All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Arbitration
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.15. Arbitration is the form of dispute resolution outside court that ends with a binding decision by a third party, so it is the closest to a private court.
How arbitration works
Arbitration is a voluntary agreement, usually in writing, to have a dispute decided by someone other than a judge. Many commercial contracts contain an arbitration clause, so disputes go to arbitration under the Arbitration Act instead of court. The parties can agree the number of arbitrators and choose them, often an expert from the trade. The decision, the award, is binding and can be enforced (Summer 2021 mark scheme).
The Arbitration Act 2025
Arbitration law was updated by the Arbitration Act 2025 (Royal Assent 24 February 2025), which implemented a Law Commission report and passed using the special House of Lords procedure for Law Commission bills (Law Commission Annual Report 2025-26).
Advantages and disadvantages
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Choice of an expert arbitrator | Can be expensive: the parties pay the arbitrator and venue |
| Private, so business reputations are protected | Unequal bargaining positions when a clause is imposed on a weaker party |
| Binding, enforceable award | Very limited appeal |
| Can be quicker and more flexible than court | No public ruling or precedent |
From Pearson's Summer 2021 mark scheme.
Worked example
A building firm and a developer have an arbitration clause and disagree over the quality of work. Explain how the dispute will be resolved.
- The clause means they agreed to arbitration, not court.
- An expert arbitrator, perhaps a surveyor, hears the case privately.
- The arbitrator's award binds the parties, with limited appeal.
Answer: By arbitration: a private hearing before an expert whose binding award can be enforced.
Check yourself
- The decision of an arbitrator is called
- a recommendation, never binding
- a verdict of a jury
- a declaration of incompatibility
- an award, which is binding
Show answer
an award, which is binding. The award binds the parties.
- An arbitration clause in a contract means that
- the contract is void
- disputes will go to arbitration rather than court
- disputes must go to the Supreme Court
- the parties must use a jury
Show answer
disputes will go to arbitration rather than court. Parties agree in advance.
- Who usually decides a commercial arbitration?
- A jury of twelve
- A bench of three magistrates
- The European Commission
- An arbitrator chosen by the parties, often an expert in the trade
Show answer
An arbitrator chosen by the parties, often an expert in the trade. The parties can choose the arbitrator (Summer 2021 mark scheme).
- Why might a business prefer arbitration to court?
- The hearing is private
- It always sets a binding precedent
- Appeals are unlimited
- A jury decides
Show answer
The hearing is private. Privacy protects commercial reputation.
- Which recent Act implementing a Law Commission report updated arbitration law?
- Courts Act 2003
- Juries Act 1974
- Arbitration Act 2025
- Royal Assent Act 1967
Show answer
Arbitration Act 2025. Royal Assent 24 February 2025.
- Give one disadvantage of arbitration.
Show answer
It can be expensive because the parties pay the arbitrator, and there is very limited right of appeal against the award.. Disadvantages: cost of arbitrators and venues, limited appeal, unequal bargaining power where a clause is imposed, no precedent.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Law Commission Annual Report 2025-26
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.