All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Public and private morality, and how law and morals compare
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.1.13 asks you to define public and private morality and explain how law and morality overlap and differ.
What is morality?
Pearson's topic guide: morals are beliefs, values and standards of behaviour. They come from upbringing, peers, religion and conscience. Compliance is voluntary and enforcement is informal, through disapproval or being shunned, not state penalties.
- Private morality is an individual's own code of conduct, for example a personal view on drinking alcohol.
- Public morality is the set of standards shared widely in a society, for example that killing and theft are wrong, which the law usually reflects.
Similarities and differences
| Similarities | Differences |
|---|---|
| Both set standards of behaviour | Legal rules are made formally and take effect at a precise time; morals develop gradually |
| Both use similar language: 'must', 'should', 'wrong' | Law is compulsory and backed by state sanctions; morals are voluntary and enforced informally |
| They often overlap (murder, theft) | Morals can demand more than law: there is generally no legal duty to rescue a stranger, but many think there is a moral one |
| Laws often rely on underlying moral support to be obeyed | Many moral rules are not law (lying in most situations, adultery) |
Based on Pearson's topic guide and October 2019 mark scheme.
Morality changing law, and law changing morality
The topic guide's essay plan uses examples both ways:
- Morality changing law: changed attitudes led the House of Lords in *R v R* (1991) to abolish a husband's immunity from prosecution for raping his wife; the abortion debate produced the Abortion Act 1967.
- Law changing morality: decriminalising homosexual acts in 1967, and later reforms, helped shift public attitudes.
Pearson's October 2019 mark scheme gives moral rules that are not legal duties: intervening to stop a fight, diving in to rescue an unrelated drowning child, not committing adultery.
Worked example
Is lying always against the law? Use the difference between law and morality.
- Most people think lying is morally wrong.
- The law only intervenes in some situations, for example fraud or perjury.
Answer: No. Lying is generally a moral wrong only; the law intervenes where it causes particular harm, such as fraud or lying on oath. This shows law and morality overlap but are not the same.
Check yourself
- Which is a moral rule but not a legal duty, according to Pearson's October 2019 mark scheme?
- Not stealing from a shop
- Driving on the left
- Paying income tax
- Diving in to rescue an unrelated drowning child
Show answer
Diving in to rescue an unrelated drowning child. There is generally no legal duty to rescue a stranger.
- How are moral rules usually enforced?
- By the Crown Prosecution Service
- Informally, through disapproval or being shunned
- By the civil courts awarding damages
- By Parliament
Show answer
Informally, through disapproval or being shunned. Moral rules carry social, not state, sanctions.
- A person's personal belief that they should never gamble is an example of
- public morality enforced by statute
- a legal duty
- a secondary rule
- private morality
Show answer
private morality. It is an individual code of conduct.
- Which is the clearest example of law and morality overlapping?
- Murder is a crime and widely seen as morally wrong
- Speed limits on motorways
- The deadline for filing a tax return
- Rules on the colour of number plates
Show answer
Murder is a crime and widely seen as morally wrong. Most regulatory rules have little moral content; murder is both a crime and a moral wrong.
- According to the topic guide, why did the House of Lords in R v R (1991) abolish the marital rape immunity?
- Parliament had passed an Act ordering it
- The European Court of Justice required it
- The old rule no longer reflected society's morals
- The defendant consented
Show answer
The old rule no longer reflected society's morals. The guide says the old rule was no longer relevant to society's morals.
- Explain two differences between legal rules and moral rules.
Show answer
Legal rules are compulsory and enforced by the state with sanctions, while moral rules are voluntary and enforced informally by disapproval; laws are made formally at a fixed time, morals develop gradually.. Differences: source (formal process v upbringing, religion, conscience), enforcement (state sanctions v social disapproval), compulsion (compulsory v voluntary), timing (precise v gradual), scope.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.