All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Unit 3 skills: the Section B thematic essay
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Section B is worth half the paper. Each essay picks up one of the option's themes and asks you to judge it across two or more key topics, often decades apart. This lesson shows the question types, the levels and a planning method.
Question types Pearson has set
- Comparison of two periods: whether the key features of British warfare in 1803 to 15 and 1899 to 1902 were 'essentially similar' (3B, June 2025).
- One factor across two periods: whether the effects of war were the most significant challenge facing Germany in 1870 to 79 and 1918 to 24 (3C, June 2025).
- A statement to assess: 'War created the Second Reich and war destroyed it.' (3C specimen).
- Turning point or change across a long span: whether the 1883 Supreme Court rulings were the most significant turning point in 1865 to 1900, or whether changing patterns of settlement and housing were the biggest influence on black lives in 1933 to 2009 (3D).
Pearson's guide notes that Unit 3 uses a wider range of stems and more complex judgements than Unit 2.
The levels
| Level | Marks | What it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 to 4 | Generalised statements; little range or depth; judgement missing or asserted. |
| 2 | 5 to 8 | Some analysis, but description not linked to the question; implicit criteria. |
| 3 | 9 to 14 | Some analysis of links between key features; criteria attempted but weakly substantiated. |
| 4 | 15 to 20 | Key issues explored through relationships between features; valid criteria applied; supported judgement. |
| 5 | 21 to 25 | Sustained analysis; precisely selected knowledge; criteria applied and their relative significance evaluated; coherent throughout. |
Paraphrased from the generic Section B descriptors in Pearson WHI03 mark schemes.
Planning a two-period essay
1. Underline the concept (similar, most significant, turning point, changed little) and every date range.
2. Pick three or four themes or factors and, for each, put evidence from each period side by side.
3. Set criteria (scale, duration, who was affected) and decide which criterion matters most: that is the Level 5 step.
4. Keep the plan short: Pearson's June 2025 reports say long plans cut writing time.
5. Conclude with a judgement that covers each period.
Common faults (Pearson reports)
- Narrative or generalised answers.
- Covering only one of the two periods, or straying outside the dates (one 3C report notes answers running past 1924).
- Arguing only one side.
- Lumping different Supreme Court decisions together instead of distinguishing them.
- Weak knowledge of one figure (for example, Honecker).
Worked example
Plan: how accurate is it to say that the effects of war were the most significant challenge facing Germany in 1870 to 79 and 1918 to 24? (3C, June 2025)
- 1870 to 79: the Second Reich was born out of war, but the greater challenges were divisions inside the new state (Catholics, socialists) that Bismarck tackled with the Kulturkampf and the Anti-Socialist Law.
- 1918 to 24: the effects of war dominate: defeat, the Treaty of Versailles, reparations and the Ruhr occupation; but Weimar's economic problems and political violence also matter.
- Criterion: which challenge most threatened the survival of the state?
Answer: A judgement might argue that war's effects were a far greater challenge in 1918 to 24 than in 1870 to 79, as the June 2025 report notes stronger answers did.
Check yourself
- What is the lowest mark in Level 5 for a Section B essay?
Show answer
21. Level 5 runs from 21 to 25.
- What distinguishes Level 5 from Level 4 in Section B?
- Including more dates
- Evaluating the relative significance of the criteria used
- Writing a longer introduction
- Quoting historians
Show answer
Evaluating the relative significance of the criteria used. Level 5 evaluates the relative significance of criteria.
- An essay names 1933 to 45 and 2000 to 09. What must the answer do?
- Choose the period you know better
- Cover only the later period
- Also cover 1945 to 2000 in detail
- Cover each period
Show answer
Cover each period. Covering only one period is a common fault in Pearson's reports.
- What do Pearson's June 2025 reports say about planning?
- Spend a short time planning; long plans cut writing time
- Spend half the time planning
- Do not plan at all
- Write the plan in full sentences
Show answer
Spend a short time planning; long plans cut writing time. A short plan is advised.
- An essay on 1918 to 24 continues into 1929. Pearson's report says this is
- a strength: it shows range
- required for Level 5
- a weakness: keep to the dates in the question
- acceptable if well written
Show answer
a weakness: keep to the dates in the question. Running past the dates is listed as a weakness.
- Which of these is a Section B question type seen on WHI03 papers?
- Whether the key features of two periods were essentially similar
- Why is Source 1 valuable?
- How much weight do you give Source 2?
- Explain one consequence of an event
Show answer
Whether the key features of two periods were essentially similar. Comparing two periods is a common Unit 3 essay type.
- What does 'evaluating the relative significance of criteria' mean in an essay?
Show answer
Deciding which of your tests for judging, such as scale or how long an effect lasted, matters most, and explaining why.. Level 5 judges which criterion carries most weight.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson WHI03/1B mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1C examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, January 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.