All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 1: Why tectonic disasters have variable impacts
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
The third key idea of 4.3.2 is that tectonic disasters have variable impacts for many reasons: the contrasting impacts of events in developed and developing contexts, socio-economic and geographical factors, and governance.
Contrasting events
(4.3.2 key idea 3 a) Compare events of similar physical size in different contexts:
- Haiti, 12 January 2010: magnitude 7.0, focus about 13 km deep, epicentre about 25 km from Port-au-Prince. About 3 million people affected, over 1 million made homeless, over 200,000 structures marked for demolition or major repair; death toll estimates range from 85,000 to 316,000. A cholera epidemic from October 2010 killed more than 9,200 by 2016 (Britannica).
- Japan, 11 March 2011: magnitude 9.0, with tsunami. 19,782 dead and 2,550 missing (Reconstruction Agency). Far more energy than Haiti, yet far fewer deaths from shaking; most deaths came from the tsunami, and the June 2024 mark scheme notes Japan was not adequately prepared for it despite sea walls on parts of the coast and a developed warning system.
- Turkiye-Syria, 6 February 2023: magnitude 7.8: over 50,000 dead in Turkiye and 5,900 in Syria (UN News, 2024), where conflict had already weakened capacity.
- Eyjafjallajokull, Iceland, 2010: no deaths, but about 100,000 flights cancelled and about $1.7bn lost airline revenue (airline estimate reported by Al Jazeera): an economic disaster for a developed region.
Socio-economic and geographical factors
(4.3.2 key idea 3 b)
- Socio-economic: income and poverty (ability to build safely, insure, recover), education (knowing what to do), housing type (heavy concrete without reinforcement collapses; informal housing on slopes), access to healthcare.
- Geographical: population density (more people exposed), isolation (rural mountain villages in Nepal 2015 were hard to reach), urbanisation (rapid unplanned growth increases exposure), time of day, and physical factors such as soft sediments and steep slopes.
The Pressure and Release style of thinking links root causes (poverty, weak institutions) through dynamic pressures (rapid urbanisation) to unsafe conditions that meet the hazard.
Governance
(4.3.2 key idea 3 c) Governance is how well a country is run at national and local level: enforcing building codes, land-use planning, corruption levels, emergency planning and the ability to coordinate a response. Strong governance builds resilience; weak governance creates vulnerability. Haiti lacked adequate building codes (Britannica). In Japan, strict codes, drills and warning systems limited deaths from shaking, though the tsunami exceeded defences.
The January 2019 research focus asked students to examine how governance affects the management of a range of disasters, so governance is a likely exam angle.
Worked example
Haiti (2010, M7.0) had far more deaths than Japan (2011, M9.0) from ground shaking even though the Japanese earthquake released far more energy. Explain why.
- Building quality: Haiti lacked adequate building codes, so concrete buildings collapsed; Japan enforces strict aseismic codes.
- Location: Haiti's shallow focus was about 25 km from the dense capital; Japan's epicentre was offshore.
- Governance and wealth: Japan has drills, warnings and emergency services; in Haiti the UN headquarters and many government buildings were badly damaged.
Answer: Vulnerability (buildings, poverty, governance) and location matter more than magnitude for death tolls.
Check yourself
- Airlines lost about $1.7 billion in revenue and about 100,000 flights were cancelled after the 2010 Eyjafjallajokull eruption. What was the mean revenue lost per cancelled flight, in dollars?
Show answer
$17000. 1,700,000,000 / 100,000 = $17,000.
- About 3 million Haitians were affected in 2010 and over 1 million were made homeless. What percentage of those affected were made homeless? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Show answer
33 %. 1 / 3 x 100 = 33%.
- Which is an example of governance reducing vulnerability?
- A high magnitude earthquake
- Enforcing building codes and land-use planning
- A steep coastline
- Living near a plate boundary
Show answer
Enforcing building codes and land-use planning. Governance is how well rules are made and enforced.
- Why is Eyjafjallajokull 2010 often used as a contrasting case study?
- It caused the largest tsunami in history
- It was the deadliest eruption of the century
- It caused no deaths but major economic disruption across Europe
- It occurred in a developing country
Show answer
It caused no deaths but major economic disruption across Europe. Ash grounded about 100,000 flights.
- Which geographical factor made relief slow in rural areas after the 2015 Nepal earthquake?
- Isolation of mountain villages and landslides blocking roads
- Flat terrain
- Very low population
- Distance from any plate boundary
Show answer
Isolation of mountain villages and landslides blocking roads. Isolation is a named geographical factor.
- Suggest why the death toll in Syria from the 2023 earthquake may have been made worse by human factors.
Show answer
Years of conflict had damaged buildings, hospitals and infrastructure and weakened governance, so emergency response and international aid were harder to deliver and people were already vulnerable.. Conflict weakened capacity and governance.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: 2010 Haiti earthquake
- Nippon.com Japan Data (2026): The state of recovery in Tohoku 15 years after 3/11 (Reconstruction Agency figures)
- UN News (6 February 2024): One year on, for survivors of Turkiye-Syria quakes the suffering is far from over
- Al Jazeera (22 April 2010): Airlines count volcano chaos cost
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WGE04/01 research focus (pre-release), January 2019
- Pearson WGE04/01 research focus (pre-release), June 2019
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.