All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
The costs of taking legal action
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.23: court costs, legal representation costs, costs awarded against the losing party and the hidden cost of lost reputation.
The costs
- Court costs: fees to issue a claim and for hearings. Fees can be a barrier: the employment tribunal fees of 2013 (up to £1,200 for a single claimant's type B claim) cut claims by about two thirds before the Supreme Court quashed them in *UNISON* (2017).
- Legal representation: solicitors' and barristers' fees, often charged by the hour, are usually the largest cost. Experts' fees add more.
- Costs awarded against the losing party: in civil cases the loser is usually ordered to pay a large part of the winner's costs as well as their own, so the risk of losing is a major deterrent.
- Hidden costs: time off work, stress, and loss of reputation from publicity, even for a party who wins.
- ADR is not always cheap: contractual mediation can cost more than £1,000 a day (Getting Started guide).
Why costs matter: access to justice
The rule of law needs people to be able to enforce their rights in court. Lord Reed in *UNISON* explained that access to the courts is inherent in the rule of law, and that courts benefit the whole public, not only the people who use them. If costs prevent people with good claims from going to court, the law is unenforceable for them, and stronger or richer parties gain an advantage. This links costs to funding (next lesson) and to the choice between courts, tribunals and ADR.
Evaluating costs in an answer
Weigh costs against benefits: a court gives a binding, enforceable decision and an appeal; tribunals, ombudsmen and ADR are cheaper but have their own limits. Use concrete figures where you have a source, such as the 2013 fees, and link to the small claims track, which is designed for people acting without lawyers.
Worked example
Explain why the 'loser pays' rule can deter people from bringing a civil claim.
- If the claimant loses, they pay their own costs and much of the defendant's.
- The total could be far more than the claim is worth.
Answer: Fear of a large costs order discourages people with uncertain cases, even good ones, from suing, especially against wealthy defendants.
Check yourself
- In civil cases the losing party is usually ordered to
- pay nothing beyond their own fees
- go to prison
- pay a large part of the winner's legal costs
- pay the judge's salary
Show answer
pay a large part of the winner's legal costs. Costs follow the event: a major risk for claimants.
- Which is a 'hidden' cost of going to law?
- Damage to reputation from publicity
- The court issue fee
- A barrister's brief fee
- An expert's report fee
Show answer
Damage to reputation from publicity. Hidden costs include reputation, time and stress.
- What happened to employment tribunal claims after fees were introduced in 2013?
- They doubled
- They stayed the same
- They fell by about two thirds
- They moved to the Crown Court
Show answer
They fell by about two thirds. UNISON judgment: a fall of roughly 66 to 70%.
- Why are high legal costs a rule of law issue?
- They make judges richer
- They can stop people enforcing their legal rights
- They mean Parliament cannot pass laws
- They abolish juries
Show answer
They can stop people enforcing their legal rights. Access to the courts is inherent in the rule of law (UNISON).
- Pearson's guide says contractual mediation can cost more than £1,000 a day. What is the minimum cost of a three-day mediation at that rate, in pounds?
Show answer
£3000. 3 x £1,000 = £3,000.
- Explain why high costs might mean that justice is not equal for everyone.
Show answer
Richer people and companies can afford lawyers and the risk of losing, while poorer people may not be able to bring or defend a case, so their rights cannot be enforced.. Costs create inequality of arms: wealthy parties can litigate and take risks; poorer people may be priced out.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- UK Supreme Court: R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51, judgment of 26 July 2017
- UK Supreme Court: Lord Sales, What is the rule of law and why does it matter? (Robin Cooke Lecture, 12 December 2024)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.