All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
2C Russia: Marxism, War Communism and the NEP, 1917 to 28
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Lenin and his associates brought Marxist ideas to economic policy: a command economy without markets or free enterprise. In practice they shifted pragmatically, first to War Communism, then to the New Economic Policy.
Ideology
A command economy means the state, not the market, decides what is produced, how and for whom. The Bolsheviks rejected private enterprise, though the 1917 land decrees let peasants take the land.
War Communism, 1918 to 21
Introduced during the civil war: nationalisation of industry and forced requisitioning of grain. It supplied the Red Army and helped win the civil war, but by 1921 industrial production had fallen to about 20% of the 1913 level and agricultural output to about 48% (Pearson January 2021 mark scheme). Peasants resisted, and revolts such as Kronstadt (1921) followed.
The NEP, 1921 to 28
The New Economic Policy (1921) was a retreat: grain requisitioning gave way to a tax, and small private trade returned. The state kept the commanding heights (large industry, banking, foreign trade). Within a year nearly 75% of trade was conducted by private traders, the Nepmen, whom many communists despised. Kulaks (richer peasants) prospered. By 1928 Stalin opposed the NEP and believed kulaks were hoarding grain (there was a grain shortfall of about 2 million tons in 1928).
Worked example
Was the attempt to create a command economy in 1917 to 28 a complete failure? (Pearson January 2021 paper)
- Failure: War Communism's chaos (industry 20%, agriculture 48% of 1913); the NEP admitted failure; Nepmen ran 75% of trade.
- Not complete: War Communism won the civil war; the state kept the commanding heights; NEP taxes funded factories and electrification; the command economy returned in 1928.
Answer: A judgement might argue it failed in 1917 to 21 but was postponed rather than abandoned.
Check yourself
- In which year was the New Economic Policy introduced?
Show answer
1921. 1921, after the civil war and the Kronstadt revolt.
- By 1921, industrial production had fallen to about what percentage of its 1913 level, according to Pearson's January 2021 mark scheme?
Show answer
20 %. About 20%.
- What was a key feature of War Communism?
- Private trade by Nepmen
- Collective farms run by tractor stations
- Forced requisitioning of grain from peasants
- Foreign joint ventures
Show answer
Forced requisitioning of grain from peasants. Grain was seized to feed the army and towns.
- Under the NEP, what did the state keep control of?
- Every small shop
- The 'commanding heights' such as large industry and banking
- All peasant land
- Nothing: it privatised the whole economy
Show answer
The 'commanding heights' such as large industry and banking. Small trade was private; large industry stayed state-run.
- Who were the Nepmen?
- Red Army commissars
- Members of Gosplan
- Peasants forced into collectives
- Private traders who flourished under the NEP
Show answer
Private traders who flourished under the NEP. They ran most trade within a year of the NEP.
- Agricultural output fell to about 48% of its 1913 level by 1921. By what percentage had it fallen from 1913?
Show answer
52 %. 100 - 48 = 52%.
- Why was the NEP seen by many communists as a retreat?
Show answer
Because it brought back private trade and profit, which went against communist ideology.. Restoring markets and profit contradicted Marxist aims.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 2 (WHI02) Option 1C: Russia, 1917 to 91, from Lenin to Yeltsin (Issue 1, April 2018)
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, January 2022
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, January 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.