All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Civil liability and remedies
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Civil law deals with disputes between individuals and organisations. Specification point 1.1.5 covers its branches, the parties, the burden and standard of proof, and remedies.
Branches of civil law
Pearson lists the main types:
- Contract: legally binding agreements (enforceable where there is offer, acceptance and consideration)
- Tort: civil wrongs against a person or property, such as negligence, trespass, nuisance or defamation
- Family: divorce, children and domestic disputes
- Employment: the working relationship
- Company: the regulation of businesses
Parties, burden and standard
The claimant brings the claim against the defendant. The burden of proof is on the claimant and the standard is the balance of probabilities: the claimant must show that their version is more likely than not. The court finds the defendant liable or not liable. The standard is lower than in criminal cases because the consequence is a remedy, not punishment.
Remedies
| Remedy | What it does |
|---|---|
| General damages | Compensation not precisely calculable, such as pain and suffering |
| Special damages | Precisely calculable losses, such as lost earnings or repair bills |
| Exemplary damages | Extra sum to punish the defendant (rare) |
| Nominal damages | A small sum showing the claimant won but lost little |
| Injunction | Orders a party to do or stop doing something (equitable) |
| Specific performance | Orders a contract to be carried out (equitable) |
| Rescission | Sets a contract aside, restoring the parties to their pre-contract position (equitable) |
| Rectification | Corrects a document so it reflects what was really agreed (equitable) |
From Pearson's October 2020 mark scheme. Equitable remedies are discretionary: see the equity lesson.
Worked example
A builder fails to finish a kitchen and the customer pays another firm £3,000 extra. Name the branch of law, the parties and a suitable remedy.
- A binding agreement was broken: contract.
- The customer sues as claimant; the builder is defendant.
- The loss can be calculated exactly.
Answer: Contract law; claimant (customer) v defendant (builder); special damages of £3,000, proved on the balance of probabilities.
Check yourself
- What is the standard of proof in a civil case?
- Balance of probabilities
- Beyond reasonable doubt
- Certainty
- Prima facie evidence
Show answer
Balance of probabilities. The claimant must show their case is more likely than not.
- Who brings a civil claim?
- The prosecution
- The Crown Prosecution Service
- The claimant
- The defendant
Show answer
The claimant. Civil cases are claimant v defendant.
- A court awards £1 because the claimant's rights were infringed but no real loss was shown. These are
- nominal damages
- special damages
- exemplary damages
- general damages
Show answer
nominal damages. Nominal damages mark a technical win.
- Which is an example of a tort?
- Failing to pay for goods under an agreement
- Murder
- A divorce petition
- Negligence causing injury
Show answer
Negligence causing injury. Negligence is a civil wrong outside contract. Failing to pay under an agreement is breach of contract.
- Lost wages of £2,400 that can be calculated exactly are claimed as
- nominal damages
- special damages
- general damages
- rectification
Show answer
special damages. Special damages cover precisely calculable losses.
- Explain one difference between contract law and tort law.
Show answer
Contract liability arises from a legally binding agreement the parties made, whereas a tort is a civil wrong such as negligence that arises without any agreement.. Contract obligations are voluntarily agreed; tort duties are imposed by law on everyone, for example the duty of care in negligence.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.