All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Advantages and disadvantages of delegated legislation
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.6. Pearson has asked for the advantages (6 marks) and the disadvantages (6 marks) as 'analyse' questions, so you must explain why each point matters, not just list.
Advantages
From Pearson's mark schemes:
- Saves parliamentary time: Parliament sets the framework; details are filled in elsewhere.
- Speed: rules can be made quickly, including in emergencies.
- Expertise: ministers can consult experts on technical detail Parliament may lack.
- Local knowledge: by-laws let local areas make rules suited to them.
- Flexibility: easy to update, for example annual minimum wage figures.
- Some democratic input: by-laws are made by elected councillors and SIs by or for elected ministers, under Parliament's control.
Disadvantages
- Takes law making away from the elected House of Commons; much is made by unelected civil servants.
- Sub-delegation: powers pass further down the chain.
- Volume: thousands of instruments make the current law hard to find.
- Little publicity: most are never debated.
- Obscure wording, like Acts.
- Weak control: Parliament cannot amend, and courts act only if challenged.
Building an analysis
Use a chain: point, explanation, consequence, example. For instance: delegated legislation is quick, because a minister can make an SI without a full bill passing both Houses, so the law can respond to emergencies, as with Orders in Council under the Civil Contingencies Act 2004. For balance, link each advantage to its matching weakness: the speed that helps in emergencies is the same feature that reduces scrutiny.
Worked example
Analyse one advantage of delegated legislation. (2 of the 6 marks)
- Point: saves parliamentary time.
- Explain: Parliament passes a framework Act and ministers add detail by SI.
- Consequence: Parliament can concentrate on major policy; example, annual minimum wage changes.
Answer: A developed point with explanation, consequence and example, which is what lifts an answer above a list.
Check yourself
- Which is an advantage of delegated legislation?
- It is always debated fully in the Commons and the Lords
- It is made only by elected MPs
- It cannot be challenged in court
- It allows rules to be made quickly in an emergency
Show answer
It allows rules to be made quickly in an emergency. Speed is a key advantage.
- Which is a disadvantage of delegated legislation?
- It takes up too much time on the floor of the Commons
- Much of it is made by unelected people with little publicity
- It can never be changed
- It is always too short
Show answer
Much of it is made by unelected people with little publicity. It moves law making away from the elected Commons.
- 'Sub-delegation' means
- a by-law approved by a minister
- a statute replacing an SI
- an appeal to a higher court
- power passed further down, for example to civil servants
Show answer
power passed further down, for example to civil servants. A criticism in Pearson's June 2022 mark scheme.
- Why are by-laws a good example of the 'local knowledge' advantage?
- Local councils understand their own area's needs
- They are made by the Supreme Court
- They apply to the whole country
- They are made by the Privy Council
Show answer
Local councils understand their own area's needs. Councils make rules suited to local conditions.
- Why can the volume of delegated legislation be a problem?
- It slows down Acts of Parliament
- It makes judges unnecessary
- It makes the current law hard to find and know
- It means Parliament has no work
Show answer
It makes the current law hard to find and know. Thousands of instruments are made, often with little publicity.
- Analyse why expertise is an advantage of delegated legislation.
Show answer
MPs may not have technical knowledge, but ministers can consult experts when making statutory instruments, so the detailed rules are more accurate and workable.. Parliament lacks technical expertise; ministers can consult specialists, so detailed rules are better informed.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2022 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2025 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.