All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Unit 3 skills: Section A levels and the judgement
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Section A is marked in five levels. The top two reward answers that separate information from claim, use context to show limitations and the values of the society that produced the source, and judge how certain each use of the sources can be.
The levels
| Level | Marks | What it looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 to 4 | Surface comprehension: quotation or paraphrase; context listed, not applied; assertive evaluation. |
| 2 | 5 to 8 | Some understanding and inference by selecting and summarising; context expands or confirms detail; evaluation thinly supported. |
| 3 | 9 to 14 | Key points explained and inferences supported; context explains or challenges; utility judged through nature, purpose or author's position; valid criteria. |
| 4 | 15 to 20 | Reasoned inferences; information distinguished from claim or opinion; context shows limitations and the values of the society; justified criteria. |
| 5 | 21 to 25 | Both sources interrogated with confidence and discrimination; context applied precisely; evidence weighed and the degree of certainty for each claim shown. |
Paraphrased from the generic Section A descriptors in Pearson WHI03 mark schemes.
Climbing to Levels 4 and 5
- Information or claim? A date, event or figure that can be checked is information; a judgement the author wants you to accept is a claim or opinion.
- Values of the society: what attitudes of the time explain why the author wrote as they did?
- Degree of certainty: say which uses are secure ('strong evidence of local white clergy's attitudes') and which are tentative ('weak evidence of who caused the violence').
- Criteria: state why one source carries more weight for this enquiry (closer to events, better informed, fewer reasons to mislead).
A worked case: Birmingham, 1963
Pearson's June 2025 1D paper set two letters on the nature of early 1960s protest. Source 1, from local church leaders, was published straight after the Birmingham protests: it called the demonstrations unwise and untimely and commended the police. Source 2, a letter by Martin Luther King published in June 1963, rebutted them: 'freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor'. Context: police commissioner Eugene 'Bull' Connor used mass arrests, attack dogs and water hoses; King was arrested in April 1963; the campaign helped pave the way for the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Worked example
Write a Level 5 style judgement on the two Birmingham letters.
- Source 1 is secure evidence of how some local white religious leaders saw the protests, but its claim that protesters caused the violence is challenged by Connor's use of dogs and hoses.
- Source 2 is secure evidence of the movement's reasoning for direct action; its praise of the protesters reflects King's role as leader, so it is less certain as evidence of how all black citizens of Birmingham felt.
- Together they show that the nature of the protest was itself contested.
Answer: Each is strong for its author's viewpoint and weaker for the contested facts; together they show the clash of values the enquiry is about.
Check yourself
- What is the lowest mark in Level 5 of Section A?
Show answer
21. Level 5 runs from 21 to 25.
- What is the highest mark in Level 3 of Section A?
Show answer
14. Level 3 runs from 9 to 14.
- Which feature marks out a Level 5 Section A answer?
- It quotes each source in full
- It lists everything the sources leave out
- It shows the degree of certainty with which each source can be used for particular claims
- It summarises each source in turn
Show answer
It shows the degree of certainty with which each source can be used for particular claims. Level 5 weighs the evidence and distinguishes certainty.
- Which statement from a source is a claim rather than information?
- The protests took place in Birmingham
- The demonstrations were unwise and untimely
- The letter was published in 1963
- King was arrested in April 1963
Show answer
The demonstrations were unwise and untimely. A judgement the author wants accepted is a claim.
- What does 'the values of the society' mean in the Level 4 descriptor?
- How much the source would sell for today
- The number of people who read the source
- The historian's own opinions
- The attitudes and beliefs of the time that shaped what the author wrote
Show answer
The attitudes and beliefs of the time that shaped what the author wrote. Context should show the attitudes behind a source.
- Which context best tests Source 1's claim that the Birmingham protests themselves incited violence?
- The letter was written by church leaders
- Bull Connor's use of attack dogs and water hoses on protesters
- The protests took place in spring
- Birmingham is in Alabama
Show answer
Bull Connor's use of attack dogs and water hoses on protesters. Police violence shows another source of the violence, testing the claim.
- What does it mean to distinguish information from claim or opinion in a source?
Show answer
Separating facts that can be checked, such as events and dates, from views or assertions the author wants the reader to believe.. Information can be checked; claims and opinions are what the author wants you to accept.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1B mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.