All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)

Influences on law reform: Law Commission, parties, pressure groups, judges and media

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)

Specification point 1.2.2 asks for each influence, with examples of success and its disadvantages. Pearson often asks you to assess two or more influences together.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The Law Commission

An independent law reform body set up in 1965. It researches areas of law, consults and publishes reports with draft bills. Its work includes codification (Pearson's example: offences against the person), consolidation (bringing scattered provisions into one Act, such as the Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act 2000) and repeal of obsolete law.

By 31 March 2026 it had published 262 law reform reports: 171 implemented in whole or part (65%) and 31 rejected (Annual Report 2025-26). Since 2010 a special House of Lords procedure speeds through uncontroversial Law Commission bills; recent examples are the Arbitration Act 2025 and the Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025.

Evaluation (Pearson mark schemes): expert, well researched, independent and non-political, with draft laws attached; but Parliament need not consult it or act on its reports, and investigations can be lengthy.

Political parties and pressure groups

Political parties set out policies in manifestos and, in government, control most parliamentary time. For example, Labour's 1997 manifesto promised a free vote on a complete ban on handguns (Commons Library).

Pressure groups may be insider groups, consulted when bills are drafted, or outsider groups using demonstrations; sectional groups represent members, cause groups promote an issue. After 16 children and their teacher were shot dead at Dunblane on 13 March 1996, the Snowdrop petition, with about 705,000 signatures, was presented to the Commons on 3 July 1996 calling for a ban on private handgun ownership (Hansard). The Firearms (Amendment) Act 1997 prohibited most handguns above .22 calibre, and a 1997-98 bill extended the ban to small-calibre pistols (Commons Library). Pearson also names Fathers4Justice. Disadvantages: groups may represent a minority and be very persuasive for narrow interests.

Judges and the media

Judges can expose problems the courts cannot solve. In Re DWS (Court of Appeal, 2001) the forfeiture rule left an estate passing to a relative rather than the killer's innocent child; the Law Commission found this unfair, reported in 2005, and a bill followed in 2010-11 (Explanatory Notes). *R v R* (1991) shows judges reforming the law themselves.

The media raise awareness through campaigns and coverage of events. Pearson's mark schemes cite the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 as media-driven and criticised as 'knee-jerk' legislation. Disadvantages: media may represent a small section of opinion, and ownership can bring bias.

Worked example

Assess the influence of pressure groups on law making, using one example.

  1. Example: Snowdrop petition after Dunblane, about 705,000 signatures.
  2. Outcome: the Firearms (Amendment) Act 1997 and a further ban in 1997-98.
  3. But: success came alongside a public inquiry, media campaigns and party policy; many campaigns fail.

Answer: Pressure groups can be very effective when public feeling is strong, as with the handgun ban, but their influence usually depends on support from parties, media and government.

Key idea: Law Commission: expert, independent, codify, consolidate, repeal; about 65% of reports implemented. Parties: manifestos. Pressure groups: insider/outsider, sectional/cause (Snowdrop). Judges expose gaps (Re DWS). Media: campaigns, risk of knee-jerk laws (Dangerous Dogs Act 1991).

Check yourself

  1. The Law Commission had published 262 reports, of which 171 were implemented in whole or part. What percentage is that, to the nearest whole number?
    Show answer

    65 %. 171 / 262 x 100 = 65%.

  2. Bringing provisions scattered across several Acts into one Act is called
    • codification
    • repeal
    • delegation
    • consolidation
    Show answer

    consolidation. Pearson's example: Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act 2000.

  3. The Snowdrop petition led to reform of which area of law?
    • Dangerous dogs
    • Handgun ownership
    • Marital rape
    • Hunting
    Show answer

    Handgun ownership. It called for private handgun ownership to be banned after Dunblane.

  4. Which Act is cited in Pearson's mark schemes as an example of media pressure producing 'knee-jerk' law?
    • Arbitration Act 2025
    • Juries Act 1974
    • Dangerous Dogs Act 1991
    • Parliament Act 1949
    Show answer

    Dangerous Dogs Act 1991. Rushed legislation after media campaigns can be poorly drafted.

  5. An insider pressure group is one that
    • is consulted by government when bills are drafted
    • only uses demonstrations and direct action
    • is a political party
    • is part of the judiciary
    Show answer

    is consulted by government when bills are drafted. Insider groups have regular access to policy makers.

  6. Which is a disadvantage of the Law Commission?
    • It has no legal expertise
    • It is controlled by a political party
    • Parliament does not have to act on its reports
    • It cannot produce draft bills
    Show answer

    Parliament does not have to act on its reports. About a third of reports are not implemented, and there is no duty to consult it.

  7. Re DWS (2001) is a good example of which influence on law reform?
    • Judges exposing an unfair rule that led to Law Commission work and a bill
    • A media campaign
    • A pressure group petition
    • A party manifesto promise
    Show answer

    Judges exposing an unfair rule that led to Law Commission work and a bill. The Court of Appeal decision prompted the Law Commission's 2005 report.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.