All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 1: Modifying the event and vulnerability
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
The second key idea of 4.3.3 is that modifying the event and modifying vulnerability are key parts of management. You need the hazard management cycle and Park's model as frameworks, and the strategies of event and vulnerability modification.
Frameworks: the hazard management cycle and Park's model
(4.3.3 key idea 2 a)
- The hazard management cycle has four linked stages: mitigation (reducing risk before an event), preparedness (plans, drills, warnings), response (rescue, emergency aid) and recovery (rebuilding, ideally better). Recovery leads back into mitigation.
- Park's model (the disaster response curve) plots quality of life against time: normality before the event, a sudden fall during the disaster, then relief (hours to days), rehabilitation (weeks to months) and reconstruction (months to years). The depth of the fall and the speed and level of recovery differ between places: a resilient country recovers faster and may end above its original level.
Apply them to named disasters: Haiti's curve shows a deep fall and slow recovery (over 62,000 still displaced in early 2016, Britannica); Japan's shows faster rehabilitation, though almost 30,000 were still in temporary accommodation in November 2025 (Nippon.com).
| Park's model stage | Timescale | Example actions |
|---|---|---|
| Relief | Hours to days | Search and rescue, medical aid, shelter |
| Rehabilitation | Weeks to months | Temporary housing, restoring water and power |
| Reconstruction | Months to years | Rebuilding to higher standards, new codes |
Modifying the event
(4.3.3 key idea 2 b) You cannot stop a tectonic event, but you can modify its effects:
- Land-use zoning: keep housing and critical buildings off fault lines, liquefiable ground, lahar paths and tsunami zones.
- Hazard-resistant design: aseismic buildings with deep foundations, cross-bracing, base isolators and dampers, flexible steel frames; roofs that shed ash.
- Engineered defences: sea walls and tsunami barriers, lava diversion channels, lahar dams.
Barriers: cost (retrofitting buildings is expensive), maintenance, and the challenge of enforcing rules. Defences can also create false security: Japan's sea walls were overtopped in 2011.
Modifying vulnerability
(4.3.3 key idea 2 c) Reduce vulnerability so people can avoid or cope with the hazard:
- Monitoring and warning systems (seismometers, DART buoys, early warning apps).
- Evacuation plans, routes and shelters; exclusion zones around volcanoes.
- Community preparedness: education, drills, emergency kits, trained local responders.
- Adaptation: changing how people live with hazards, for example raising homes or relocating.
These are often cheaper than engineering and can save many lives: large-scale evacuation at Merapi in 2010 (June 2025 mark scheme).
Worked example
Use Park's model to compare the likely response curves for Haiti 2010 and Japan 2011.
- Haiti: very deep fall in quality of life (government buildings and housing destroyed, over 1 million homeless); long relief phase reliant on international aid; slow reconstruction (62,000 still displaced in 2016).
- Japan: deep fall in tsunami areas, but rapid relief by national agencies, faster rehabilitation and reconstruction to higher standards.
- Japan may recover above its pre-disaster level in some areas; Haiti did not recover to its original level for years.
Answer: Haiti: deeper, longer trough and slower, lower recovery; Japan: faster recovery owing to wealth, governance and preparedness.
Check yourself
- Which stage of the hazard management cycle includes drills and warning plans?
- Response
- Recovery
- Reconstruction
- Preparedness
Show answer
Preparedness. Preparing people before an event.
- In Park's model, the phase of temporary housing and restoring water and power is
- relief
- rehabilitation
- reconstruction
- mitigation
Show answer
rehabilitation. Weeks to months after the event.
- Which is an example of modifying the event?
- Running evacuation drills
- Issuing insurance
- Sending emergency aid
- Building base-isolated aseismic structures
Show answer
Building base-isolated aseismic structures. Hazard-resistant design changes how the event affects buildings.
- Which is an example of modifying vulnerability?
- Community education and evacuation planning
- Building a sea wall
- Diverting lava with a channel
- Zoning land on a fault
Show answer
Community education and evacuation planning. Prepares people to cope.
- Almost 470,000 people were evacuated in the first days after the 2011 Japan disaster and almost 30,000 were still in temporary accommodation in November 2025. What percentage of the original number is that? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
6.4 %. 30,000 / 470,000 x 100 = 6.4%.
- Explain why event modification is used less in developing countries.
Show answer
Hazard-resistant buildings and engineered defences are expensive to build, retrofit and maintain, and governments may lack the money and the capacity to enforce building codes, so cheaper vulnerability measures are often used instead.. Cost and enforcement.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: 2010 Haiti earthquake
- Nippon.com Japan Data (2026): The state of recovery in Tohoku 15 years after 3/11 (Reconstruction Agency figures)
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WGE04/01 examiners' report, January 2025 series (published March 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.