All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Equity and equitable remedies in contract
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Damages are the normal remedy for breach of contract, but sometimes money is not enough. Specification point 1.2.8 covers how equity developed further remedies, when they are available, and their advantages and disadvantages.
What equity adds
Equity is a body of rules developed by the courts to bring fairness where the common law's remedy of damages would be inadequate. Equitable remedies are discretionary: the court decides whether to grant them, and will not do so where damages would be an adequate remedy (October 2020 mark scheme). Equity has also produced doctrines such as promissory estoppel, which Pearson's topic guide links to Lord Denning in *Central London Property Trust v High Trees House* (1947) and to the moral idea that promises should be kept.
The remedies
| Remedy | What it does | Pearson's example case |
|---|---|---|
| Specific performance | Orders a party to carry out the contract | Nutbrown v Thornton (1804): where specialised machinery was needed |
| Rescission | Sets the contract aside, putting parties back in their pre-contract position; used where a misrepresentation induced the contract | Redgrave v Hurd (1881) |
| Injunction | Orders a party to do, or stop doing, something | Argyll v Argyll (1967) |
| Rectification | Corrects a written document so it matches what was actually agreed | No case named by Pearson |
Cases from Pearson's Getting Started guide (week 22).
Limits and evaluation
Limits (October 2020 mark scheme): equitable remedies are discretionary; the court may find damages sufficient; specific performance is rarely used, cannot compel personal services and is not ordered against a minor; rescission depends on a misrepresentation having induced the contract.
Advantages: fairness where money cannot put things right, for example unique goods or land; flexibility. Disadvantages: uncertainty, because the outcome depends on discretion; specific performance can require court supervision; and the 'clean hands' approach means a claimant who behaved badly may be refused.
Worked example
A buyer agrees to purchase a unique painting; the seller refuses to hand it over. Which remedy should the buyer seek, and why?
- The painting is unique, so damages could not buy an equivalent.
- Specific performance orders the seller to complete the contract.
Answer: Specific performance, because damages are inadequate for a unique item; but the court has discretion.
Check yourself
- Equitable remedies are
- available as of right to every claimant
- only available in criminal cases
- the same as damages
- discretionary
Show answer
discretionary. The court decides whether to grant them.
- Which remedy orders a party to carry out the contract?
- Rescission
- Specific performance
- Rectification
- Nominal damages
Show answer
Specific performance. Specific performance compels performance.
- Pearson's guide links Redgrave v Hurd (1881) to which remedy?
- Specific performance of a building contract
- An injunction protecting privacy
- Exemplary damages
- Rescission for misrepresentation
Show answer
Rescission for misrepresentation. Rescission sets aside a contract induced by misrepresentation.
- Specific performance will not be ordered to
- compel someone to perform personal services
- transfer a unique painting
- complete a sale of land
- supply specialised machinery
Show answer
compel someone to perform personal services. Courts will not force personal services (October 2020 mark scheme).
- Rectification is used to
- award compensation for injury
- end a marriage
- correct a written document so it reflects what was agreed
- punish a defendant
Show answer
correct a written document so it reflects what was agreed. It corrects the document.
- Explain why equitable remedies were needed alongside damages.
Show answer
Damages are sometimes inadequate, for example where the subject matter is unique, so equity created remedies like specific performance to achieve a fair result.. Money cannot always put the claimant in the right position; equity fills that gap fairly.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.