All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Criminal liability and sanctions
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Criminal law deals with conduct the state treats as harmful to society as a whole. Specification point 1.1.6 covers the burden and standard of proof, the parties and the sanctions.
Parties, burden and standard
The state brings the case: the prosecution (usually the Crown Prosecution Service) against the defendant, so cases are named *R v Smith* (R for Rex or Regina, the Crown). The burden of proof is on the prosecution and the standard is beyond reasonable doubt. The verdict is guilty or not guilty; in the Crown Court the jury must be unanimous or reach an accepted majority verdict.
Sanctions
| Sanction | Key features (from Pearson mark schemes) |
|---|---|
| Custodial sentence | Prison; magistrates can impose up to 12 months for one offence |
| Suspended sentence | For offenders 18 or over; a prison term that does not take effect immediately; activated if the offender reoffends. Pearson's mark schemes say a term of up to 2 years; the Sentencing Act 2026 raised this to 3 years for convictions from 22 March 2026, with an operational period of up to 2 years (3 if the term is over 2 years) |
| Community order | For offenders 18 or over (Sentencing Act 2020, s202); can combine requirements such as curfew, exclusion, unpaid work, and drug, alcohol or mental health treatment |
| Fine | A sum paid to the state |
| Conditional discharge | No penalty now; if the offender reoffends within the set period (up to 3 years) they can be sentenced for the original offence too |
| Absolute discharge | No penalty: the court considers none is needed |
Choosing a sanction
Sentencers match the sanction to the seriousness of the offence and the purposes of sentencing (see the theories of punishment lessons). A fine or discharge suits minor offending; community orders combine punishment with rehabilitation; custody is for the most serious offences. Magistrates' sentencing powers are limited, so serious cases go to the Crown Court.
Worked example
A first-time offender aged 19 commits a minor theft and shows remorse. Suggest a sanction and explain it.
- Minor offence, no previous convictions.
- Punishment may not be necessary, but a warning is.
Answer: A conditional discharge: no penalty now, but if they reoffend within the period (up to 3 years) they can be sentenced for the theft as well.
Check yourself
- In a criminal trial, who must prove guilt and to what standard?
- The defendant, on the balance of probabilities
- The judge, beyond reasonable doubt
- The prosecution, beyond reasonable doubt
- The prosecution, on the balance of probabilities
Show answer
The prosecution, beyond reasonable doubt. The burden is on the prosecution; the standard is beyond reasonable doubt.
- What is the maximum conditional period (in years) for a conditional discharge, according to Pearson's mark schemes?
Show answer
3 years. Up to 3 years.
- Under the Sentencing Act 2026, what is the longest prison term, in years, that a court can suspend for an offender convicted on or after 22 March 2026?
Show answer
3 years. 3 years. Before 22 March 2026 the limit was 2 years, which is the figure in Pearson's older mark schemes.
- Which can be a requirement of a community order?
- Rescission
- Unpaid work
- Specific performance
- An injunction against a landlord
Show answer
Unpaid work. Community orders can include unpaid work, curfews and treatment requirements. The others are civil remedies.
- In the case name R v Patel, what does 'R' stand for?
- The respondent
- The claimant
- The Royal Courts of Justice
- The Crown (Rex or Regina)
Show answer
The Crown (Rex or Regina). Criminal prosecutions are brought in the name of the Crown.
- What is the most a magistrates' court can impose for a single offence?
- 5 years' imprisonment
- 12 months' imprisonment
- Life imprisonment
- A 10 year suspended sentence
Show answer
12 months' imprisonment. Magistrates can impose prison of up to 12 months for one offence; more serious cases go to the Crown Court.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2022 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- GOV.UK: Become a magistrate, what magistrates do
- GOV.UK press release, 17 October 2024: Increased sentencing powers for magistrates
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2020, section 202 (community order: availability)
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2026, section 2 (suspended sentence orders)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.