All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Unit 4 skills: the Section B essay
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Section B is half the paper: one essay from two, set on key topics 2 to 4. It rewards precise, well-selected knowledge used to argue towards a judgement. This lesson turns Pearson's guidance and examiners' reports into a working method.
What the question targets
Every essay targets a second-order concept: cause, consequence, change, continuity, similarity, difference or significance. Pearson's topic guides say questions can cover a single year or the whole period of key topics 2 to 4, and can cross topics (in 4A, for example, comparing Italy and Germany). Many questions name a factor ('Was X the main reason ...?'): you must evaluate X and weigh it against other factors.
Plan, select, argue
1. Underline the key term and the dates. Pearson's reports call chronology a major weakness: for example placing Gorbachev in power before 1985, Kennedy and Khrushchev as leaders in the 1970s, or detente in the 1950s (June 2025 and January 2025 4C reports).
2. Choose a few themes; a thematic structure often beats a chronological one (June 2025 4C report).
3. Select: 'there is no need for candidates to write about everything they know' (June 2025 4C report). Pearson notes you do not need the full hour.
4. Keep the introduction short: it should establish the argument, not give long background.
5. Set valid criteria and apply them; finish with a conclusion that states the judgement and the relative significance of the factors.
Faults examiners penalise
- Dismissing the given factor and writing about others without weighing them against it.
- Naming another factor as more important without valid criteria.
- Drifting outside the dates (for example pre-1939 events in a 1939 to 41 question, or Dien Bien Phu in a 1946 question).
- 'Everything I know' answers that become long, contradictory or incoherent.
- Describing events instead of evaluating their significance.
Worked example
Plan: 'How accurate is it to say that superpower relations between the USA and USSR improved greatly during 1962 to 79?' (Pearson exemplar, June 2017, 4C, Level 5)
- Key term: 'improved greatly'. Criteria: did agreements change behaviour, and did they last?
- Improvement: Test Ban Treaty (1963), hot-line (1963), Non-Proliferation Treaty (1968), SALT I (1972), Helsinki Accords (1975).
- Limits: proxy conflicts in Africa; human rights disputes; SALT II not ratified; Soviet invasion of Afghanistan (late 1979).
Answer: A judgement such as: relations improved substantially in the early 1970s, but the improvement was limited and reversible, as the collapse of detente by 1979 shows. Pearson's commentary praised the exemplar for setting criteria for 'greatly' and using precise knowledge to test change.
Check yourself
- Which of these is a second-order concept that a Section B essay can target?
- Provenance
- Reliability
- Continuity
- Utility
Show answer
Continuity. Cause, consequence, change, continuity, similarity, difference and significance.
- An essay asks whether factor X was the main reason. What do Pearson's examiners criticise?
- Dismissing X quickly and writing only about other factors
- Evaluating X before turning to other factors
- Setting criteria to compare X with others
- Ending with a judgement on X
Show answer
Dismissing X quickly and writing only about other factors. Reports criticise answers that dismiss the given factor without weighing it.
- Pearson's June 2025 report says strong essays
- always use all 60 minutes
- describe each event in date order
- select knowledge precisely rather than writing everything known
- open with a long background section
Show answer
select knowledge precisely rather than writing everything known. 'There is no need for candidates to write about everything they know.'
- Which of these is a chronological error Pearson's 4C examiners reported?
- Khrushchev leading the USSR in 1956
- Gorbachev leading the USSR before 1985
- Nixon visiting China in 1972
- Reagan as President in 1985
Show answer
Gorbachev leading the USSR before 1985. Gorbachev became leader in March 1985.
- How do Unit 4 Section B questions differ from some Unit 3 questions, according to Pearson's guide?
- They always ask about one year
- They use extracts
- They are worth 10 marks
- They are not set as a quoted statement to be assessed
Show answer
They are not set as a quoted statement to be assessed. Pearson's guide says they are phrased like Unit 3 questions but are not expressed as a statement to be assessed.
- What should a Section B introduction do?
- Give a full narrative of the background
- Establish the foundations of the argument briefly
- Summarise every factor in detail
- State that the question is hard to answer
Show answer
Establish the foundations of the argument briefly. Reports say introductions should 'establish the foundations of the argument' without extensive context.
- Why do essays need 'valid criteria' for judgement?
Show answer
Criteria are the tests, such as which factor had the most lasting or widest impact, that let you decide which factor was more significant rather than just asserting it.. Criteria turn an assertion into a supported judgement.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History exemplars, Unit 4 Section B
- Pearson WHI04/1B examiners' report, June 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1B examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1C examiners' report, January 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1C examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1D examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1A: The Making of Modern Europe, 1805 to 71
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.