All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
The House of Lords, the Parliament Acts and evaluating the legislative process
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
The specification names the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 and the Royal Assent Act 1967. In June 2025, a 6 mark part asked for the role and powers of the House of Lords, and a 10 mark part asked candidates to assess criticisms of the process.
The House of Lords
The Lords is the second, unelected chamber. Bills can start there or arrive from the Commons. Its main role is revising: it examines bills in detail and can amend them, and amendments must go back to the Commons. It can also reject a bill, but its power to block is limited by the Parliament Acts.
The Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949
- 1911: a public bill rejected by the Lords could become law if passed by the Commons in three sessions over two years.
- 1949: reduced this to one year and two sessions. It was itself passed using the 1911 procedure.
- Conditions: a public bill that started in the Commons. Bills to extend Parliament beyond five years are excluded. Money bills do not use this route: under section 1 of the 1911 Act, a money bill not passed by the Lords within one month can go for Royal Assent without their consent.
- Acts passed using the procedure as amended in 1949 (Lords Library): War Crimes Act 1991, European Parliamentary Elections Act 1999, Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 2000 and Hunting Act 2004.
- In Jackson v Attorney General (2005) the House of Lords rejected a challenge to the 1949 Act (and so to the Hunting Act).
The Royal Assent Act 1967: an Act is duly made when the monarch's Assent, given by Letters Patent, is notified to each House sitting separately by its Speaker, as an alternative to the traditional ceremony in the House of Lords.
Evaluating the process
| Strengths | Criticisms (June 2025 mark scheme) |
|---|---|
| Democratic: the elected Commons has the final say | Language can be obscure and complex |
| Detailed scrutiny at several stages | Drafting tries to cover every situation, making Acts long |
| Lords' expertise improves bills | Many stages give chances to delay |
| Consultation through Green and White Papers | Law on one topic is spread across several Acts and amended piecemeal |
| Acts are clear authority, superior to judge-made law | MPs often vote on party lines; bills are drafted by civil servants |
A conclusion should weigh whether the process is undemocratic, uncertain, inaccessible or slow, as the mark scheme suggests.
Worked example
Explain the limits on the power of the House of Lords. (6 marks)
- Role: revising chamber; can amend; amendments return to the Commons.
- Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949: can only delay a public Commons bill for about a year.
- Example: Hunting Act 2004; challenge rejected in Jackson (2005).
- Money bills and bills extending Parliament excluded.
Answer: The Lords can amend and delay but not ultimately block most Commons public bills; the Parliament Acts allowed the Hunting Act 2004 to pass without Lords consent.
Check yourself
- Under the Parliament Act 1949, for roughly how long can the Lords delay a public bill that started in the Commons?
- One year (two sessions)
- Two years (three sessions)
- One month
- Indefinitely
Show answer
One year (two sessions). 1949 reduced the delay from two years to one.
- Which Act was passed using the Parliament Acts?
- Human Rights Act 1998
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005
- Hunting Act 2004
- Juries Act 1974
Show answer
Hunting Act 2004. The Hunting Act 2004 was passed without the Lords' consent.
- Which kind of bill cannot be passed using the Parliament Acts?
- A bill to extend the life of Parliament beyond five years
- A criminal justice bill that started in the Commons
- A bill about hunting
- A bill about war crimes
Show answer
A bill to extend the life of Parliament beyond five years. Bills extending Parliament beyond five years are excluded entirely. Money bills have their own one month procedure under section 1 of the 1911 Act.
- In Jackson v Attorney General (2005), the House of Lords
- struck down the Hunting Act 2004
- said the Lords could veto any bill
- abolished the Parliament Act 1911
- rejected a challenge to the validity of the Parliament Act 1949
Show answer
rejected a challenge to the validity of the Parliament Act 1949. The challenge failed, so the Hunting Act stood.
- The main role of the House of Lords in law making is
- electing the Prime Minister
- revising and amending bills
- giving Royal Assent
- drafting all government bills
Show answer
revising and amending bills. It is a revising chamber.
- What did the Royal Assent Act 1967 allow?
- The House of Lords to refuse Royal Assent
- Bills to become law without Royal Assent
- The Prime Minister to give Royal Assent
- Royal Assent to be notified to each House separately by its Speaker
Show answer
Royal Assent to be notified to each House separately by its Speaker. Section 1: Assent signified by Letters Patent can be notified to each House by the Speaker, instead of the ceremony in the Lords.
- Give one criticism of the process by which Acts of Parliament are made.
Show answer
Acts are often written in complex, obscure language, so they are hard for ordinary people to understand and judges have to interpret them.. Criticisms in the June 2025 mark scheme: obscure language, over-detailed drafting, delay, law spread across many Acts, piecemeal amendment, party-line voting, drafting by civil servants.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- House of Lords Library: Parliament Act 1949, reducing the power to delay
- legislation.gov.uk: Parliament Act 1911, section 1 (money bills)
- legislation.gov.uk: Royal Assent Act 1967, section 1
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2025 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson examiners' report: YLA1/01, June 2025
- UK Parliament, MPs' Guide to Procedure: Bill stages
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.