All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation

Unit 2 skills: question (a), why is the source valuable?

Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation

Question (a) asks why a source is valuable for a particular enquiry. It is marked out of 10 in three levels. This lesson shows how to build an answer from the source's content, its provenance and your own knowledge of the context.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

What the question rewards

The stem is 'Why is Source 1 valuable to the historian for an enquiry into ...?'. You must:

Pearson's guide says limitations are not the focus: an answer with no limitations can still reach the top level, and examiners' reports say discussing limitations earns no credit.

The levels

LevelMarksWhat it looks like
11 to 3Surface comprehension: quotes or paraphrases; context listed; assertive evaluation.
24 to 6Some analysis; inferences start; value addressed mainly through provenance.
37 to 10Valid, developed inferences; context used to explain them; value judged through the nature, purpose or author's position, linked to the enquiry.

Paraphrased from the generic descriptors in Pearson WHI02 mark schemes.

A model method

1. Underline the enquiry: every point must link to it.

2. Pick two or three inferences and quote briefly to support each.

3. For each, add context that explains or confirms it (a date, law, event or figure).

4. Use provenance to say why the source is especially useful: an insider's knowledge, an immediate reaction, a private document with no reason to deceive, or a public statement that shows what a government wanted people to believe.

Example from Pearson's January 2024 2A mark scheme: an All-India Congress Committee resolution is valuable for the reasons Gandhi began 'Quit India' (1942) because it states Congress's intentions directly, and context confirms it: in 1939 Britain declared war on India's behalf without consulting Indians.

Worked example

A diary written inside the foreign legations in Beijing in 1900 is offered for an enquiry into how serious the Boxer Rebellion was for foreigners. Why is it valuable?

  1. Provenance: the writer was inside the besieged legations and wrote at the time, so it records an immediate reaction.
  2. Inference: it describes huge crowds and slogans such as 'Kill the foreign devils!', suggesting a real threat to foreign lives.
  3. Context: Boxers killed the German ambassador in Beijing, and an Eight-Nation force of 20,000 relieved the legations on 14 August 1900 (Pearson June 2023 mark scheme).

Answer: It is valuable because an eyewitness inside the legations, writing immediately, shows the scale of the threat, which the known context confirms.

Key idea: Question (a): inferences relevant to the enquiry + provenance explaining value + context explaining inferences. Limitations earn no credit.

Check yourself

  1. What is the main focus of question (a)?
    • Listing every weakness of the source
    • Summarising the source line by line
    • What the source can contribute to the enquiry
    • Comparing the two sources
    Show answer

    What the source can contribute to the enquiry. Question (a) is about value; Pearson says limitations are not the focus.

  2. Which is an inference rather than a paraphrase?
    • The writer's demand for unity 'at the present moment' suggests the regime felt under threat
    • The source says unity is particularly necessary at the present moment
    • The source is about unity
    • The source was written by a congress
    Show answer

    The writer's demand for unity 'at the present moment' suggests the regime felt under threat. An inference draws out what the words imply.

  3. To reach Level 3 in question (a) an answer must
    • quote as much of the source as possible
    • list the dates of the period
    • make developed inferences and judge value using the source's nature, purpose or author's position
    • explain why the source is unreliable
    Show answer

    make developed inferences and judge value using the source's nature, purpose or author's position. That is the Level 3 descriptor in the mark schemes.

  4. What is the lowest mark in Level 3 for question (a)?
    Show answer

    7. Level 3 runs from 7 to 10 marks.

  5. How should own knowledge be used in question (a)?
    • As a separate paragraph of facts about the period
    • Only in the conclusion
    • To replace the source
    • To explain or support inferences drawn from the source
    Show answer

    To explain or support inferences drawn from the source. Examiners reward context that develops inferences, not free-standing knowledge.

  6. Pearson's June 2025 2A examiners' report criticised answers that called a source valuable simply because the author was
    • a government official
    • 'there at the time'
    • writing in a newspaper
    • an Indian nationalist
    Show answer

    'there at the time'. Generic 'there at the time' claims are not enough; explain what the author's position adds.

  7. Name two aspects of provenance you should consider when judging why a source is valuable.
    Show answer

    The author and their position, and the purpose of the source (also its date and audience).. Provenance means the author, date, nature, purpose and audience of a source.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.