All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
2C Russia: collectivisation and the Five-Year Plans, 1928 to 53
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Agricultural collectivisation and its impact is a nominated area. Stalin rejected the NEP for planned industrialisation and collectivisation, driven by ideology, defence needs and political rivalry.
Collectivisation
- 1928: a grain shortfall led to forced requisitions; at the end of 1929 policy became the 'liquidation of the kulak as a class'.
- By 1 March 1930 more than 70 million peasants were on collective farms. On 2 March Stalin published 'Dizzy with Success' (Britannica: 'Dizzy from Success'), and 40 to 50 million left the collectives in the following months.
- Over 27,000 urban workers (the 'twenty-five-thousanders') volunteered to enforce it; the OGPU rounded up opponents (Pearson June 2021 mark scheme).
- 62% of peasant households were collectivised by 1932 and 93% by 1937 (Pearson June 2018 mark scheme).
The cost
- Official 1934 figures: 26.6 million cattle (42.6%) and 63.4 million sheep (65.1%) lost, as peasants slaughtered animals rather than hand them over.
- About 10 million were deported, and at least 2 million died prematurely (Britannica).
- Famine, winter 1932 to 33: 4 to 5 million died in Ukraine and 2 to 3 million in the North Caucasus and Lower Volga, while about 1.7 million tons of grain were exported.
The Five-Year Plans
- The First Plan was announced in April to May 1929 with growth targets of 18 to 20% a year, later raised; it was declared complete at the end of 1932, though none of its targets was reached. Later Soviet economists put true growth at about 3.5% a year (Britannica).
- 1928 to 41: steel production quadrupled and coal rose six-fold; the Fourth Plan (1946 to 50) raised industrial production 75% above 1940 (Pearson June 2018 mark scheme).
- Human cost: real wages in 1933 were about one-tenth of 1926 to 27; internal passports (December 1932); death penalty for theft of state property (August 1932); forced labour, such as on the Baltic to White Sea Canal.
Worked example
Stalin's 1929 speech says kulaks once produced over 600 million poods of grain but can now be eliminated 'as a class'. Why is it valuable for the reasons for dekulakisation?
- Provenance: Stalin controlled policy; a Marxist audience; signals a new phase.
- Inferences: he had long wanted to attack the kulaks but needed their grain; claims collectives now made them unnecessary.
- Context: kulaks prospered under NEP; collectivisation began in 1928 to feed industrialisation and pay for imports.
Answer: Valuable as the leader's own justification, though its claims of success are propaganda.
Check yourself
- What did Stalin's article 'Dizzy with Success' (March 1930) lead to?
- The start of the NEP
- 40 to 50 million peasants leaving the collectives
- The end of the Five-Year Plans
- The Kirov murder
Show answer
40 to 50 million peasants leaving the collectives. Stalin blamed local officials for excesses, and many peasants left.
- What percentage of peasant households were collectivised by 1937, according to Pearson's June 2018 mark scheme?
Show answer
93 %. 93% (62% by 1932).
- Official figures say 26.6 million cattle were lost, 42.6% of the herd. About how many million cattle were there before? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Show answer
62 million. 26.6 / 0.426 = 62.4, so about 62 million.
- Who were the 'kulaks' in Stalinist propaganda?
- Factory managers
- Members of the Politburo
- Richer peasants, and any peasant who resisted collectivisation
- Red Army officers
Show answer
Richer peasants, and any peasant who resisted collectivisation. The label was stretched to anyone who resisted.
- Which regions suffered most in the famine of 1932 to 33?
- Ukraine, the North Caucasus and the Lower Volga
- Moscow and Leningrad
- The Baltic states
- Siberia and the Far East
Show answer
Ukraine, the North Caucasus and the Lower Volga. Grain-producing regions were hit hardest by requisitions.
- Coal production rose six-fold between 1928 and 1941. By what percentage did it increase?
Show answer
500 %. Six times the original is an increase of 5 times the original: 500%.
- In which year was the First Five-Year Plan declared complete?
Show answer
1932. At the end of 1932, though none of its targets was reached.
- Give two reasons why Stalin introduced collectivisation.
Show answer
To get grain to feed the towns and to export to pay for industrial machinery, and to destroy the kulaks as a class enemy.. Grain for industry and exports, and ideological war on the kulaks.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 2 (WHI02) Option 1C: Russia, 1917 to 91, from Lenin to Yeltsin (Issue 1, April 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Soviet Union, Toward the second revolution, 1927 to 30
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Soviet Union, Industrialization, 1929 to 34
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, January 2022
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, June 2021
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, June 2018
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.