All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations

1A.1 War, debt and failed reform, 1774 to 87

Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations

France's debt grew worse in the 1780s. The specification asks how far problems deteriorated before 1789, the impact of the American Revolution and the failings of Louis XVI and his ministers.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The American war

France joined the War of American Independence on the side of the colonists against Britain. Pearson's mark schemes stress:

Necker's loans

Jacques Necker controlled royal finances from October 1776 and was director general of finances from June 1777. He paid for the war with loans rather than new taxes. In 1781 his *Compte rendu au Roi* claimed a surplus of 10 million livres, when the real position was a deficit of about 46 million livres. He was forced out in May 1781.

Calonne and the Notables

The financial reforms of Turgot, Necker and Calonne added to the crisis rather than solving it. Calonne proposed an Assembly of Notables, which met in February 1787: he offered the upper classes a role in law-making in return for giving up privileges, especially the nobility's exemption from taxes. The Notables would not accept this.

Other pressures

Worked example

Necker's Compte rendu claimed a surplus of 10 million livres. The real deficit was about 46 million livres. How large was the gap between his claim and reality?

  1. Claimed: +10 million. Real: -46 million.
  2. Gap = 10 + 46.

Answer: About 56 million livres.

Key idea: American war: huge borrowing, triple vingtieme 1782, ideas of liberty (Lafayette). Necker funded it with loans; Compte rendu 1781 hid a deficit. Calonne's Assembly of Notables (Feb 1787) refused to give up tax privileges. Harvests and court spending added to discontent.

Check yourself

  1. Necker's Compte rendu (1781) claimed a surplus of 10 million livres while the real deficit was about 46 million livres. By how many million livres did it misstate the position?
    Show answer

    56 million livres. From +10 to -46 is a difference of 56 million livres.

  2. In which year did France impose the triple vingtieme to help pay for the American war?
    Show answer

    1782. Pearson's June 2025 mark scheme dates the triple vingtieme to 1782.

  3. How did Necker mainly pay for French involvement in the American war?
    • By a new land tax on nobles
    • By borrowing
    • By selling Church lands
    • By printing assignats
    Show answer

    By borrowing. Necker tried to fund the war without new taxes, relying on loans.

  4. In which year did Calonne's Assembly of Notables meet?
    Show answer

    1787. It met in February 1787.

  5. What did Calonne ask the Assembly of Notables to accept?
    • An end to privileges such as the nobility's exemption from taxes
    • The abolition of the monarchy
    • A declaration of war on Britain
    • The election of bishops
    Show answer

    An end to privileges such as the nobility's exemption from taxes. He offered a role in law-making in return for giving up privileges, especially tax exemption.

  6. Which of these was an IDEOLOGICAL effect of the American Revolution on France?
    • It raised interest rates on royal loans
    • It damaged French trade
    • It set a precedent for overthrowing a ruler in the interests of the ruled
    • It led to the triple vingtieme
    Show answer

    It set a precedent for overthrowing a ruler in the interests of the ruled. The other options are financial or economic effects.

  7. Explain one way the American war made the French monarchy's problems worse.
    Show answer

    It was very expensive, so the crown borrowed heavily and fell deeper into debt.. The war's cost, paid by loans, deepened the debt and forced new taxes.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.