All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations

Unit 4 skills: the Section A interpretations question

Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations

Section A gives you two short extracts from historians who disagree, and a view to judge. It is not a source question: you are not asked who wrote the extract or why. You are asked whether the argument stands up. This lesson shows how to do that.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The question

The question names a view and ends: 'Explain your answer using Extracts 1 and 2 and your knowledge of the issues related to this controversy.' Examples from Pearson's exemplar pack:

In June 2024 (4B) the extracts were by W K Storey (leaders were pushed into action by war plans with complicated mobilisation timetables) and J F V Keiger (decisions were mainly overtaken by events, not driven by war plans).

What to do

1. Read both extracts in full before writing. Pearson's examiners report candidates misreading an extract by quoting part of a sentence, or not reading Extract 2 to the end.

2. Work out each extract's overall argument and its supporting points. Use the authors' names (Pearson's reports encourage this; use 'et al' for several authors).

3. Test each point with precise own knowledge: what supports it, what it leaves out, what counters it.

4. Set out criteria for judging the view, then reach an overall judgement that takes account of both extracts.

5. Keep comparing the extracts throughout instead of describing one and then the other.

What earns no credit

Worked example

Plan for the June 2024 4B view: decision-makers in 1914 were 'rushed into action by the nature of war plans'.

  1. Storey (Extract 1) supports: offensive German and French plans demanded rapid mobilisation; the German command persuaded the Kaiser there was no alternative to the Schlieffen Plan. Own knowledge: Russia mobilised on 30 July 1914 and set other plans in motion (Pearson mark scheme).
  2. Keiger (Extract 2) challenges: the crisis moved too fast for full knowledge; French leaders were away from Paris for much of July. Own knowledge: many leaders were on summer breaks; the Kaiser and Tsar tried personal diplomacy.
  3. Criterion: were decisions made because of plan timetables, or before the plans began to bite (the blank cheque, the ultimatum)?

Answer: A judgement such as: the plans explain why a local crisis became general war very quickly once Russia mobilised, but the key choices of early and mid July were made before any plan forced the pace.

Key idea: Read both extracts fully; name the authors; find each argument and its points; test them with precise knowledge; set criteria; reach a judgement using both extracts. Never evaluate provenance.

Check yourself

  1. Section A mainly tests
    • AO2: the value and weight of primary sources
    • AO3: analysing and evaluating historians' interpretations
    • AO4: independent investigation
    • AO1 only
    Show answer

    AO3: analysing and evaluating historians' interpretations. Section A is AO3 20 marks and AO1 5 marks.

  2. A candidate argues that Extract 1 is unreliable because of the author's nationality. Pearson's examiners say this
    • is needed for Level 5
    • is the best way to start
    • is required in every answer
    • earns no credit: it is source evaluation, not analysis of the interpretation
    Show answer

    earns no credit: it is source evaluation, not analysis of the interpretation. Provenance is AO2 work and is not credited in Section A.

  3. How should you refer to the extracts and their writers?
    • As Sources 1 and 2
    • As Extracts, using the authors' names
    • As primary evidence
    • By the publisher's name only
    Show answer

    As Extracts, using the authors' names. Pearson's reports ask for 'Extracts' (not 'Sources') and encourage naming the authors.

  4. In the June 2024 4B paper, what was J F V Keiger's view in Extract 2?
    • War plans with rigid mobilisation timetables pushed leaders into war
    • Serbia was most to blame for the war
    • Decisions in 1914 were mainly overtaken by events rather than driven by war plans
    • The arms race made war certain from 1911
    Show answer

    Decisions in 1914 were mainly overtaken by events rather than driven by war plans. Pearson's June 2024 report summarises Keiger's view this way; Storey argued the opposite.

  5. Which mistake do Pearson's examiners report most often in Section A?
    • Reading only part of an extract and misreading its view
    • Writing too much about provenance in the conclusion
    • Naming the historians
    • Using precise dates
    Show answer

    Reading only part of an extract and misreading its view. Reports note candidates quoting partial phrases and not reading Extract 2 fully.

  6. How should own knowledge be used in Section A?
    • As a separate essay after the extracts
    • Only in the conclusion
    • To test and develop the arguments in the extracts
    • Instead of the extracts
    Show answer

    To test and develop the arguments in the extracts. Pearson's exemplar commentary rewards knowledge integrated with the extracts, not stand-alone.

  7. What must a Level 5 answer do when it reaches a judgement in Section A?
    Show answer

    It reaches a fully substantiated judgement on the view that takes account of the arguments in both extracts, using clear criteria.. Level 5 judgements are substantiated and take account of both extracts.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.