All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
4A Nationalism and liberalism in Germany and Italy, 1815 to 48
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Metternich's system tried to hold back nationalism and liberalism. This lesson covers the movements and the repression in Germany and Italy, and the rise of Prussia's economic power, up to the eve of 1848.
Germany
- Patriotic student societies (Burschenschaften) demanded unity; students met at the Wartburg (1817).
- After the murder of the playwright Kotzebue (23 March 1819), the Diet adopted the Karlsbad Decrees (20 September 1819): censorship, and the student societies outlawed (Britannica).
- Hambach Festival (May 1832) called for unification, republican government and popular sovereignty; the Diet then tightened controls.
- Zollverein: the treaties were agreed in 1833 (the date Pearson's topic guide and June 2021 mark scheme use), and the customs union came into force on 1 January 1834. Prussia led it, and it bound other states to Prussia economically.
- Railways in the 1840s, the Rhine crisis with France (1840) (the song 'The Watch on the Rhine') and Frederick William IV's United Diet (1847) raised hopes of Prussian leadership.
Italy
- Revolutions in 1820 to 21 and 1831 were crushed by Austria and rulers restored (specimen mark scheme).
- Mazzini founded Young Italy from 1831; ideas of Gioberti and Balbo shaped the Risorgimento; secret societies, art and culture spread national feeling.
- Charles Albert ruled Piedmont; Pope Pius IX's reforms (from 1846) raised hopes, and he called for an Italian customs union and rejected Metternich's attempt to garrison Papal lands (June 2024 mark scheme).
How strong were the movements?
Pearson's mark schemes stress limits: German cultural nationalism (language, shared traditions) was stronger than any political movement; Prussian kings did not intend to undermine the Confederation, and the Zollverein's political effects were a by-product; Italian nationalism was divided and repressed. Yet Metternich's repression itself gave nationalists a cause.
Worked example
Was Prussia's rise the most significant factor in the growth of German nationalism, 1815 to 48? Give one argument each way.
- For: the Zollverein showed states cooperating for economic gain, and railways spread ideas; in 1848 many looked to Frederick William IV.
- Against: Prussian kings were conservative and did not aim at unity; cultural nationalism and reaction against Metternich's repression mattered more.
Answer: A judgement might say Prussia created the economic framework that made a Prussian-led Germany thinkable, but did not deliberately foster nationalism before 1848.
Check yourself
- In which year were the Karlsbad Decrees adopted?
Show answer
1819. 20 September 1819, after Kotzebue's murder.
- What did the Hambach Festival of May 1832 call for?
- Restoration of Napoleon
- Austrian leadership of Italy
- Abolition of the Zollverein
- National unification, republican government and popular sovereignty
Show answer
National unification, republican government and popular sovereignty. Britannica lists these demands.
- The Zollverein treaties were agreed in 1833. In which year did the customs union come into force (on 1 January)?
Show answer
1834. It came into force on 1 January 1834; Pearson's mark schemes sometimes give 1833, the year the treaties were agreed.
- Who founded Young Italy?
- Cavour
- Garibaldi
- Mazzini
- Charles Albert
Show answer
Mazzini. Mazzini founded Young Italy from 1831.
- Why did Pius IX's early reforms excite Italian nationalists?
- He called for an Italian customs union and refused Metternich's garrison
- He declared war on Piedmont
- He invited Austria to occupy Rome
- He abolished the Papal States
Show answer
He called for an Italian customs union and refused Metternich's garrison. June 2024 mark scheme: these actions made him a nationalist 'hero'.
- Which 1840 crisis produced a strong German nationalist response?
- The Belgian revolt
- The Crimean War
- The Rhine crisis with France
- The Ems telegram
Show answer
The Rhine crisis with France. The Rhine crisis produced the song 'The Watch on the Rhine'.
- How did Metternich try to stop nationalism and liberalism in Germany?
Show answer
He used repression: the Karlsbad Decrees brought censorship and outlawed student societies, and the Diet restricted the press, meetings and legislatures.. Censorship and repression through the Diet.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1A: The Making of Modern Europe, 1805 to 71
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Germany, The age of Metternich and the era of unification, 1815 to 71
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: German Empire, Establishment of the North German Confederation
- Encyclopedia.com: Zollverein (tariff contracts in force 1 January 1834)
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2021
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2018
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.