All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3A USA: a house divided, Harpers Ferry to secession, 1859 to 61
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
The second half of key topic 4 covers the final slide to war: John Brown's raid, the bitterly contested election of 1860 and the secession of the southern states.
John Brown and Harpers Ferry, 1859
- John Brown, already notorious for violence in Kansas, led 21 recruits (including 5 black men) in a raid on Harpers Ferry on 16 to 18 October 1859. State and federal troops, the federal force commanded by Colonel Robert E. Lee, subdued them; Brown was indicted for treason and hanged before the end of the year (Britannica).
- Most Northerners denounced the raid, but it electrified the South and convinced planters that abolitionists would stop at nothing to end slavery (Britannica).
- Jefferson Davis cited it as grounds for leaving the Union; Frederick Douglass later said Brown 'did at least begin the war that ended slavery' (Pearson January 2022 mark scheme).
The election of 1860
- Abraham Lincoln, candidate of the antislavery Republican Party, was elected president on 6 November 1860 (Britannica) after a bitterly contested election (Topic Guide).
- Lincoln had hardly any support in the South and was an opponent of slavery; the South saw itself as a threatened minority (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
Secession, 1860 to 61
- South Carolina led: its convention voted unanimously for secession on 20 December 1860 (Encyclopedia.com). The Topic Guide's date of 1861 is when the other Confederate states followed.
- The Confederate States of America was formed at Montgomery, Alabama, on 4 February 1861, with Jefferson Davis as president.
- Fort Sumter was attacked on 12 April 1861 and surrendered on 13 April.
- In all 11 states seceded between December 1860 and April 1861 (Britannica; Pearson January 2022 mark scheme).
Worked example
Pearson's January 2022 paper set a southern newspaper on John Brown's raid against a speech by Frederick Douglass years later. Use them together.
- Source 1 (southern, close to events): Brown 'has been hanged'; 'there can be no Union unless this aggressive policy of the North is stopped'. Strong evidence of southern fear and anger.
- Source 2 (Douglass, speaking years later): Brown began 'the war that ended slavery'. Strong evidence of how abolitionists remembered him, written with hindsight to honour him.
- Context: Davis cited the raid as grounds for secession; 11 states seceded in 1860 to 61.
Answer: Together they show that North and South drew opposite meanings from the same event, which is itself evidence of how far the Union had divided.
Check yourself
- In which year did John Brown raid Harpers Ferry?
Show answer
1859. 16 to 18 October 1859.
- According to Pearson's January 2022 mark scheme, how many states seceded in 1860 to 61?
Show answer
11 states. 11 states.
- In which year did South Carolina's convention vote to secede?
Show answer
1860. 20 December 1860, unanimously.
- Who commanded the federal troops that helped subdue John Brown's raiders?
- Colonel Robert E. Lee
- Ulysses S. Grant
- Jefferson Davis
- Stephen Douglas
Show answer
Colonel Robert E. Lee. Britannica: the federal force was commanded by Lee.
- Who became president of the Confederate States in February 1861?
- Robert E. Lee
- John C. Calhoun
- Jefferson Davis
- Stephen Douglas
Show answer
Jefferson Davis. Chosen at Montgomery, Alabama, on 4 February 1861.
- Why did Lincoln's election alarm the South, according to Pearson's specimen mark scheme?
- He had hardly any southern support and opposed slavery
- He promised to abolish slavery at once by force
- He was a southern slaveholder
- He had won no northern states
Show answer
He had hardly any southern support and opposed slavery. The South saw itself as a threatened minority.
- How did most Northerners react to John Brown's raid, according to Britannica?
- They celebrated it as a victory
- They demanded war on the South
- They denounced it
- They ignored it completely
Show answer
They denounced it. A majority of Northerners denounced it, though the South saw it as proof of abolitionist intent.
- Why did the southern states secede in 1860 to 61?
Show answer
They feared that Lincoln, elected without southern support, would threaten slavery and their political and economic interests.. The South saw Lincoln's victory as a threat to slavery and to its power.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3A: The USA, Independence to Civil War, 1763 to 1865 (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Harpers Ferry Raid
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: American Civil War timeline
- Encyclopedia.com: South Carolina Ordinance of Secession (1860)
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, January 2022
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.