All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3A USA: a house divided, the breakdown of compromise, 1850 to 58
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Key topic 4 runs from 1850 to 1861. This lesson traces how the Compromise of 1850 unravelled as the slave-owning South and the more populous North drew apart.
Two economies and the Compromise of 1850
- The slave-owning South was divided from the more populous North by clashing economic interests: only one-ninth of US industrial capacity was in the southern states (Topic Guide; Pearson June 2025 mark scheme).
- The Compromise of 1850, Henry Clay's last great triumph, was passed in September 1850 after Stephen Douglas brought in substitute bills, with Daniel Webster's support. Its five laws admitted California as a free state, set up territorial government for Utah and New Mexico, settled the Texas boundary, strengthened the Fugitive Slave Act and abolished the slave trade in Washington, DC (US National Archives; Britannica).
- The Fugitive Slave Act required officials in every state to help arrest suspected fugitives and punished anyone who helped an escape, which angered many in the North (US National Archives).
Anti-slavery feeling and Kansas
- *Uncle Tom's Cabin* (book form 1852) sold some 300,000 copies in the USA in the year after publication; abolitionists took it up eagerly and the South denounced it (Britannica).
- The Kansas-Nebraska Act (30 May 1854), Douglas's bill, repealed the Missouri Compromise and let the territories decide slavery by popular sovereignty. The turmoil led to the new Republican Party (1854) and destroyed what remained of the Whigs (US Senate; Topic Guide).
- 'Bleeding Kansas': pro-slavery Missourians flooded in to vote illegally, and the pro-slavery side took the territorial legislature election of March 1855; on 21 May 1856 a pro-slavery posse sacked Lawrence, which northern journalists presented as a massacre. Some 55 people were killed in 1855 to 59 (History.com; Pearson June 2023 mark scheme).
1856 to 58: polarisation
- Congressman Preston Brooks attacked Senator Charles Sumner in Congress in 1856 ('Bleeding Sumner'). The Democrats split in 1856 (Topic Guide; Pearson June 2025 mark scheme).
- Dred Scott (6 March 1857): by 7 to 2 the Supreme Court, in Chief Justice Taney's opinion, ruled that black Americans were not and could never be citizens, and that Congress had no power to forbid slavery in the territories, so the Missouri Compromise (1820) was unconstitutional (Britannica). Abolitionists were outraged.
- The Lincoln-Douglas debates (1858).
- There was no strong leadership in the White House until Lincoln arrived in 1860 (Topic Guide).
Worked example
The Missouri Compromise dated from 1820. How long had it stood when the Kansas-Nebraska Act repealed it, and when Dred Scott called it unconstitutional?
- 1854 - 1820 = 34 years.
- 1857 - 1820 = 37 years.
Answer: 34 years and 37 years: a settlement that had held for a generation was swept away within three years, which shows how quickly compromise collapsed in the 1850s.
Check yourself
- In which year was the Dred Scott decision made?
Show answer
1857. 6 March 1857.
- Who attacked Senator Charles Sumner in Congress in 1856?
- John Brown
- Congressman Preston Brooks
- Stephen Douglas
- Jefferson Davis
Show answer
Congressman Preston Brooks. Brooks attacked Sumner ('Bleeding Sumner').
- What happened in the Kansas territorial legislature election of March 1855?
- Abolitionists won every seat
- Kansas voted to leave the Union
- Congress cancelled the election
- Pro-slavery Missourians voted illegally and the pro-slavery side won
Show answer
Pro-slavery Missourians voted illegally and the pro-slavery side won. Pro-slavery voters from Missouri flooded in, leading to violence.
- Which new party was founded in 1854 after the Kansas-Nebraska Act?
- The Republican Party
- The Whig Party
- The Federalist Party
- The Democratic Party
Show answer
The Republican Party. The turmoil created the Republican Party and destroyed the Whigs.
- Which part of the Compromise of 1850 most angered the North?
- Ending the slave trade in Washington, DC
- Settling the Texas boundary
- The strengthened Fugitive Slave Act
- Admitting California
Show answer
The strengthened Fugitive Slave Act. Officials everywhere had to help catch fugitives.
- What did the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 do?
- Repealed the Missouri Compromise and let the territories decide slavery by popular sovereignty
- Banned slavery in every territory
- Admitted California as a free state
- Abolished the slave trade in Washington, DC
Show answer
Repealed the Missouri Compromise and let the territories decide slavery by popular sovereignty. US Senate: it repealed the Missouri Compromise and allowed popular sovereignty.
- What did the Dred Scott decision rule about the territories?
- Slavery was banned there
- They must all become free states
- Congress had no power to forbid slavery there
- Each territory must hold a vote on secession
Show answer
Congress had no power to forbid slavery there. So the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional.
- Why did 'Bleeding Kansas' destabilise relations between North and South?
Show answer
Violence between pro-slavery and anti-slavery settlers convinced many that compromise over slavery in the territories was impossible.. The violence showed that compromise over the territories was breaking down.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3A: The USA, Independence to Civil War, 1763 to 1865 (Issue 1, January 2018)
- US National Archives, Milestone Documents: Compromise of 1850
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Compromise of 1850
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Uncle Tom's Cabin
- US Senate: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
- History.com: Bleeding Kansas
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Dred Scott decision
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.