All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
4A The revolutions of 1848 to 49 in Italy and Germany: causes and failure in Italy
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
In 1848 revolutions swept Italy and Germany. Pearson has asked what caused them and why the Italian revolutions failed. This lesson covers both.
Why 1848?
- Economic and social distress: harvest failures from 1845 to 1848 raised food prices; overproduction and factory growth threw artisans and workers out of work; crowded towns bred discontent (June 2018 mark scheme).
- Ideas: nationalism (Mazzini, Gioberti, Balbo in Italy) and liberal demands for representation.
- Triggers: revolution in France set off a spontaneous chain reaction; local grievances, such as Sicilian resentment of Naples and taxation in Lombardy.
- Pius IX's reforms raised expectations he then failed to meet (June 2024 mark scheme). Counter-point: the worst economic crisis had eased by 1848.
The Italian revolutions
- Revolts drove Austrian troops out of some areas; republics were set up in Venice and Rome (the Roman Republic, 1848 to 49).
- Charles Albert of Piedmont led the First War of Independence but was beaten by Radetzky at Custoza (July 1848) and Novara (March 1849) (January 2020 mark scheme).
Why they failed
- Austria: Radetzky held the Quadrilateral fortresses as a base for counter-attack; once Austria had crushed revolution at home and in Hungary it regained Lombardy and Venetia, and deposed rulers returned.
- Divisions among revolutionaries: localism, poor organisation, different aims; peasants in Naples backed the monarchy.
- Piedmont's weakness and Charles Albert's failure to lead 'Italy'.
- The Pope: his Allocution undermined the war; France later intervened to restore the Papacy in Rome.
- By the end of 1849, apart from Piedmont (which kept its constitution), Italy was again autocratic and Austrian-dominated (specimen mark scheme).
Worked example
Judge: 'The most important reason for the failure of the 1848 to 49 revolutions in Italy was Austrian intervention.'
- For: the Quadrilateral, Radetzky's victories at Custoza and Novara, and Austria's recovery after crushing Hungary.
- Against: revolutionaries were divided and localist; the Pope's Allocution; France restored the Pope in Rome; Piedmont was weak.
Answer: A judgement might argue Austria's military power was decisive in the north, but division among the revolutionaries meant they could not resist it, and France, not Austria, ended the Roman Republic.
Check yourself
- Where did Radetzky defeat Piedmont in July 1848?
- Custoza
- Solferino
- Magenta
- Novara
Show answer
Custoza. Custoza, July 1848; Novara followed in March 1849.
- In which year was the Battle of Novara?
Show answer
1849. March 1849, ending the First War of Independence.
- What was the Quadrilateral?
- A group of Austrian fortresses in northern Italy
- A Piedmontese alliance
- A Papal army
- The four Italian republics of 1848
Show answer
A group of Austrian fortresses in northern Italy. Radetzky used the Quadrilateral as a base for counter-attacks.
- Which power intervened to restore the Pope in Rome?
- Austria
- Britain
- Russia
- France
Show answer
France. France intervened to restore the Papacy in the Papal States.
- Which evidence supports an economic explanation of 1848?
- The Karlsbad Decrees
- Harvest failures from 1845 to 1848 and rising food prices
- The Crimean War
- The Congress of Verona
Show answer
Harvest failures from 1845 to 1848 and rising food prices. June 2018 mark scheme: harvest failures, unemployment, urban distress.
- What did Piedmont keep after 1849 that the other Italian states lost?
Show answer
Piedmont kept its constitution, a constitutional monarchy, while the rest of Italy returned to autocratic rule.. Its constitution (the Statuto) survived.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1A: The Making of Modern Europe, 1805 to 71
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2018
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, January 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.