All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Funding legal action: insurance, state funding, conditional fees and free advice
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.24 lists the ways of paying for legal advice and representation, including the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012. Pearson has set this as a 4 mark 'explain four ways' question and a 14 mark evaluation.
Ways of funding
| Method | Key points (June 2024 mark scheme) |
|---|---|
| Legal expenses insurance | Paid for by premiums, often added to car or home insurance; covers future disputes |
| State funding (legal aid) | Civil: depends on the merits of the case and, for some cases, public interest; criminal: depends on means, merits and the interests of justice |
| Conditional fee agreements | 'No win, no fee': the lawyer is paid only if the case succeeds, with an uplift (success fee) that is capped |
| Trade union membership | Unions often fund members' work-related claims |
| Citizens Advice | Free general advice; may refer to other services |
| Pro bono | Lawyers working free of charge |
| Self-funding | Paying privately |
The Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012
LASPO 2012, implemented in April 2013, aimed to target legal aid at those who needed it most and to make significant savings. It removed many areas of civil law from the scope of legal aid or restricted them with specific criteria. The Ministry of Justice's 2019 review found that legal help in employment, welfare benefits, debt and clinical negligence fell by 99 to 100%; in private family cases legal aid mainly remained through a 'domestic violence gateway' requiring evidence of abuse. The scope changes cut spending by about £90 million on civil and £160 million on family legal aid in 2017-18. Critics, and stakeholders in that review, reported a rise in litigants in person who struggle to present their cases.
Evaluating funding
- Insurance: cheap if bought in advance, but many people do not know they have it, and it may not cover the dispute.
- Legal aid: protects the poorest and supports fair criminal trials, but tight means and merits tests leave many on modest incomes ineligible.
- CFAs: give access without upfront fees, but lawyers may take only strong cases, and success fees reduce what the client receives.
- Unions, Citizens Advice, pro bono: free or cheap, but limited in capacity and scope.
- A Level 4 answer weighs several methods and reaches a conclusion about whether access to justice is adequate.
Worked example
Explain two ways a person injured at work could fund a claim. (4 marks)
- Trade union: if a member, the union may fund a work-related claim (1), with its own lawyers (1).
- Conditional fee agreement: no win, no fee (1); if successful, the lawyer gets an uplift, which is capped (1).
Answer: Trade union funding and a conditional fee agreement, each identified and explained.
Check yourself
- A conditional fee agreement means
- the state pays all costs
- the lawyer is paid only if the case succeeds, with a capped uplift
- the client always pays double
- an insurer pays in advance
Show answer
the lawyer is paid only if the case succeeds, with a capped uplift. 'No win, no fee'.
- Criminal legal aid depends on
- the defendant's age only
- the judge's personal view
- whether the defendant is a union member
- means, merits and the interests of justice
Show answer
means, merits and the interests of justice. June 2024 mark scheme.
- What was a key effect of LASPO 2012 on civil legal aid?
- It made legal aid available for every civil case
- It removed many types of civil case from the scope of legal aid
- It abolished criminal legal aid
- It created conditional fee agreements for the first time in 2012
Show answer
It removed many types of civil case from the scope of legal aid. Many civil areas lost funding.
- 'Pro bono' work is
- work paid by a trade union
- a type of insurance
- legal work done free of charge
- a court fee
Show answer
legal work done free of charge. Latin for 'for the public good'.
- Legal expenses insurance is often
- added to car or home insurance policies
- provided by the Crown Court
- paid for by the losing party in advance
- only for criminal cases
Show answer
added to car or home insurance policies. Pearson's mark scheme.
- Give one disadvantage of conditional fee agreements.
Show answer
Lawyers may only take on cases they are likely to win, so people with risky but valid claims may not find a lawyer, and the success fee reduces the client's damages.. Disadvantages: lawyers cherry-pick strong cases; success fees and insurance premiums reduce what the client keeps.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Ministry of Justice: Post-Implementation Review of Part 1 of LASPO (February 2019)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.