All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Lay magistrates
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.22 begins with lay magistrates (Justices of the Peace): volunteers who deal with most criminal cases. You need their selection, appointment and role, and their advantages and disadvantages.
Who they are and how they are appointed
There are over 12,000 magistrates in England and Wales. They are unpaid volunteers (loss of earnings can be claimed), need no legal qualifications, and must sit at least 13 days (26 half days) a year for at least five years. Applicants must be 18 to 74; retirement is at 75, and people over 70 are generally not appointed (judiciary.uk).
Application (Magistrates Recruitment): observe court hearings; apply online with two references; pass an online scenario-based qualifying assessment; an interview scored by a local Advisory Committee; checks including a DBS check; then the Senior Presiding Judge approves the appointment on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice. Training includes an introductory programme and a mentor. The specification also names the Justices of the Peace Act 1979, which formerly governed the office.
Their role
Magistrates usually sit as a bench of three, one acting as chair, advised on law and procedure by a qualified legal adviser.
- Criminal: about 95% of criminal cases are completed in magistrates' courts. They try summary offences such as minor assaults, motoring offences, theft and TV licence evasion; decide bail; and sentence, with powers up to 12 months' prison for one offence, fines and community penalties. Serious cases are sent to the Crown Court.
- Youth court: specially trained magistrates hear cases against defendants aged 10 to under 18.
- Family court: children's cases, child arrangements, maintenance and protection from domestic abuse.
Advantages and disadvantages
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Local knowledge | Inconsistent sentencing between benches |
| Volunteers: cheap for the state | Perceived bias towards police and prosecution |
| A bench of three balances views | Not a true cross-section: selection and panel make-up |
| Training and a legal adviser | Influence of the legal adviser or a dominant member |
| Frees the Crown Court for serious cases | Complex cases may be beyond lay people |
From Pearson's Summer 2021 and June 2024 mark schemes.
Worked example
Explain the role of lay magistrates in a summary trial. (plan for 6 marks)
- Pre-trial: bail and adjournments.
- Trial: a bench of three hears evidence and decides guilt by majority or unanimously, advised by the legal adviser on law.
- Sentence: within their powers (up to 12 months for one offence) or commit to the Crown Court.
Answer: A sequence through pre-trial, trial and sentence, with analysis of strengths or weaknesses.
Check yourself
- What is the minimum number of days a year a magistrate must sit?
Show answer
13 days. At least 13 days (26 half days) a year.
- At what age must magistrates retire?
Show answer
75 years. The mandatory retirement age is 75.
- Magistrates usually hear cases
- alone without any adviser
- with a jury of twelve
- as a panel of five Supreme Court Justices
- as a bench of three with a legal adviser
Show answer
as a bench of three with a legal adviser. Three magistrates, one as chair, plus a legal adviser.
- About what proportion of criminal cases are completed in magistrates' courts?
- About 95%
- About 50%
- About 10%
- All serious cases
Show answer
About 95%. judiciary.uk: about 95%.
- Who approves the appointment of a new magistrate on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice?
- The Prime Minister
- The local MP
- The Senior Presiding Judge
- The Crown Prosecution Service
Show answer
The Senior Presiding Judge. After the Advisory Committee recommends.
- What legal qualifications must a magistrate have?
- None
- A law degree
- Five years as a solicitor
- Pupillage
Show answer
None. No legal experience or qualifications are needed.
- Give one disadvantage of using lay magistrates.
Show answer
Sentencing can be inconsistent between different benches, and magistrates may be seen as biased towards the police and prosecution.. Disadvantages: inconsistent sentencing, perceived prosecution bias, unrepresentative benches, reliance on the legal adviser, lack of legal knowledge.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary: Magistrates
- Magistrates Recruitment (judiciary.uk): What is a magistrate?
- Magistrates Recruitment (judiciary.uk): Application process
- GOV.UK: Become a magistrate, what magistrates do
- Judicial Office: The Judicial System of England and Wales, a visitor's guide (March 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson: Paper 1 exemplar answers with examiner commentary, Question 5 (lay people)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.