All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Option 1: Prediction and forecasting
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
4.3.3 asks 'How successful is the management of tectonic disasters?' Its first key idea is that prediction and forecasting are important elements of management, but their accuracy depends on hazard type and on technology.
Prediction versus forecasting
- Prediction states when and where a hazard will occur (and ideally how big).
- Forecasting gives a probability that a hazard of a certain size will occur in an area over a period (January 2025 mark scheme).
Accuracy varies by hazard (4.3.3 a):
- Earthquakes cannot be predicted in time; their likely location can be identified from fault maps (spatially predictable, temporally not). Early-warning systems detect P waves and give seconds of warning.
- Volcanoes often give warning signs: ground deformation, increased small earthquakes, gas emissions, temperature changes, so eruptions can often be predicted days to weeks ahead, though not always their size.
- Tsunami can be predicted once an earthquake has occurred: ocean-bottom pressure sensors (such as DART buoys) and models give warnings of minutes to hours depending on distance.
Technology and its limits
(4.3.3 b) Prediction relies on complex, expensive monitoring: seismometer networks, GPS and satellite radar (InSAR) for ground deformation, gas spectrometers, tiltmeters and ocean buoys. These are not universally available: many volcanoes in poorer countries are poorly monitored.
The Indian Ocean had no tsunami warning system in 2004, when nearly 230,000 died; the Indian Ocean Tsunami Warning and Mitigation System, coordinated through UNESCO, was set up afterwards (EARTH Magazine). Warning also needs communication to reach people and people who trust and act on it.
Merapi 2010 (VEI 4): monitoring and warnings allowed exclusion zones and the displacement of nearly 400,000 people, and the risk reduction strategy 'saved many lives' (Subandriyo and others, 2023).
| Hazard | Spatial prediction | Temporal prediction | Warning time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earthquake | Good (fault maps) | Poor | Seconds (early warning) |
| Volcano | Good (known volcanoes) | Moderate to good | Days to weeks |
| Tsunami | Good once quake detected | Good once quake detected | Minutes to hours |
Hazard mapping
(4.3.3 c) Forecasting risk is possible through hazard mapping: maps of expected ground shaking, liquefaction potential, lava and lahar paths and tsunami inundation. They inform land-use zoning, building codes and evacuation routes. Mapping is not prediction: it shows where risk is high, not when an event will occur.
The January 2025 question was: '"Prediction and forecasting are the most effective way of reducing the vulnerability of communities to tectonic hazards." Discuss.' The mark scheme expected candidates to define vulnerability, compare hazard types, and recognise that prediction does not reduce vulnerability where buildings are weak, training is limited or warnings do not reach people.
Worked example
Why can volcanic eruptions usually be predicted more successfully than earthquakes?
- Magma rising before an eruption produces measurable signs: swarms of small earthquakes, ground swelling, gas changes.
- Earthquakes release stress suddenly on faults with no reliable short-term precursor.
- So monitoring can show an eruption is likely within days or weeks, but not when a fault will slip.
Answer: Volcanoes give measurable precursors; earthquakes do not.
Check yourself
- Which is a forecast rather than a prediction?
- An eruption will begin next Tuesday at noon
- A 30% probability of a major earthquake on a fault in the next 30 years
- A tsunami will reach the harbour in 14 minutes
- An earthquake will strike at 3 am
Show answer
A 30% probability of a major earthquake on a fault in the next 30 years. Forecasts are probabilities over time.
- Which is a warning sign used to predict volcanic eruptions?
- Changes in ocean salinity
- Rising air pressure
- Bird migration
- Ground deformation and swarms of small earthquakes
Show answer
Ground deformation and swarms of small earthquakes. Monitored by GPS, InSAR and seismometers.
- What is the main limitation of hazard mapping?
- It is impossible to produce
- It shows where risk is high but not when an event will happen
- It only works for volcanoes
- It always increases vulnerability
Show answer
It shows where risk is high but not when an event will happen. Mapping forecasts risk, not timing.
- Why was the death toll so high in the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami?
- The earthquake was small
- It occurred inland
- There was no Indian Ocean tsunami warning system
- Warnings were ignored in every country
Show answer
There was no Indian Ocean tsunami warning system. Only the Pacific had a system at the time.
- The June 2025 mark scheme says the 2010 Merapi eruption affected about 350,000 people but caused around 300 deaths. How many deaths is that per 1,000 people affected? Give your answer to 2 decimal places.
Show answer
0.86. 300 / 350,000 x 1,000 = 0.86.
- Explain why prediction alone may not reduce vulnerability in a developing country.
Show answer
Even if a hazard is predicted, warnings may not reach people, they may lack transport or safe shelter to evacuate, and weak buildings and poverty mean losses are still high, so other measures are needed.. Warnings must reach people and they must be able to act.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WGE04/01 mark scheme, June 2025
- EARTH Magazine (3 November 2014): Benchmarks, 26 December 2004, Indian Ocean tsunami strikes
- Subandriyo, Gertisser, Aisyah and others (2023), An overview of the large-magnitude (VEI 4) eruption of Merapi in 2010, in Merapi Volcano (Springer), University of Twente record
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.