All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Unit 2 skills: the Section B breadth essay
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Section B is worth half the paper. You answer one essay from three, and every essay asks for a judgement about a feature of your option over at least a decade. This lesson turns the mark scheme into a plan you can use.
What examiners reward
Essays test AO1: knowledge used to analyse and reach a substantiated judgement about one of these second-order concepts: cause, consequence, change, continuity, similarity, difference, significance. The stems are 'How far ...?', 'To what extent ...?' and 'How accurate is it to say that ...?'. Some questions name a factor ('Was X the main reason ...?'), so you must weigh it against other factors.
Levels: 1 (1 to 6), 2 (7 to 12), 3 (13 to 18), 4 (19 to 25). Level 4 explores key issues through the relationships between features, uses sufficient knowledge, applies valid criteria and is logically organised.
Planning in a few minutes
1. Underline the key term (main reason, significant, changed, similar) and the date range.
2. Choose three or four themes; Pearson's reports advise weighing them against each other rather than describing each.
3. Decide your criteria for judgement (for example, which factor affected the most people, lasted longest, or made the others possible).
4. Write a line of argument in the introduction and keep to it.
5. Conclude with a supported judgement, not a summary.
Common faults (from Pearson's reports)
- Description that is not linked to the question.
- Drifting outside the date range or the country (for example, into the USSR or the USA in a China essay).
- In a two-factor comparison, adding a third factor that earns no credit.
- Thin knowledge: use precise names, dates and figures from across the period.
- A judgement that is asserted, not supported.
Worked example
Plan: 'How accurate is it to say that Gandhi was crucial in advancing Indian independence in 1920 to 39?' (Pearson specimen paper, 2A)
- For: mass satyagraha in 1920 to 22 and 1930; boycotts let ordinary people take part; the 1931 agreement with Viceroy Irwin.
- Against: the 1920 to 22 campaign was abandoned after Chauri Chaura; the Round Table Conferences showed he did not speak for all Indians; friction with the Muslim League.
- Criterion: did his actions change British policy, or did other pressures matter more?
Answer: A judgement such as: crucial in turning nationalism into a mass movement, but less decisive in winning concessions, which came through negotiation and wider pressures.
Check yourself
- What is the lowest mark in Level 4 for a Section B essay?
Show answer
19. Level 4 runs from 19 to 25.
- Which of these is one of the second-order concepts an essay can target?
- Significance
- Provenance
- Reliability
- Inference
Show answer
Significance. Cause, consequence, change, continuity, similarity, difference and significance.
- Pearson's examiners advise that a strong essay plan should
- list every event in date order
- cover as many themes as possible briefly
- choose three or four key themes and weigh them against each other
- start writing immediately without a plan
Show answer
choose three or four key themes and weigh them against each other. Weighing a few themes produces analysis, not description.
- An essay asks whether factor X was more significant than factor Y. What earns no credit?
- Setting criteria to compare X and Y
- Adding a third factor Z
- Using precise evidence for X
- Reaching a judgement on X against Y
Show answer
Adding a third factor Z. Pearson's June 2025 report notes that a third factor earned no credit in a two-factor question.
- A China essay drifts into detail about Soviet politics. Pearson's guidance says this is
- a strength: it shows breadth
- required for Level 4
- acceptable if it is in the date range
- a weakness: keep the focus on China
Show answer
a weakness: keep the focus on China. The China topic guide warns students to keep their focus on China.
- What is normally the shortest period covered by a Section B essay?
- One year
- A decade
- Five years
- Half a century
Show answer
A decade. Pearson's guide says a decade is normally the shortest period.
- What does it mean to apply 'valid criteria' when reaching a judgement in an essay?
Show answer
It means stating how you will judge, such as which factor had the widest or longest impact, and using that test to decide.. Criteria are the tests you use to weigh factors.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson WHI02/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI02/1D mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1A examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI02/1D examiners' report, January 2025
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 2 (WHI02) Option 1B: China, 1900 to 76 (Issue 1, April 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.