All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation

Unit 3 skills: Section A, using two sources together

Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation

Section A asks how far a historian could use two sources together for one enquiry. It rewards inferences, provenance, context and a judgement, and it rewards using the sources together rather than one after the other.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

What the task needs

What examiners criticise

From Pearson's WHI03 examiners' reports (January 2021 and June 2025):

A method

1. Underline the enquiry.

2. Source 1: two or three inferences, each with a brief quotation and a line of context.

3. Source 2: the same.

4. Provenance for each: why is it strong or weak for this enquiry?

5. Together: agreement, disagreement, complement.

6. Judgement: what can each be trusted for, and how certain can you be?

Worked example

Pearson's June 2023 1A paper used two sources on reactions to Nat Turner's Rising (1831): a southern newspaper written soon after, seeking to reassure readers that the revolt was contained; and Harriet Jacobs's account, published about 30 years later, describing violence she witnessed in Edenton. How far can they be used together?

  1. Source 1 claims the rising was short and local, with rebels killed or captured within 24 hours: it is strong evidence of what southern whites were being told, but its reassuring purpose means the claim needs testing.
  2. Source 2 is an eyewitness account, written with hindsight and condemning, of indiscriminate violence against black people.
  3. Context: about 60 people were killed before the militia defeated the rebels; violence against black people went on for weeks after; Virginia restricted black religious meetings.
  4. Together: both accept heavy loss of life; context supports Source 2 on the wider reaction, so Source 1's calm is better read as a claim.

Answer: Together they show the official reassurance and the violent reaction it played down, giving a fuller picture than either alone.

Key idea: Section A: inferences + provenance + context for each source, then use them together (agree, disagree, complement) and judge how far they can be used.

Check yourself

  1. Pearson's reports say answers that deal with the sources separately
    • find the highest levels much harder to reach
    • are always placed in the top level
    • score the same as answers that combine them
    • receive no marks at all
    Show answer

    find the highest levels much harder to reach. Using the sources together is needed for the highest levels.

  2. When does an omission count against a source?
    • Whenever the source does not mention every cause
    • Only when the source is a newspaper
    • When it appears to be deliberate
    • Never, in any circumstances
    Show answer

    When it appears to be deliberate. Pearson: omissions count only if they look deliberate.

  3. Which is a stereotyped judgement that examiners criticise?
    • The author was educated, so he must be unbiased
    • As a confidential letter to a minister, it had reason to be frank
    • Written to reassure readers, it may play down the threat
    • Written 30 years later, it has hindsight but may blur details
    Show answer

    The author was educated, so he must be unbiased. The January 2021 1D report gives this example of an unsupported assumption.

  4. A newspaper written days after a slave revolt says it is over and contained. For which enquiry is it strongest evidence?
    • The full death toll of the revolt
    • How the enslaved felt about the revolt
    • The long-term laws passed afterwards
    • What southern whites were being told about the revolt
    Show answer

    What southern whites were being told about the revolt. A source written to reassure is strong evidence of the message its readers received.

  5. Which piece of context best challenges the newspaper's claim that the Nat Turner revolt was quickly contained?
    • Turner had planned the rising for some time
    • Violence against black people continued for weeks after the rising
    • The newspaper was printed in the South
    • The rising took place in 1831
    Show answer

    Violence against black people continued for weeks after the rising. Context showing a long, violent aftermath challenges the claim of calm.

  6. Which is an inference rather than a paraphrase?
    • The newspaper says the rebels were caught
    • The source is a newspaper
    • The source mentions a rising
    • The reassuring tone suggests the writer feared panic among white readers
    Show answer

    The reassuring tone suggests the writer feared panic among white readers. An inference draws out what the words imply.

  7. Give two ways two sources can be used together in Section A.
    Show answer

    Show where they agree or corroborate each other, and where they disagree or one fills a gap in the other.. Agreement and disagreement (or complement) are the two main ways of combining.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.