All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1A.1 The aristocratic revolt and the calling of the Estates-General
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
Between 1787 and 1789 the nobility and the parlements blocked royal reform. The crown, unable to raise money, agreed to call the Estates-General.
Resistance to reform
- The Paris Parlement opposed Calonne's further loans and refused to register them.
- It was hostile to Brienne's land tax reforms and refused to register the edicts, leading to calls for an Estates-General.
- It declared that only an Estates-General could consent to new taxes.
The May Edicts and the revolt of the nobles
The May Edicts of 1788 removed the nobles' right to register protests against royal decrees. Nobles resented this, producing the Revolt of the Nobles:
- violent opposition such as the Day of Tiles;
- unauthorised assemblies of the Second Estate demanding that an Estates-General consent to new taxes;
- some aristocratic members of the Church withdrew support over the *don gratuit*.
Deadlock and surrender
Aristocratic resistance paralysed government. Only agreeing to call the Estates-General could break the deadlock. Necker was recalled as finance minister on 26 August 1788, as France neared bankruptcy. Then the weather and a poor harvest in 1788 caused an economic crisis in 1789, with riots in Paris and the countryside.
How significant was the revolt?
For: it was the most violent opposition Louis XVI had yet faced and forced the calling of the Estates-General.
Against: the revolt was uncoordinated and sporadic, and the Revolution's decisive steps came from the Third Estate (the Tennis Court Oath) and from popular action (the Bastille).
Worked example
Why did the aristocratic revolt force the king to call the Estates-General?
- The parlements and nobles refused to accept new taxes.
- They argued only the Estates-General could consent to taxes.
- Without new taxes the bankrupt crown could not govern, so the king gave way.
Answer: Because the deadlock over taxation could only be broken by the Estates-General.
Check yourself
- What did the May Edicts of 1788 do that angered the nobility?
- Removed their right to register protests against royal decrees
- Abolished all noble titles
- Doubled the taille
- Closed the churches
Show answer
Removed their right to register protests against royal decrees. The edicts removed the nobles' right to register protests, which led to the Revolt of the Nobles.
- The Day of Tiles is an example of
- a royal victory over the Parlement
- a peasant uprising in 1793
- violent opposition during the aristocratic revolt
- the storming of the Bastille
Show answer
violent opposition during the aristocratic revolt. Pearson cites the Day of Tiles as the most violent opposition Louis had faced.
- In which year was Necker recalled as finance minister, as the Estates-General was being summoned?
Show answer
1788. He was recalled on 26 August 1788.
- What constitutional claim did the Paris Parlement make about taxation?
- The king could tax without limit
- The Church should set all taxes
- Taxes should be voted by the army
- Only an Estates-General could consent to new taxes
Show answer
Only an Estates-General could consent to new taxes. This claim pushed the crown towards calling the Estates-General.
- Which point COUNTERS the view that the aristocratic revolt was the main reason for the onset of revolution?
- It paralysed royal government
- The revolt was uncoordinated and petered out
- It produced the Day of Tiles
- Nobles demanded an Estates-General
Show answer
The revolt was uncoordinated and petered out. The other three support the view; the revolt's weakness counters it.
- How did the 1788 harvest contribute to the crisis of 1789?
Show answer
The poor harvest raised bread prices, causing hunger and riots in Paris and the countryside.. A poor harvest in 1788 caused an economic crisis in 1789 with riots in town and country.
Sources
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, January 2020
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, January 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Jacques Necker
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1A France in Revolution, 1774 to 1799 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.