All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Alternative dispute resolution: negotiation, mediation and conciliation
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Most civil disputes never reach a trial. Specification points 1.2.16 to 1.2.18 cover three forms of ADR, each with a definition, advantages and disadvantages.
The three methods
| Method | How it works |
|---|---|
| Negotiation | The parties, or their lawyers, discuss the dispute directly and try to reach a settlement; no third party |
| Mediation | A neutral mediator acts as a confidential go-between, helping the parties find common ground; the mediator does not give their own view, and the parties reach their own compromise |
| Conciliation | A neutral conciliator plays a more active role and can suggest a settlement, which the parties need not accept; ACAS conciliates in employment disputes |
Definitions from Pearson's October 2019 and Summer 2021 mark schemes; ACAS from the Getting Started guide.
The courts and ADR
The courts encourage ADR. In Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council (Court of Appeal, 29 November 2023), a homeowner sued the council over Japanese knotweed spreading onto his land without first using the council's complaints procedure. The Court of Appeal held that a court can lawfully stay proceedings or order parties to engage in non-court-based dispute resolution, provided the order does not impair the very essence of the right to a judicial hearing and is proportionate to settling the dispute fairly, quickly and at reasonable cost.
Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages (Summer 2021 mark scheme): private; aims at compromise, preserving relationships; an independent, qualified person; informal; usually cheaper and quicker than court.
Disadvantages: both parties may end up dissatisfied; mediation and conciliation are not binding unless a settlement is agreed; no appeal; no public airing or precedent; power imbalance between parties; and it is not always cheap: Pearson's guide notes contractual mediation can cost more than £1,000 a day.
Worked example
Two neighbours fall out over a boundary hedge but want to stay on good terms. Recommend a method of dispute resolution.
- They want to preserve their relationship and keep costs down.
- A mediator can help them find their own compromise privately.
Answer: Mediation: private, cheaper than court and focused on agreement, which preserves the relationship; but any agreement depends on both being willing.
Check yourself
- In mediation, the mediator
- imposes a binding decision
- acts as judge and jury
- represents one party
- helps the parties find their own compromise without giving a view
Show answer
helps the parties find their own compromise without giving a view. Mediators facilitate rather than decide.
- How does conciliation differ from mediation?
- The conciliator's decision is always binding
- The conciliator can suggest a settlement
- Conciliation needs a jury
- Conciliation takes place in the Supreme Court
Show answer
The conciliator can suggest a settlement. Conciliators play a more active role.
- Which body is known for conciliation in employment disputes?
- The Law Commission
- The Bar Standards Board
- The Privy Council
- ACAS
Show answer
ACAS. Pearson's guide names ACAS.
- Which method involves no third party at all?
- Negotiation
- Mediation
- Conciliation
- Arbitration
Show answer
Negotiation. The parties deal directly.
- In Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil (2023), the Court of Appeal held that courts
- can never order ADR
- must always order mediation before trial
- can order parties to engage in non-court dispute resolution if proportionate
- can only order ADR in criminal cases
Show answer
can order parties to engage in non-court dispute resolution if proportionate. Subject to not impairing the essence of the right to a hearing.
- Explain one disadvantage of mediation.
Show answer
The outcome is not binding unless both parties agree, so a party can walk away and the dispute may still end up in court, wasting time and money.. Not binding, needs cooperation, power imbalance, no precedent or appeal, compromise may leave both unhappy.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Court of Appeal: Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416 (judiciary.uk)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.