
- How can biofuel production affect food security?
- It always lowers food prices
- It only uses desert land
- It has no link to food
- Crops and land used for fuel compete with food, raising prices
Show answer
Crops and land used for fuel compete with food, raising prices. Competition for crops and land.
- Explain why small farmers may gain little from export agriculture dominated by TNCs.
Show answer
TNCs have market power, so they can push down the farm-gate price paid to growers while keeping most of the value added in processing, transport and retail, leaving smallholders with a small share of the final price.. Market power over prices and value chains.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Fairtrade International: An overview of Fairtrade's impact (key figures)
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.