All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
How judges deal with morality: the key cases
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.1.14 asks you to apply case law to show how the courts interpret morality. Pearson's topic guide and mark schemes repeatedly name these cases.
Consent, harm and private conduct
- R v Brown (House of Lords, 1993): men who engaged in consensual sado-masochistic activity were convicted; a person cannot consent to actual bodily harm or worse (GOV.UK factsheet). The majority reflected Devlin; the minority, Mill (topic guide). The European Court of Human Rights upheld the decision in Laskey, Jaggard and Brown v UK (1997): the interference with private life was justified to protect health and morals. The principle was later restated in statute in the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 (the 'rough sex' defence).
- R v Wilson (1996): a husband tattooed his initial on his wife's buttock with her consent; this was not treated as a crime (topic guide), suggesting a Hart-style approach to private matters.
Judges and public morals
- Shaw v DPP [1962] AC 220: publication of a 'Ladies' Directory' of prostitutes' contact details (Law Commission Report No 358). The House of Lords upheld a conviction for conspiracy to corrupt public morals, which the topic guide treats as the judges creating an offence: support for Devlin.
- Knuller v DPP [1973] AC 435: a magazine carried contact advertisements for gay men; charges included conspiracy to outrage public decency. The Law Commission notes such facts would almost certainly not outrage current standards, showing how morality changes.
- R v Gibson [1990] 2 QB 619: an exhibited sculpture used freeze-dried human foetuses as earrings; conviction for outraging public decency upheld.
- R v R (House of Lords, 1991): abolished a husband's immunity from prosecution for raping his wife, because the old rule no longer reflected society's morals (topic guide).
Life and death
- R v Dudley and Stephens (1884): necessity was rejected as a defence to murder (Britannica).
- R v Bourne [1939] 1 KB 687: a gynaecologist ended the pregnancy of a 14 year old who had been raped; the judge directed that a doctor was justified if he believed continuing the pregnancy would make the woman a 'physical or mental wreck' (Hansard, 1966 debate). The uncertainty this left helped lead to the private member's bill that became the Abortion Act 1967.
- Re A (Conjoined Twins) (Court of Appeal, 2000): doctors were allowed to separate twins although the weaker twin would die; the court said it was a court of law, not of morals (topic guide).
- R (Pretty) v DPP [2001] UKHL 61: a woman with motor neurone disease wanted her husband to help her die without risk of prosecution under the Suicide Act 1961. The House of Lords refused; Lord Bingham said the House was not a legislative body and not entitled to act as a moral or ethical arbiter.
Using the cases
Pearson's mark schemes for 20 mark morality questions repeatedly list *R v Brown*, *Shaw v DPP*, *R v R* and the *Gillick* case. Use each case to make a point, not just to tell a story: which theorist does it support, did the court lead or follow public morality, and should judges or Parliament decide such questions?
Worked example
Use Pretty v DPP to answer: should judges decide moral questions?
- Facts: assisted suicide request refused.
- Lord Bingham: the House is not a moral or ethical arbiter; the question is for Parliament.
- Contrast Shaw v DPP, where judges did enforce public morals.
Answer: Pretty suggests judges should leave deep moral questions to Parliament; Shaw shows judges have sometimes enforced morality themselves. A conclusion can argue that elected Parliament is the better forum.
Check yourself
- What principle did R v Brown (1993) establish?
- A person cannot consent to actual bodily harm or worse
- Consensual tattooing is always a crime
- Judges cannot create criminal offences
- Necessity is a defence to murder
Show answer
A person cannot consent to actual bodily harm or worse. Restated in the Domestic Abuse Act 2021.
- Shaw v DPP is often used to show
- Parliament legalising prostitution
- the harm principle being applied
- judges enforcing public morals through the criminal law
- the European Court overruling the House of Lords
Show answer
judges enforcing public morals through the criminal law. The House of Lords upheld conspiracy to corrupt public morals.
- In R (Pretty) v DPP, Lord Bingham said the House of Lords
- was not a legislative body or a moral arbiter
- would legalise assisted suicide
- could overrule the Suicide Act 1961
- was bound by the European Court of Justice
Show answer
was not a legislative body or a moral arbiter. He stressed the court's limited role on deep moral questions.
- R v Gibson concerned
- a tattoo between spouses
- a directory of prostitutes
- a shipwreck
- a sculpture using freeze-dried human foetuses as earrings
Show answer
a sculpture using freeze-dried human foetuses as earrings. Conviction for outraging public decency was upheld.
- What did R v Dudley and Stephens (1884) decide about necessity?
- It is a full defence to murder
- It is not a defence to murder
- It reduces murder to manslaughter
- It applies only at sea
Show answer
It is not a defence to murder. Britannica: the case rejected necessity as a defence to homicide.
- In Laskey, Jaggard and Brown v UK (1997), the European Court of Human Rights
- overturned R v Brown
- said consent is always a defence
- refused to hear the case
- upheld the convictions as justified to protect health and morals
Show answer
upheld the convictions as justified to protect health and morals. The interference with private life under Article 8 was justified.
- Explain how R v R (1991) shows the courts responding to changes in morality.
Show answer
The House of Lords abolished the old rule that a husband could not be guilty of raping his wife, because it no longer reflected society's moral views about marriage and consent.. The topic guide: the old immunity was no longer relevant to society's morals, so the Lords removed it.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- GOV.UK: Domestic Abuse Bill 2020 factsheet, consent to serious harm for sexual gratification not a defence
- Law Commission No 358: Simplification of Criminal Law, Public Nuisance and Outraging Public Decency (2015)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Regina v. Dudley and Stephens
- House of Commons Library Standard Note SN/SES/4309: Abortion law (2009)
- Hansard, House of Commons, 22 July 1966: Medical Termination of Pregnancy Bill, second reading (private member's bill)
- House of Lords: R (Pretty) v DPP [2001] UKHL 61, judgment of 29 November 2001
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.