All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Juries and other lay people in the law
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.22 also covers jurors (including the Juries Act 1974) and lay tribunal members, mediators, conciliators, ombudsmen and arbitrators. Juries have been the subject of full 20 mark questions.
Qualification and selection
To serve, a person must be 18 to 75, registered to vote, and have lived in the UK for at least 5 years since age 13 (GOV.UK). The upper age was raised from 70 to 75 by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015. Disqualified: people on bail; anyone who received a prison, suspended or community sentence in the last 10 years; anyone ever sentenced to 5 years or more; people detained under the Mental Health Act or lacking capacity.
The Jury Central Summoning Bureau selects people at random from the electoral register. Service usually lasts ten working days. Jurors can ask to defer or be excused for good reason. Twelve are sworn in; jurors may be challenged for cause.
Role and verdicts
Juries sit mainly in the Crown Court for serious criminal trials, where they decide the facts and the verdict, guilty or not guilty, after the judge's directions on law and summing up; the judge decides sentence. They deliberate in secret and appoint a foreperson. Civil juries are rare: a party can ask for one in claims such as false imprisonment, malicious prosecution or fraud, and since the Defamation Act 2013 defamation cases are tried without a jury unless the court orders otherwise. The verdict should be unanimous, but under the Juries Act 1974, s17 the judge can accept a majority verdict: 10 of 11 or 12 jurors, or 9 of 10, after at least two hours of deliberation.
Evaluation
| For juries | Against juries |
|---|---|
| Cross-section of the community; trial by peers | Perverse verdicts against the evidence |
| Range of views, backgrounds and ages | Compulsory service: reluctant jurors; burden on employers |
| Twelve people and a high standard of proof protect the defendant | Pressure from inside or outside the jury; media publicity |
| Judicial guidance on law | Complex cases jurors may not understand; cost |
| Public participation in justice | Secrecy: reasons are never given |
From Pearson's Summer 2021, June 2022 and June 2025 mark schemes. Pearson's mark schemes and guide also cite the 1670 trial of the Quaker Penn and R v Ponting (1985), a verdict often described as perverse.
Other lay people
Tribunal members bring specialist expertise to panels alongside a judge. Mediators and conciliators help parties settle; arbitrators decide disputes privately; ombudsmen investigate complaints. Most are experts rather than lawyers, which brings knowledge and lower cost, but raises questions about consistency and legal accuracy. The examiners' report for June 2025 warned candidates not to confuse lay people with expert witnesses or conciliation when asked about criminal trials.
Worked example
A jury of 11 is deliberating. How many must agree for a majority verdict, and when can it be accepted?
- Juries Act 1974, s17: with 11 or more jurors, 10 must agree.
- The jury must have deliberated for at least two hours.
Answer: 10 of the 11, after at least two hours' deliberation.
Check yourself
- Under the Juries Act 1974, how many jurors must agree for a majority verdict when 12 are sitting?
Show answer
10. 10 of 12 (or 11).
- If the jury has fallen to 10 members, how many must agree?
Show answer
9. 9 of 10.
- What is the age range for jury service?
- 18 to 75
- 21 to 65
- 16 to 70
- 18 to 70
Show answer
18 to 75. Raised from 70 to 75 by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015.
- Who is disqualified from jury service?
- A teacher
- A student aged 19
- A person who has never served before
- A person who received a community sentence in the last 10 years
Show answer
A person who received a community sentence in the last 10 years. GOV.UK disqualification rules.
- In a Crown Court trial, the jury decides
- the sentence
- the facts and whether the defendant is guilty
- points of law
- whether the case goes to the Supreme Court
Show answer
the facts and whether the defendant is guilty. The judge directs on law and sentences.
- What is the minimum period of deliberation before a majority verdict can be accepted under the Juries Act 1974?
- Ten minutes
- One week
- Twenty four hours
- Two hours
Show answer
Two hours. At least two hours.
- Explain what a perverse verdict is and why it is a criticism of juries.
Show answer
A perverse verdict is one that goes against the evidence and the judge's direction, for example acquitting out of sympathy, which means the law is not applied correctly.. Juries may acquit against the evidence or the law (examples cited by Pearson: Penn 1670; Ponting); this can undermine the law, though some see it as a safeguard.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- GOV.UK: Jury service, who can be on a jury
- legislation.gov.uk: Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, section 68 (jury age limit raised to 75)
- legislation.gov.uk: Juries Act 1974 (as enacted)
- legislation.gov.uk: Defamation Act 2013, Explanatory Notes to section 11 (trial without a jury)
- Judicial Office: The Judicial System of England and Wales, a visitor's guide (March 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2022 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2025 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson examiners' report: YLA1/01, June 2025
- Pearson: Paper 1 exemplar answers with examiner commentary, Question 5 (lay people)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.