All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Controlling delegated legislation: Parliament and the courts
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Because unelected people make delegated legislation, it must be controlled. Specification point 1.2.5 covers parliamentary and judicial controls and the Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006. In June 2025, a 12 mark evaluation could only reach Level 4 if it covered both courts and Parliament.
Parliamentary controls
- The enabling Act sets the limits of the power.
- The House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (the 'Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee' in Pearson's mark schemes) reports on whether a bill delegates powers inappropriately, before committee stage; it cannot amend the bill.
- Negative resolution (most SIs): the SI becomes law unless either House annuls it within 40 days. Annulment is very rare; UK Parliament says the Commons last annulled one in October 1979.
- Affirmative resolution (a few SIs): Parliament must approve it. Parliament can only approve or reject, not amend. The last affirmative SI the Commons failed to approve was in July 1978. Pearson's example is the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.
- The Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments checks whether SIs are legal and within the parent Act's powers, and reports on issues such as unexpected taxes, retrospective effect or defective drafting; it cannot change them.
- The Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 lets a minister make an order to remove or reduce burdens resulting from legislation (s1), or to promote good regulation (s2). Safeguards: the minister must be satisfied of preconditions such as proportionality and that the order is not of constitutional significance (s3); an order cannot impose a tax or create an offence punishable with more than two years' imprisonment (ss5 and 6); and the draft goes through a negative, affirmative or 'super-affirmative' procedure, with either House able to insist on a stricter one (ss15 to 18). Critics see it as letting ministers change Acts with limited debate.
Judicial control
Anyone affected can challenge delegated legislation by judicial review (or in a civil claim or on appeal by case stated). The court can declare it ultra vires (beyond the powers) and so void.
- Procedural ultra vires: the correct procedure in the enabling Act was not followed: Pearson's standard example is Agricultural Training Board v Aylesbury Mushrooms (1972).
- Substantive ultra vires: the content goes beyond the powers given: Pearson cites Customs and Excise v Cure and Deeley (1962), and its June 2025 mark scheme lists R v Home Secretary, ex parte Fire Brigades Union (House of Lords, 1995) under ultra vires: the Home Secretary had not brought into force the statutory criminal injuries compensation scheme in the Criminal Justice Act 1988 and instead introduced a cheaper non-statutory tariff scheme. The House held, by a majority, that he could not bind himself never to use his power to commence the statutory scheme, so introducing the tariff scheme was unlawful and an abuse of power.
- Unreasonableness: so unreasonable no reasonable body could have made it: Pearson cites Strickland v Hayes Borough Council (1896) for a by-law.
- Pearson's June 2025 mark scheme also lists presumptions against unreasonable regulations, taxes and sub-delegation without express power, and R v Secretary of State for Education, ex parte National Union of Teachers (2000).
How effective are the controls?
- Most SIs are never debated: negative resolution relies on someone noticing within 40 days.
- Parliament cannot amend an SI, only accept or reject it, and rejection is extremely rare.
- Committees scrutinise technical legality, not merits, and can only report.
- Courts act only if someone brings a challenge, which costs money, and only after the law is in force; they review legality, not wisdom.
- But: the threat of judicial review and committee reports encourages careful drafting, and the courts can strike down unlawful rules entirely.
Worked example
Assess how effectively Parliament controls delegated legislation. (12 marks: plan)
- Explain each control: enabling Act, DPRRC, negative and affirmative resolution, JCSI.
- Weigh: annulment last happened in 1979; no power to amend; committees only report.
- Compare with judicial control, which must also be covered for Level 4.
- Conclude: Parliament's control is broad but weak in practice; courts give a stronger but reactive check.
Answer: A balanced answer covering both Parliament and the courts with a justified conclusion.
Check yourself
- Within how many days can either House annul a statutory instrument laid under the negative procedure?
Show answer
40 days. The 40-day period.
- Under the affirmative resolution procedure, Parliament can
- amend any clause it chooses
- approve or reject the instrument but not amend it
- only debate it after it has expired
- refer it to the Supreme Court
Show answer
approve or reject the instrument but not amend it. Parliament cannot amend SIs.
- A minister makes regulations without carrying out a consultation the enabling Act requires. On what ground could they be challenged?
- Substantive ultra vires
- Declaration of incompatibility
- The golden rule
- Procedural ultra vires
Show answer
Procedural ultra vires. A failure to follow required procedure is procedural ultra vires (Aylesbury Mushrooms).
- Pearson's Getting Started guide gives Customs and Excise v Cure and Deeley (1962) as an example of
- substantive ultra vires
- procedural ultra vires
- a declaration of incompatibility
- the affirmative resolution procedure
Show answer
substantive ultra vires. The content went beyond the powers in the parent Act.
- What can the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments do if it finds a problem?
- Strike the SI down
- Amend the SI
- Report it to Parliament
- Fine the minister
Show answer
Report it to Parliament. It can only report.
- Which is a limit on orders made under the Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006?
- They cannot impose a tax
- They can only be made by local councils
- They need a referendum
- They can never amend an Act of Parliament
Show answer
They cannot impose a tax. Section 5 bars orders imposing, abolishing or varying any tax; section 6 limits new criminal penalties.
- If a court finds delegated legislation ultra vires, the legislation is
- automatically re-enacted
- sent to the European Commission
- void
- converted into an Act
Show answer
void. Ultra vires legislation is void.
- Explain one weakness of judicial control of delegated legislation.
Show answer
The courts can only act if someone brings a challenge by judicial review, which is expensive, and only after the legislation is already in force.. Courts are reactive (they need a claimant), challenges cost money, review comes after the law is in force, and courts review legality not merits.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- UK Parliament: Statutory instruments procedure in the House of Commons
- legislation.gov.uk: Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006, Part 1 (as enacted)
- First-tier Tribunal (Criminal Injuries Compensation) decisions database: R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union (House of Lords, 5 April 1995)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2022 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2025 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson examiners' report: YLA1/01, June 2025
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.