All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Advantages and disadvantages of judicial law making
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.9. Pearson has asked candidates to 'evaluate' or 'assess' judicial precedent and to discuss whether judges use precedent to reach the outcome they prefer. Balance and examples are essential.
Advantages
From Pearson's mark schemes:
- Certainty and time saving: like cases are decided alike, so lawyers can advise and many disputes settle.
- Detailed rules built from real cases.
- Flexibility: the law can develop to meet new situations or update out-of-date rules: *R v R* (1991) on marital rape and *Herrington* (1972) on trespassers.
- Impartiality and authority: senior judges decide, and decisions are publicly reported.
Disadvantages
- Rigidity: lower courts must follow bad decisions until a higher court corrects them; *Caldwell* stood for about 20 years before *R v G* (2003).
- Undemocratic: unelected judges can make law, possibly conflicting with parliamentary supremacy. In *Shaw v DPP* (1962) the House of Lords upheld a conviction for conspiracy to corrupt public morals, which the topic guide treats as judges creating an offence.
- Uncertainty: several judges giving different reasons can make the ratio hard to identify; distinguishing on fine points can make the law complex.
- Dependent on litigation: the law develops only when a case reaches a senior court, which depends on funding.
- Retrospective: a new rule applies to events before the decision.
- Volume: a huge number of reported cases.
Judges or Parliament?
Senior judges themselves recognise limits. In *Knauer* (2016) the Supreme Court said complex changes with wider implications may be better left to Parliament. In *Pretty* (2001) Lord Bingham said the House of Lords was not a legislative body or a moral arbiter. But where Parliament does not act, judges can, as in *R v R* (1991). A strong conclusion weighs certainty against flexibility and asks which body is better placed for each kind of change.
Worked example
Evaluate the claim that judges can use precedent to reach the outcome they prefer. (outline)
- For: distinguishing on fine factual differences; Supreme Court can depart (Herrington, Jogee); Court of Appeal exceptions.
- Against: lower courts are bound; departure is 'very circumspect' and rare; criminal law caution; Parliament can override.
- Conclusion: some freedom exists at the top, but strict limits make the claim overstated.
Answer: A balanced answer with cases on each side and a justified conclusion.
Check yourself
- Which case does Pearson's mark scheme cite as judges updating an out-of-date rule?
- Fisher v Bell (1961)
- Young v Bristol Aeroplane (1944)
- R v R (1991)
- London Tramways (1898)
Show answer
R v R (1991). R v R removed the marital rape immunity.
- Why is rigidity a disadvantage of precedent?
- Lower courts must follow bad decisions until a higher court corrects them
- Judges can ignore any precedent
- Parliament cannot change judge-made law
- Juries decide points of law
Show answer
Lower courts must follow bad decisions until a higher court corrects them. A poor precedent can last years, like Caldwell.
- Shaw v DPP is often used to illustrate which criticism of judicial law making?
- Excessive use of Hansard
- Delay in Parliament
- Unelected judges creating criminal offences
- Use of juries in civil cases
Show answer
Unelected judges creating criminal offences. The topic guide presents it as judges creating an offence.
- Judge-made law is said to be retrospective because
- it only applies to future cases
- a new rule applies to events that happened before the decision
- it must be approved by Parliament first
- it applies only to retired judges
Show answer
a new rule applies to events that happened before the decision. The parties' conduct is judged by a rule announced after it happened.
- Which is an advantage of judicial precedent?
- Judges are elected
- It allows unlimited changes by any court
- It removes the need for statutes
- Lawyers can predict outcomes, so many disputes settle
Show answer
Lawyers can predict outcomes, so many disputes settle. Certainty and time saving.
- Give one argument that judges should leave major changes in the law to Parliament.
Show answer
Parliament is elected and can consult widely, whereas judges are unelected and can only decide the case in front of them, so major changes are more legitimate if made by Parliament.. Parliament has democratic legitimacy and can consult and research; judges decide individual cases (Knauer; Pretty).
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson: IAL Law sample assessment materials (Paper 1 sample paper and mark scheme)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Law Commission No 358: Simplification of Criminal Law, Public Nuisance and Outraging Public Decency (2015)
- House of Lords: R v G [2003] UKHL 50
- UK Supreme Court press summary: Knauer v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 9
- House of Lords: R (Pretty) v DPP [2001] UKHL 61, judgment of 29 November 2001
- Pearson: Paper 1 exemplar answers with examiner commentary, Question 1 (judicial precedent)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.