All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Unit 2 skills: question (b), how much weight?
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Question (b) asks how much weight you would give a source as evidence for an enquiry. It is marked out of 15 in four levels. Unlike question (a), you must weigh value against limitations and reach a judgement.
What the question rewards
The stem is 'How much weight do you give the evidence of Source 2 for an enquiry into ...?'. You must:
- Interrogate the evidence: what can be accepted, and what is claim or opinion?
- Use context to confirm or challenge what the source says, and to show its limitations.
- Use provenance to judge reliability: author's position and stance, purpose, audience, date, censorship.
- Reach a judgement on how much weight the evidence will bear, using clear criteria.
Pearson's guide warns that information should not be accepted at face value, and that opinion is not automatically dubious: context may show an opinion is authoritative.
The levels
| Level | Marks | What it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 to 3 | Surface comprehension; stereotyped judgements about reliability. |
| 2 | 4 to 7 | Some analysis; reliability addressed mainly through provenance. |
| 3 | 8 to 11 | Detailed context explains inferences; weight judged using nature, purpose or author's position, with valid criteria and some justification. |
| 4 | 12 to 15 | Interrogates the evidence, distinguishing information from claim or opinion; context shows limitations and the values of the society; a justified judgement on the weight the evidence will bear. |
Paraphrased from the generic descriptors in Pearson WHI02 mark schemes.
Weighing well
- Avoid stereotypes such as 'it is biased so it is useless' or 'it is primary so it is reliable'.
- A biased source can be strong evidence of the attitudes of its author or audience.
- Omissions count only when the author left something out deliberately or through ignorance; noting that a source does not cover everything does not set its weight.
- Example from Pearson's June 2023 2B mark scheme: a report by an expelled communist written about two years after 1949 claims US aid failed because of Chiang's corruption. Context supports part of it (the USA gave the GMD about $3 billion and refused more funding by January 1949), but his ideological hostility to the USA must be weighed.
Worked example
Otto Braun's account of the Long March is offered for an enquiry into Mao's leadership on the march. How much weight should it carry?
- For: Braun was an eyewitness and military adviser.
- Against: Mao removed him from the leadership at the Zunyi conference (January 1935), so he had reason to be hostile; he could not speak Chinese and lost his diary.
- Context: Mao took control after Zunyi and directed the changes of route to avoid the GMD (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
Answer: Some weight on the hardships he saw, but little on his judgement of Mao, which context challenges.
Check yourself
- How does question (b) differ from question (a)?
- It requires weighing limitations as well as value to reach a judgement
- It does not need any own knowledge
- It is marked out of 10
- It must compare the source with Source 1
Show answer
It requires weighing limitations as well as value to reach a judgement. Weight means judging how far the evidence can be trusted for the enquiry.
- What is the lowest mark in Level 4 for question (b)?
Show answer
12. Level 4 runs from 12 to 15 marks.
- Which statement is a 'stereotypical judgement' that keeps an answer in Level 1?
- It is a primary source so it must be reliable
- As a private diary written the same day, it had no audience to persuade
- Censorship of the press means the report may hide criticism of the government
- The author was removed from power by the man he criticises
Show answer
It is a primary source so it must be reliable. Generic claims about 'primary' sources are stereotyped.
- According to Pearson's guide, how should opinion in a source be treated?
- It should always be ignored
- It always reduces weight to zero
- It should be treated as fact
- It is not automatically dubious; context may show it is authoritative
Show answer
It is not automatically dubious; context may show it is authoritative. Opinion can be well informed; context decides.
- When does an omission reduce a source's weight?
- Whenever the source does not mention every cause
- When the author left something out deliberately or through ignorance
- Only if the source is a speech
- Never
Show answer
When the author left something out deliberately or through ignorance. Pearson's reports say omissions matter only when deliberate or due to ignorance.
- A speech by a minister defends a policy in glowing terms. For which enquiry could it carry most weight?
- How well the policy worked in practice
- How ordinary people suffered under the policy
- What opponents thought of the policy
- What the government wanted people to believe about the policy
Show answer
What the government wanted people to believe about the policy. Propaganda is strong evidence of the government's aims and claims.
- Give two ways you should use contextual knowledge in question (b).
Show answer
To confirm or support what the source says, and to challenge it or show its limitations.. Context is used both to support claims and to challenge them.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson WHI02/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI02/1C mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI02/1A examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI02/1D examiners' report, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.