All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 1: Players, loss modification and living with risk
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
The third key idea of 4.3.3 is that the roles and attitudes of different players are important in risk assessment and reduction: loss modification, multi-agency responses and why people live in hazardous places.
Loss modification
(4.3.3 key idea 3 a) Loss modification reduces the losses after an event:
- Emergency and relief aid: search and rescue, medical care, food, water, shelter. Timing is crucial: most people trapped in collapsed buildings must be rescued within the first few days.
- Longer-term aid for reconstruction.
- Insurance: spreads the financial loss; common in developed countries, rare among the poor.
- Community action: neighbours are usually the first rescuers.
Example: after the 2023 earthquake, UNHCR provided over three million relief items such as tents, containers, hygiene kits and warm clothing in Turkiye (UN News, 2024).
Multi-agency responses
(4.3.3 key idea 3 b) Disasters involve many players with different roles:
- Communities and local government: first response, local knowledge, shelters.
- National government: emergency declarations, army, funding, building codes, warning systems.
- International organisations and NGOs: UN agencies (UNHCR, WFP, WHO), the Red Cross and Red Crescent, specialist rescue teams, the World Bank for reconstruction loans.
- Scientists: monitoring, hazard maps, advice.
- Insurance companies and businesses.
Coordination matters: in Haiti 2010 the UN headquarters was among the badly damaged buildings (Britannica), hampering coordination; Nepalese UN peacekeepers were the likely source of a cholera outbreak, and in 2016 the UN admitted it had played a role in starting it. The outbreak sickened about 770,000 people: a reminder that responders can cause harm.
| Player | Typical role | Possible limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Community | First rescue, local knowledge | Lacks equipment |
| National government | Coordination, laws, funding | Weak governance, corruption |
| International NGOs and UN | Relief aid, expertise, funding | Slow to arrive, coordination problems |
| Scientists | Monitoring and warnings | Uncertainty, communication |
Why people live with tectonic risk
(4.3.3 key idea 3 c) The reasons are complex and linked to opportunities:
- Economic: fertile volcanic soils for farming; geothermal energy (Iceland); tourism; jobs in cities that happen to lie on faults or coasts.
- Social and cultural: family ties, land ownership, attachment to place, religious beliefs.
- Lack of choice: poverty means people cannot afford to move; rapid urbanisation pushes migrants onto unsafe land.
- Perception: low frequency hazards are underestimated; trust in technology; fatalism (the January 2025 mark scheme mentions fatalism in Turkiye).
The June 2025 question asked whether trends in impacts show that tectonic disaster management is increasingly successful: candidates had to judge improvement in some places against rising losses and unequal success.
Worked example
Explain why many people continue to farm on the slopes of an active volcano such as Merapi.
- Volcanic soils are very fertile, allowing high crop yields and income.
- Families have lived there for generations and have cultural and spiritual ties to the mountain.
- Eruptions large enough to threaten life are infrequent, and monitoring and evacuation plans reduce the perceived risk.
- Poverty limits the option to move.
Answer: Fertile soils and livelihoods, attachment to place, infrequent large eruptions with monitoring, and lack of alternatives.
Check yourself
- Which is an example of loss modification?
- Building on bedrock rather than sediment
- Insurance payouts after an earthquake
- Hazard mapping
- Base isolation of buildings
Show answer
Insurance payouts after an earthquake. It reduces losses after the event.
- Why is timing crucial for emergency aid after an earthquake?
- Aid is cheaper later
- Aftershocks never occur
- Insurance only pays in the first hour
- Most people trapped in rubble must be rescued within the first few days
Show answer
Most people trapped in rubble must be rescued within the first few days. Survival chances fall quickly.
- Fatalism means
- trusting scientists completely
- believing that disasters are inevitable or determined by fate so little can be done
- moving away from hazards
- buying insurance
Show answer
believing that disasters are inevitable or determined by fate so little can be done. An attitude that reduces preparedness.
- Which economic opportunity encourages people to live in Iceland's volcanic regions?
- Coal mining
- Rice terraces
- Geothermal energy
- Deep-sea fishing only
Show answer
Geothermal energy. Volcanic heat is used for power and heating.
- Three months after the 2011 Japan disaster the government estimated about 15,000 dead; the Reconstruction Agency now gives 19,782 (including disaster-related deaths). By what percentage did the count rise? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
31.9 %. (19,782 - 15,000) / 15,000 x 100 = 31.9%.
- Explain why poverty can force people to live in areas of high tectonic risk.
Show answer
Poor people cannot afford land or housing in safer areas, so they settle on cheap, unsafe land such as steep slopes or near faults, and they cannot afford to move away or build safely.. Affordability and lack of choice.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- UN News (6 February 2024): One year on, for survivors of Turkiye-Syria quakes the suffering is far from over
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: 2010 Haiti earthquake
- Nippon.com Japan Data (2026): The state of recovery in Tohoku 15 years after 3/11 (Reconstruction Agency figures)
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2025
- Subandriyo, Gertisser, Aisyah and others (2023), An overview of the large-magnitude (VEI 4) eruption of Merapi in 2010, in Merapi Volcano (Springer), University of Twente record
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.